Jump to content

  • You are not alone. Join Celiac.com for trusted gluten-free answers and forum support.



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

Discouraged By My Dr.

CanadianK

Recommended Posts

CanadianK Apprentice
CanadianK
Posted

In June I went to a Naturopath for all my gut/mental health issues and she ran a celiac test. The DGP IgA came back as almost positive. In the "normal" range, but where .9 was the positive, mine was .8. I had been gluten light for 2 years.

 

So I decided I wanted definite answers. Went to my GP, got into a GI Specialist, and started the ball rolling. Colonoscopy done, as well as blood work for lactose intolerence. She recommended the celiac test (before I even mentioned that I wanted one) and she advised me doing a 10 week gluten challenge. I wanted answers so I did it.

 

10 weeks of feeling awful, more fights with my husband than we'd had in years, bloating, D, pain, joint pain, debilitating migraines... I'm sure you all know what I'm talking about. And during that time I read a TON about celiac. Visited these forums, learned, listened to podcasts and got myself up to speed about everything.

 

Before the endoscopy I checked with the Dr. that the celiac panel she'd ordered for me to do after the endoscopy included all the tests this forum suggested. TTG IgA/IgG, DGP IgA/IgG, EMA, (the total serum had been done before and was within range). I requested 6-8 biopsies. She complied and said YES to everything, and assured me all my requests would be met... I felt so good and validated with her...

 

Today I finally got my results and it turns out she only took 3 biopsies, and the blood work "Celiac Panel" she requested only tested my TTG IgA and DGP IgG!!! Both came back negative. I really wanted to see if my DGP IgA level went up since that one was so close to being positive gluten light...

 

I am feeling so annoyed/betrayed/hopeless... I've now been off gluten (and dairy, grains and eggs) for 5 weeks now (since I thought I had allll my bases covered). I am 10 times better and I was really looking forward to having some closure with this. It's been years and years of not being well...

 

I just feel a total sense of powerlessness in this. I advocated for myself so clearly and felt so proud of myself for finally putting forward my demands but the Dr had another agenda and didn't honour my requests for MY body.

 

Argh.

 

I won't do another gluten challenge. I just wanted some answers. Even if they were positive or negative. But I feel now that things weren't done properly I'm right back to where I started before I took on the gluten challenge. It feels like all that pain and mental health disruption was for nothing.

 

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


BlessedMommy Rising Star
BlessedMommy
Posted

Welcome to the club! We should have a sub forum here called "Strictly Gluten free Without a Diagnosis." LOL!

 

I won't do a gluten challenge ever again, because the neurological implications are too scary, so I live a celiac lifestyle and am getting to the point where I'm fairly comfortable with that.

 

I wish that it had been possible to get a DX, but you know what, I feel 100x better off of gluten. Some of my gluten issues were very obvious (severe skin rash) and most people who remember that, can understand why I care about being strict. Those who don't remember that, will usually know about the TIA I had from the headaches while on gluten. I knew 100% that after having the TIA, I would never go back to gluten despite what any lab tests told me. Positive, negative, inconclusive, it wouldn't really matter. So I'm happy and healthy and at the end of the day, that's more important than a diagnosis.

 

Most of the time an adult can get by without a diagnosis. I've been in the hospital since going gluten free (had to go with my son to the children's hospital for a femur fracture) and they happily let us eat off their wonderful gluten free menu, no requirement to be celiac to eat from it.

 

And your gluten challenge wasn't for nothing! Now that you have gone through it, you know firsthand what gluten does to you and can be motivated to be strict in your diet.

 

Hang in there! Everything will be fine. 

nvsmom Community Regular
nvsmom
Posted

Ugh.   :angry: How frustrating for you!  You did everything right and they messed it up.  Sigh.  You could always request the DGP IgA form you other doctor and compare it to your earlier one.  Sometimes tests can linger high for a while, although the DGP tests are often some of the first to come down.  :(

 

Well, I guess you can tell people that you had celiac tests done and you need to eat gluten-free... it's all true, right?  ;)

 

Best wishes.

bartfull Rising Star
bartfull
Posted

I would have a talk with the doctor though and tell her what you told us. Tell her you feel betrayed and lied to. Then tell her she's fired.

Serielda Enthusiast
Serielda
Posted

CanadianK, getting diagnosed is tricky tricky trust me. Since my mid 20's I was plauged by illness that seemed centered around food, that sometimes left effects that out of fear made me high tail it to the Dr. to be told its' the flu or food poisioning but the older I got I sensed things was a bit more complex than that. I had a Dr give me a test trying to figure out what was causing me so much pain and it came back negatory. A few yrs later another Dr. who I went to  as my old one retired gave a test guess what negatory. Finally  after moving to another city and finding a celiac savvy healthcare system I finally got my answer to what was wrong. I agree that horrid challenge is brutal and I know way to well. My advice honestly and I am not a Dr. but if it is mkaing you ill cut it out, I liken things to a burner, your not gonna keep sticking a your hand on a raging hot burner over and over right, so why keep eating that horrible crap aka gluten and feeling horrid. And like Bartful said if they won't listen can their tush if  you feel they are not listening or doing you right all patients have rights.

nvsmom Community Regular
nvsmom
Posted

I would have a talk with the doctor though and tell her what you told us. Tell her you feel betrayed and lied to. Then tell her she's fired.

 

Up here it's a bit harder to fire doctors. It can be done but then you have to get another referral  and start at the back of the line. To this date I have never been to a GI specialist; the wait for celiac disease  issues was one year in my city of over a million, so I skipped it entirely... Of course, since you are not going back on gluten to do more testing you can fire her and not worry too much.  ;)

BlessedMommy Rising Star
BlessedMommy
Posted

Wow, 1 year? So they expect an ill person to keep on eating gluten for an additional year in order to get an endoscopy? That's crazy!

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


SMRI Collaborator
SMRI
Posted

Up here it's a bit harder to fire doctors. It can be done but then you have to get another referral  and start at the back of the line. To this date I have never been to a GI specialist; the wait for celiac disease  issues was one year in my city of over a million, so I skipped it entirely... Of course, since you are not going back on gluten to do more testing you can fire her and not worry too much.   ;)

 

That is just crazy...glad I can just call and get an appointment when I need one!!

1desperateladysaved Proficient
1desperateladysaved
Posted

You might ask if the lab has enough of your blood samples in store to run some more tests for celiac.  My lab keeps draws for about 6 months and one can request more tests.  I hope that will help!

 

Your other test (reactions to gluten free) sounds really positive!

 

Dee

frieze Community Regular
frieze
Posted

since she out and out lied to you, isn't there a medical society/board that you could report her to?

dania Explorer
dania
Posted

CanadianK - do you know if it was your doctor that didn't put the tests on the form even though she said she would, or maybe it was the lab that just didn't do them? I'm in Canada (BC) and the lab won't do certain celiac tests and also has certain rules about what can be ordered together. My doctor was super willing to order any celiac tests I wanted and I had a copy of the requisition form so I know that both the DGP IgA and DGP IgG were on it, yet the lab would only do DGP IgG so that's the only one I got back on my results. Same with TTG - the lab would only do the IgA and not the IgG.

 

My lab also will only run the total serum IgA if it's ordered by itself; if it's ordered with TTG or other celiac tests, they won't run it (I have absolutely no idea why).

 

Have you talked to your doctor since you got your results? Maybe it's something the lab did.

CanadianK Apprentice
CanadianK
Posted
  • Author

Thanks for all your replies. It's been a topsy turvy week as I dealt with this disappointment, but I've come out the other side and I'm feeling ok with it all. Ultimately I know what I need to do. I realized I was also feeling challenged by certain family members doubting me and I just wanted proof/dr's approval to show this one person… I think I need to work through some "stuff" !! lol! 

 

I have lymphocytic colitis and I'm lactose intolerant which this GI found and diagnosed (so it wasn't ALL for nothing). The diet for LC is to stop grains, dairy, casein, etc. so I've been doing that and feeling tons better. The "gluten migraine" I get is flaring up less which means I'm avoiding even small amounts so I'll just keep trekking on. A

 

I have an appt this week with the GI. I'm going to ask her where things went wrong.

 

@Dania You might be right that it's the lab… I had researched which labs run which tests and chose accordingly. But from what you described and the tests your lab ran it sounds very similar to the results I received. It's times like these that I wish we had more power and transparency in our medical system. 

 

 

 

CanadianK - do you know if it was your doctor that didn't put the tests on the form even though she said she would, or maybe it was the lab that just didn't do them? I'm in Canada (BC) and the lab won't do certain celiac tests and also has certain rules about what can be ordered together. My doctor was super willing to order any celiac tests I wanted and I had a copy of the requisition form so I know that both the DGP IgA and DGP IgG were on it, yet the lab would only do DGP IgG so that's the only one I got back on my results. Same with TTG - the lab would only do the IgA and not the IgG.

 

My lab also will only run the total serum IgA if it's ordered by itself; if it's ordered with TTG or other celiac tests, they won't run it (I have absolutely no idea why).

 

Have you talked to your doctor since you got your results? Maybe it's something the lab di

SMRI Collaborator
SMRI
Posted

I don't know why you put up with care like that.  You pay through the nose in taxes for that medical care!!!

nvsmom Community Regular
nvsmom
Posted

I don't know why you put up with care like that.  You pay through the nose in taxes for that medical care!!!

In my province we have to put up with it because there are no options unless we travel out of province or country and pay for it ourselves... or are paying for extra insurance that will cover some of it.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Celiac.com:
    Donate
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):



    Celiac.com Sponsors (A17-M):



  • Recent Activity

    1. knitty kitty
      - knitty kitty commented on Scott Adams's article in Diagnosis, Testing & Treatment
      6

      New Study Links Gut Bacteria and Fiber to Faster Healing in Celiac Disease (+Video)

      I'm not a big fan of inulin in chicory root. I found it a bit rough on my digestive system. Lots of toots, like @trents mentioned. Members of the alum family (onions, leeks, garlic) were studied for the thiamine forms they contain which led to Benfotiamine and Thiamine TTFD, but there's limitations to the amount of garlic one can eat. Those sulfur...
    2. trents
      - trents commented on Scott Adams's article in Diagnosis, Testing & Treatment
      6

      New Study Links Gut Bacteria and Fiber to Faster Healing in Celiac Disease (+Video)

      @Jo Woodard, Scott Adamas amended the article to specify that it was inulin. That info was in the original study article but not in the synopsis of it as originally posted in this forum. Read his post, the one immediately above yours.
    3. knitty kitty
      0

      Cocoa Powder and SCFAs

    4. suek54
      - suek54 replied to Ginger38's topic in Coping with Celiac Disease
      3

      The Struggle Has Overtaken Me

      Hi Ginger38, Huge sympathies, so very hard to do alone. Are there any groups locally where you could meet others face to face to share your struggles and to encourage each other with diet? I'm a foodie too and love baking. I found it very hard facing the fact that I could never again eat homemade bread still warm from the oven or cakes or pastry...
    5. Khastiana
      - Khastiana replied to Ginger38's topic in Coping with Celiac Disease
      3

      The Struggle Has Overtaken Me

      I never felt that it was hard, gluten feels like a rock in my stomach and everyone else's. Gluten free is probably not good enough. You need to be grain-free because we do cross react the other proteins- how lovely. Quinoa is 99% similar to the protein in gluten. Period cramps cease on a grain free diet. You can try Pamela's Baking mix, it...
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      134,165
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      10,442
    kmmwlton32
    Newest Member
    kmmwlton32
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.7k
    • Total Posts
      1m
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):

  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • suek54
      The Struggle Has Overtaken Me

      By suek54 · Posted

      Hi Ginger38,  Huge sympathies, so very hard to do alone. Are there any groups locally where you could meet others face to face to share your struggles and to encourage each other with diet? I'm a foodie too and love baking. I found it very hard facing the fact that I could never again eat homemade bread still warm from the oven or cakes or pastry. I tried a few gluten free recipes but they were pretty miserable by comparison and I gave up. Lately however I have gone back to it and am finding a few recipes which are pretty good to eat and enjoyable to make. . (For what its worth, I  think the secret is finding a good general purpose gluten free flour and embracing the use of xanthem gum) If you can find just one gluten free receipe you can make and enjoy, it might just help you break out of the struggle you are in?  Sometimes though, you simply have to ask for help to get you through the tough times...a friend, a neighbour, a doctor, a work colleague? I hope you find someone to help. Sue
    • Khastiana
      The Struggle Has Overtaken Me

      By Khastiana · Posted

      I never felt that it was hard, gluten feels like a rock in my stomach and everyone else's.    Gluten free is probably not good enough. You need to be grain-free because we do cross react  the other proteins- how lovely. Quinoa is 99% similar to the protein in gluten. Period cramps cease on a grain free diet.  You can try Pamela's Baking mix, it really is GOOD and has almond flour in it. Whole Foods has Italian made, gluten pasta. I am 100% certain I react to most grain based on my brain function when I eat any grain.  You can safely have white rice and tapioca, I make pizza and bread rolls like Red Lobster from that combo. If you really want to know what is safe for you, you can use Dr Vojani's lab in Phoenix. Cyrex Labs. I think you need a celiac partner who is already gluten free to help you. Every time you cheat you are setting your immune system up for a six-month attack. 
    • trents
      Dermatitis Herpetiformis - follow up dermatology appointment coming up

      By trents · Posted

      @BelleDeJour, why did the dermatologist not take a punch biopsy to confirm or eliminate dermatitis herpetiformis? Were you not in an active outbreak stage?
    • Prom363
      The Struggle Has Overtaken Me

      By Prom363 · Posted

      I know it's really hard to be gluten free. When I first started out, IT WAS SO HARD. I eventually had to start telling myself that I was "allergic". Even though I'm not, gluten affects my body negatively. If you're allergic, you stay completely away. I always have my "safe" foods. Options that I always know where I can eat or what I can make that are easy and delicious. If I don't plan ahead, that's when I'm super tempted to go off track. Texas roadhouse rolls used to ALWAYS make me chance it and then they would make me so sick. I eventually had to tell myself, you are allergic. That is something you cannot have. It really helped me. I hope this helps! Have you ever tried baking with almond flour? It may take some trial and error but I've had some great muffins and banana bread from almond flour that may help with your blood sugar. 
    • Ginger38
      The Struggle Has Overtaken Me

      By Ginger38 · Posted

      I don't know how to even begin this or what topic to post this under, so feel free to move it if need be, but I just need a place where I can be honest and I need to vent to people who can relate and who can hopefully inspire me to get back on the right track with my life. This whole gluten / celiac/ testing etc has been nothing but an uphill battle and struggle for me since it began. When I went gluten free years back, it was the hardest thing I ever did, and I did it on my own without much help or guidance aside from this group. I am a foodie and a carb lover and a baker and having to give up so many foods that brought me so much happiness was so incredibly hard for me, but I eventually did it. Even when people encouraged me to have just a little or cheat here and there I didn't give in.  I have since developed uncontrolled diabetes which has complicated all this to say the very least, because none of the breads, flours or replacement foods, that actually taste semi good are diabetic friendly (at least not for me). So I have struggled with eating gluten off and on in the form of crackers and breads and low carb keto foods, even though I know I shouldn't. I do good for a while and then I completely lose control again and somehow justify it in my mind.  Inevitably because of my struggles, I was really concerned about going back on gluten (full time) for the gluten challenge, I mean it gave me an excuse to party hard, and be miserable while doing so, but I was afraid once I did that challenge for 8-10 weeks that I would never be able to give the gluten back up again. And that is exactly where I am sitting at as we speak. It has been an on again off again roller coaster ride of no gluten, gluten, little gluten, no gluten, lots of gluten etc.  I go from buying small loaves of bread and keto tortillas and buns to whole wheat buns and pasta - justifying it somewhat because it is better for my blood sugar issues and that is what is most important. I binge eat some of the foods and then I feel horribly guilty for eating it and then I end up throwing all the gluten food away in a desperate attempt to stop the madness. Then I restart the process all over again at some point.  My joints ache. My stomach is constantly sour. I walk around like I have terrible arthritis or something. My hands are swelling terribly, sometimes I can't even make a fist. I am experiencing numbness and tingling in my hands and weird things with numbness and tightness in my face as well. I am dropping things constantly. I am forgetting lots of things and struggle to recall things. I can't focus on my work. I am having nightmares. I am wanting to sleep all the time. I am bloated and sometimes have diarrhea and nausea, but then other times I am horribly constipated. My  post herpetic neuralgia issues from shingles are much worse now and overall I am just so irritable and angry and emotionally numb.   I know for some it is a simple choice, but I can't be alone in this struggle. Thanks for letting me getting all this out there. I hope someone can scare or encourage some sense into me. It is kind of insane what I do to myself. And I am just tired of dealing with all the food issues and health issues   
×
×
  • Create New...