Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×
  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.




  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):



    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):


  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate
  • Record is Archived

    This article is now archived and is closed to further replies.

    Dr. Ron Hoggan, Ed.D.
    Dr. Ron Hoggan, Ed.D.

    Expert Opinions Misguided and Misinterpreted

    Reviewed and edited by a celiac disease expert.
    Expert Opinions Misguided and Misinterpreted - Photo: CC - opensourceway
    Caption: Photo: CC - opensourceway

    Celiac.com 03/06/2012 - I was disappointed to read the opinion article by   Dr. Di Sabatino and Dr. Corazza  published in February 2012 by Annals of Internal Medicine (1).  The article itself is mostly  reasonable and thoughtful. However,  they implicitly assert gluten to be a healthy food by stating that they wish to prevent "a gluten preoccupation from evolving into the conviction that gluten is toxic for most of the population" (1).  In that single statement they are making dietary recommendations in the absence of evidence; the very situation they claim to want to rectify.

    Photo: CC - opensourcewayTheir published opinion has spawned a number of articles online and in the popular press which  seem to ignore all of the concessions to non-celiac gluten sensitivity in the source article. Some of these spin-off commentaries even use the original article to support their suggestions that a gluten free diet is inappropriate even for those with symptoms that are relieved by the diet. This definitely contravenes the opinions expressed by Di Sabatino and Corazza.  For instance, one of them states "That hasn’t stopped many people from declaring they are gluten sensitive, even though they may not be." (2)

    Celiac.com Sponsor (A12):
    Please take a moment to consider this proposition. The gluten free diet is restrictive, inconvenient, and expensive. Why would anyone continue to follow such a diet without being convinced that it was valuable to them?  Di Sabatino and Corazzo freely acknowledge that there is a dearth of diagnostic tests and protocols for non-celiac gluten sensitivity.  

    Doctors  Di Sabatino and Corazza  not only acknowledge non-celiac gluten sensitivity as a cause for symptoms very similar to those of celiac disease, they  call for further research to develop and codify diagnostic protocols that will help clinicians better recognize and treat this newly recognized ailment. They go on to acknowledge that conditions including "headache, lethargy, attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, ataxia, or recurrent oral ulceration" in the absence of celiac disease often improve or resolve on a gluten free diet.  Their unfortunate denial of gluten as toxic seems to have invited much of the spin-off conjecture under such titles as "Gluten-free diets not always necessary, study suggests" (3).   Even the characterization of this opinion article as a study is misleading in the extreme.       

    Di Sabatino and Corazza focus mostly on gastrointestinal symptoms when discussing non-celiac gluten sensitivity.  It is clear that their focus does not extend far beyond such symptoms. What is also clear is that many cases of non-celiac gluten sensitivity, just like celiac disease, manifest with a wide range of signs and symptoms including neurological illnesses. Dr. Marios Hadjivassiliou, chief neurologist at the Royal Hallamshire Hospital in Sheffield, U.K. has repeatedly demonstrated that a majority of his patients with neurological disease of unknown origin show evidence of gluten sensitivity, the majority of whom do not have celiac disease (4). 
    My disappointment stems not so much from doctors Di Sabatini and Corazza's article and their assertion that gluten grains are not toxic to the general population, as from the spin-off claims that the gluten free diet is being excessively followed  in the belief that it is more healthful.  A rapidly growing body of evidence is showing  that increasing numbers of ailments among increasing numbers of people are driven by this ubiquitous food.  Gluten may well be toxic for most of the population. We don't know.  We can't know that without more research. 

    The growing numbers of people who are willing to accept the inconvenience and expense of a gluten free diet because of the benefits they experience should be considered.  Gluten may be toxic to many more people than are currently identifiable by available testing. Asserting one side or the other of this argument is at least premature. At most it could prove very harmful to those individuals who listen and obey the voices of experts, even when they err and when relayed inaccurately by the media.  

    For a more detailed account of this controversy please see the spring 2012 issue of the Open Original Shared Link.

    Sources:

    1. Di Sabatino A, Corazza G. Nonceliac Gluten Sensitivity: Sense or Sensibility? Ann Intern Med. 2012;156:309-311.
    2. Open Original Shared Link
    3. Open Original Shared Link
    4. Hadjivassiliou M, Gibson A, Davies-Jones GA, Lobo AJ, Stephenson TJ, Milford-Ward A. Does cryptic gluten sensitivity play a part in neurological illness? Lancet. 1996 Feb 10;347(8998):369-71.



    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    Guest J.C. West

    Posted

    The doctors involved obviously represent "special interests" and would pimp gluten or anything else that would generate "rewards" in some form. Medicine's veracity in egregiously undependable, unreliable and often downright dishonest. In medical school class I was associated with rampant cheating with basic science courses was normative which accounts for vacuous opinions they generate.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites


    Guest
    This is now closed for further comments

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Celiac.com:
    Donate
  • About Me

    Dr. Ron Hoggan, Ed.D.

    As co-author of "Dangerous Grains" and "Cereal Killers", the study of the impact of gluten continues to be a driving passion in my life. I am fascinated by the way that gluten induces illness and impedes learning while it alters mood, behavior, and a host of other facets of our existence. Sure, the impact of gluten on health is an important issue, but that is only the most obvious area of impact. Mood disturbances, learning disabilities, and the loss of quality of life due to psychiatric and neurological illness are even more tragic than the plethora of physical ailments that are caused or worsened by gluten. The further I go down this rabbit hole, the more I realize that grains are a good food for ruminants - not people. I am a retired school teacher. Over the last decade, I have done some college and university level teaching, but the bulk of my teaching career was spent working with high school students.


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):





    Celiac.com Sponsors (A17-M):




  • Related Articles

    Scott Adams
    Celiac.com 07/31/2006 - The National Institutes of Health (NIH) today announced the launch of a campaign to heighten awareness of celiac disease, an autoimmune disorder that interferes with the absorption of nutrients from food. The campaign stems from consensus recommendations of an independent panel of experts convened by the NIH to assess current diagnosis, treatment, and management of the disease.
    “We now know that celiac disease is more prevalent that previously thought — affecting nearly 1 percent of the U.S. population — and remains under-diagnosed,” said Griffin P. Rodgers, M.D., acting director of the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases (NIDDK), the NIH institute leading the effort. “Through the campaign, we hope to increase physician...


    Rebecca  Herman
    Transparency Revealed in World of Distilled Spirits - Freeport, Maine
    Celiac.com 06/27/2011 - In order to protect the propriety of their products, distilleries can be reluctant to disclose process details. Yet their disclosure is crucial for those of us who are unable to consume gluten.  Recently, I investigated a potato vodka and gin distillery in Freeport, Maine where this is not the case.
    Don Thibodeau, president of Green Thumb Farms, launched Maine Distilleries in 2004 with his brother, Lee Thibodeau, and managing partners, Bob Harkins, director of sales and marketing, and Chris Dowe, head distiller.  Maine Distilleries is dedicated to the production of three spirits that are sold under its Cold River label.
    Green Thumb Farms, a 2,000-acre family-owned farm located in Fryeburg, Maine, produces potatoes, beans, and corn in the alluvial soils of t...


    Jefferson Adams
    Celiac.com 11/04/2011 - For many folks, fall means changing leaves, crisp weather, football, and beer. Or just crisp weather and beer. Fortunately, for those with gluten sensitivities, the explosion of diagnoses for celiac disease and gluten-intolerance has given rise to an explosion of gluten-free products, including a number of gluten-free beers.
    "People are becoming more knowledgeable of the symptoms in which gluten can cause on one's health," said New Planet Beer Marketing Director Danielle Quatrochi, "so people are being diagnosed sooner and more often than before. There's also been a lot of press around the benefits of a gluten-free diet, opening the door for companies to add gluten-free options to their product mix."
    Gluten-free beers have often lacked depth compared to their...


    Jefferson Adams
    Celiac.com 01/13/2012 - In an event that was part local apple festival, part celiac disease awareness promotion, and one-hundred percent record-breaking bake-off, a team of community members in Buenos Aires has baked the world's longest apple tart. One third of the 984-foot tart was made gluten-free to promote celiac disease awareness.
    Enthusiastic volunteers removed sections of the tart from numerous bakery trucks parked along Rivadavia Avenue, the world's longest avenue.
    They then assembled them end to end, making sure to keep the gluten-free portions carefully separated from the rest of the tart.
    This is the third year in a row that the tart-baking group, which is based in from Cinco Saltos, Argentina, has organized the tart bake-off.
    Another goal of the event, say event...


  • Recent Activity

    1. - knitty kitty replied to Louise Broughton's topic in Post Diagnosis, Recovery & Treatment of Celiac Disease
      4

      Louise

    2. - knitty kitty replied to Blue Roan's topic in Related Issues & Disorders
      1

      Lymph nodes in neck + thyroid issues

    3. - cristiana replied to MeghanEileenReilly's topic in Post Diagnosis, Recovery & Treatment of Celiac Disease
      47

      Severe Itching And No Rash

    4. - knitty kitty replied to MeghanEileenReilly's topic in Post Diagnosis, Recovery & Treatment of Celiac Disease
      47

      Severe Itching And No Rash

    5. - SoBannaz replied to MeghanEileenReilly's topic in Post Diagnosis, Recovery & Treatment of Celiac Disease
      47

      Severe Itching And No Rash


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):



  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      125,665
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748

    MomofGF
    Newest Member
    MomofGF
    Joined

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):


  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      120.8k
    • Total Posts
      1m

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):





  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):



  • Popular Now

    • Louise Broughton
      4
    • sh00148
      19
    • pasqualeb
      9
    • Jean Shifrin
  • Popular Articles

    • Scott Adams
    • Scott Adams
    • Scott Adams
    • Scott Adams
    • Scott Adams
  • Upcoming Events

×
×
  • Create New...