Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×
  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.




  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):



    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):


  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Positive Biopsies, Negative Serology - ?


murphy203

Recommended Posts

murphy203 Rookie

Good morning,

 

I had an endoscopy recently for unexplained, severe anemia, and the biopsies are "definitely concerning" for celiac disease.  I don't have Marsh scores yet, and my followup appointment isn't for another week.  My followup TTG and EMA results were negative, with no total IGA deficiency.  Still waiting for HLA results -- how long do these normally take?

 

I have Hashimotos (since my teens), and my son has type 1 diabetes. 

 

Should I just throw in the towel and start eating gluten-free???

 

I am slightly freaked out...


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



nvsmom Community Regular

Welcome to the board.  :)

 

The tTG IgA is not a perfect test. When positive, it is 95% specific to celiac disease but its sensitivity can be as low as 75% (it can miss up to 25% of celiacs).  The EMA IgA is very similar to the tTG IgA test except that it is positive when the damage becomes more advanced.  It is quite unusual to have a positive EMA IgA when the tTG IgA is negative - I've only seen that twoor so times in the three years I have been on this board.  I would expect a negative EMA IgA if the tTG IgA was negative.

 

Perhaps look into getting the other celiac disease tests done?  Some celiacs are positive only in the DGP tests, others only in the IgG based tests even if they have normal IgA levels. Doing more tests may give you a better clue if your abnormal biopsy results were indeed caused by celiac disease.

 

Request these tests:

  • tTG IgG (tissue transglutaminase)
  • DGP IgA and DGP IgG (deaminated gliadin peptides)
  • AGA IgG and AGA IgG (anti-gliadin antibodies) - older and less reliable tests largely replaced by the DGP tests
  • total serum IgG - might be good to check ut is most likely normal

 

This article discusses testing from pages 7-13: Open Original Shared Link

 

You need to be eating gluten (1/2 slice to 2 slices of bread per day) in the 8-12 weeks prior to the tests being done.  Don't go gluten-free unless you are satisfied that testing is complete.

 

That being said, there is a VERY strong link between celiac disease and thyroiditis, and an even stronger one with diabetes (T1).  Since you have a positive biopsy, Hashimoto's, and anemia (now thought to be one of the most common celiac disease symptoms), I would assume you have celiac disease that happens to be serologically negative.  It is not the norm, but it is FAR from rare; there are many people around here in the same boat as you, or with a negative biopsy but positive tests..  It happens.

 

As for the HLA testing, that just tells you if you are part of the 30% of the world who has the genes (DQ2 or DQ8)  that most celiacs have.  A positive just means that you are in the higher risk group; your chances of getting celiac disease would be closer 1 in 30 (or 1 in 40)  rather than the 1 in 133 of the world's population. It won't tell you if you have celiac disease.  In fact, a very small minority (~3%) of celiacs do not even have those genes so a negative result does not absolutely mean you can't develop celiac disease.

 

Besides, with a history of Hashi's, and a son with diabetes, you most likely have the genes.  :(  BTW, those with diabetes are at a much higher risk of developing celiac disease sometime in their life; I think the risk is close to 1 in 10.  If your son is eating any gluten at all, he should be checked (with all the blood tests) every two years or as soon as any symptoms present themselves.... Any other children should be checked too because you (most likely) have celiac disease; their risk of developing is somewhere between 1 in 10 and 1 in 22.

 

I'm afraid I don't know how long those tests take to do. I did not have them done.

 

I've babbled.... My advice would be to finish getting the blood tests for celiac disease.  If any of those, or the biopsy, comes back positive then assume you have celiac disease and go gluten-free. Get the kids tested too.  Going gluten-free is tough for the first few months but it gets easier once you know your brands and what is safe.  

 

It's almost like shopping in a new, large grocery store. At first it is a pain and you don't know where anything is but as time goes by, you eventually learn your way around.

 

Best wishes.

nvsmom Community Regular

Oops. I forgot to mention that getting nutrient levels checked is a good idea for celiacs.  We are often low in: B12, D, A, K, Mg, Ca, Cu, Fe, Zn, and ferritin.

cyclinglady Grand Master

Everything that NVSMOM said! I am one of those who had the complete celiac disease panel and had only one DPG test positive. Looks like you did not get that one! My biopsy showed a Marsh stage IIIB. I also have Hashi's (almost 20 years). Anemia was my only symptom too. Just went in for a routine colonoscopy and my GI guessed celiac disease based on my history of anemia and that I was four months into menopause.

murphy203 Rookie

Thanks for the information.  My doctors are heading to a dx of celiac unless the genetic tests come back negative.  Neither suggested the DGP tests, I'll ask for them for a lab referral for that and the nutrients.  Pretty soon I will know the lab techs by name, LOL.  I already know my ferritin level -- it is so low (3) that I will need a blood transfusion/infusion (can't remember what she said) next week unless it improves.  I have been taking iron supplements for a few weeks now. 

 

My son had an annual physical a few days ago and asked for the celiac panel all by himself -- go, kiddo!!  He actually used to see Dr. Fasano back in the day when he was a pediatric gastro at a nearby hospital -- son was equivocally positive with his blood tests but his biopsies were negative.  No recommendations to go gluten-free at that time, and we never re-tested for some reason.  He's 22 now -- it was probably about 6-8 years ago that he was tested.

 

Family is super-supportive, dinners will be gluten-free and I have claimed a "clean" area of the kitchen for my purposes.  I am lucky that kids are older, for sure!  Most recent trip to grocery store was a little emotional -- its overwhelming to think about really being perfectly gluten-free.  Its good to read posts from people that have learned the ropes and are no longer fazed by the eating regimen << hope that it is me one day.

 

Or maybe the genetic tests will be negative?  Ha, hope springs eternal!

cyclinglady Grand Master

My ferritin (iron stores) was a 2. I refused the transfusion even when my hemoglobin was at my lowest (7) and that is the number to be concerned about! Taking iron and going gluten-free improved my hemoglobin level fast and the iron stores continued to build for six months. That is when I stopped supplementation. Take that iron with Orange juice for better absorption. Old fashioned molasses is chock full of iron too. Of course, I do not know your situation, so do your research.

It is nice not to be out of breath anymore!

murphy203 Rookie

It is nice not to be out of breath anymore!

 

YES!!!  This is exactly what drove me to see my doctor a few weeks ago.  Afterwards, I realized that I have every single symptom listed on Mayo's website for anemia.  I can't wait to feel better. My doctor did warn me that iron infusions are dangerous, which is why we are trying supplementation first.  My hemoglobin was "soaring" along at 8.4.  I don't feel like I am going to keel over half the time anymore, so maybe my anemia is improving.  I just want to have the energy to hop back on MY bike, cyclinglady -- that, and stay up past 7!!


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



cyclinglady Grand Master

My anemia (iron-deficient) resolved in less than six months on a gluten-free. You will be fine! Keep eating gluten until all testing is complete though!

nvsmom Community Regular

I hope the DGP tests give you a clear result, but remember, some celiacs are negative in blood work with positive biopsies and others may have positive blood work but a negative biopsy.  It is usually (although not always) best to assume one has celiac disease if they have a positive celiac disease test of any kind, including biopsy.

 

My son had an annual physical a few days ago and asked for the celiac panel all by himself -- go, kiddo!!  He actually used to see Dr. Fasano back in the day when he was a pediatric gastro at a nearby hospital -- son was equivocally positive with his blood tests but his biopsies were negative.  No recommendations to go gluten-free at that time, and we never re-tested for some reason.  He's 22 now -- it was probably about 6-8 years ago that he was tested.

 

 

So your son had positive blood tests for celiac disease but was not told to go gluten-free?  He has been eating gluten for the past 6-8 years?  Oh dear. :(  Doctors seem to do that to celiacs - keep them eating gluten until they are sick enough to get a really clear cut diagnosis.  In the meantime, the patient suffers...  I'm glad he is retesting, but if he has any symptoms, and his test results are not firmly all negative, he should go gluten-free and consider himself to be a celiac. You might want to make sure he knows all of the tests that he can ask for so his tests are as accurate as possible.

 

That being said, the tTG IgA can sometimes (<5% of all positives) produce a weak positive that is caused by another health issue, one of which is diabetes (T1).  The other health issues that can cause a slightly elevated tTG IgA (and by slightly I mean something like a 21 when 0-20 is normal) are thyroiditis, crohn's, colitis, chronic liver disease, and a serious infection.  I have Hashi's, and it took over 9 months for my tTG IgA to get to almost normal (from >200 to just under 21 when 0-20 was normal). I always assumed it was because of the Hashi's.

 

Good luck to you. I hope your anemia is improved by summertime!  B)

murphy203 Rookie

Quick update: GI and PC have now both dxd me with celiac disease, so I am officially gluten-free. I have read and learned a whole lot from these forums. so I am gonna stick around! I consider myself asymptomatic for celiac disease, except for symptoms related to iron deficiency, so I am curious to see if removing glluten from my diet will reveal symptoms I don't even realize I have? We shall see!

Kitchen is cleaned, gluten-free staples are stocked, and I am ready! Even my puppy is going gluten-free! :-)

nvsmom Community Regular

:D  Best wishes!

murphy203 Rookie

THANKS! One last update on my diagnosis: Today, my GI ordered the DGP antibody tests, reordered HLA tests (there was a mixup on the original codes, so I still dont have results) and ordered a slew of nutrition tests. I do have an abnormality at a bile duct and will need another biopsy with different equipment, so that is scheduled in about 6 weeks with additional biopsies to see if the gluten-free diet is helping. Progress!

nvsmom Community Regular

Progress is good.  :);)

BlessedMommy Rising Star

Even my puppy is going gluten-free! :-)

 

How wonderful! My kitty eats gluten free and he is SO healthy and has such a shiny coat of fur! I don't think that animals were ever designed to eat gluten to begin with.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):



  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      128,877
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748

    filippa
    Newest Member
    filippa
    Joined

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):


  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.1k
    • Total Posts
      71.3k

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):




  • Who's Online (See full list)


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):



  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • trents
      Thanks for sharing, Karen. Certainly a needed reminder what we already knew (and I've posted many times on this forum) but sometimes forget, namely, autoimmune disorders tend to cluster. Where one is found, you can look for others to show up eventually. The thing that is unusual in your son's case is the onset of several of them at such a young age. My sister in law, who is in her early 60's has Crohn's and struggles with constipation so I don't think that is unusual with Crohn's. If nothing else, it's the outcome of not eating much because of the pain. Now that you know what is going on with your son and the Crohn's, we hope he is beginning to improve.
    • Nathan.
      Hi there. My son is turning 16 this month. He had an endoscopy and biopsy to confirm celiac. He went gluten-free and his pain never got any better. I think it got worse. Months went by. The pain started around 7th grade. He missed a lot of school in 8th grade, and a whole lot in 9th grade. He couldn't go to school in 10th grade. All along the gastroenterologist prescribed Hyoscyamine, didn't help at all. Cyproheptadine, no less pain. Peppermint oil, ginger, Miralax, Senna. Doc said he was constipated, but I couldn't get him to have Miralax daily. Eventually he went on Linzess and no senna or Miralax. Sorry this is long, there will be a point.  We gave his school not just a doctors not, but everything, and U of M makes a lot of notes. They still turned us in for Truancy.  I didn't get him enrolled in online school fast enough.  The school would not recommend an online school and i didn't know which one to choose.  Doc thought it was nerve pain and mental. He recommended the u of m my pain program.  Nathan did so good, 3 days a week supposed to be for 4 weeks.  Never missed, always on time.   After two weeks, they discharged him. Said it was not  benefitting him.  Pain went on. I had been asking if there were any other test they could do. Ultrasound, colonoscopy. Doc said we can do it, but I don't think we'll find anything.  Finally he had a colonoscopy and another endoscopy.  Guess what, they did find something. They found a ton of tiny ulcers everywhere, from the esophagus to his rectum. They think Crohn's. I understand they didn't check for that because he was more constipated, not much diarrhea. He is getting an MRI with contrast on Sunday. Also they want him to do a cal-protectin (give a poop sample). Then an appointment on the 16th to talk about treatment. Then the probation officer on the 17th. In the meantime he is taking Budesonide extended release.  $276.00 for 30 pills, and that's with insurance. Also he was diagnosed with hyperthyroidism, Graves disease a few months ago. If it is for sure Crohn's,  it will be three autoimmune diseases. If someone is gluten-free for a month or more, and the pain is no better, don't stop looking. I was beside myself. Did they think he was exaggerating, lying? I was considering taking him to a holistic doctor, who would probably recommend Peppermint oil and ginger.  He's such a good kid. Kind of an introvert. He was on the 9th grade soccer team. He would try to go to practice and kept having to stop, the pain was that bad. Every time he ate, it didn't matter what, gluten-free chicken tenders, mac and cheese, pizza, ice cream, all gluten-free, he would eat a normal amount but stop and say, I can't eat anymore, my stomach hurts.  If anyone reads all this, thank you. I had a gut feeling, no pun intended, that he had an additional problem. They found celiac and stopped looking. If you don't feel better, keep on your doctor to check further, keep looking.   Take care, Karen  
    • Scott Adams
      Most likely cross-contamination I believe.
    • cristiana
      I think it takes different people different amounts of time, but in my own case I had pain,  bloating and loose stools for some time, exacerbated by a lactose intolerance, which eventually went.  I would say the really bad diarrhea got better quite quickly, but the bloating pain carried on for a few months, until I was told to give up lactose for a few weeks.  That helped enormously and once I realised milk and yoghurt was the cause, after a short break I went back to lactose very gradually and felt a lot better.  Now I can tolerate it well. From Coeliac UK "The enzyme lactase is found in the brush border of the small intestine. This is why people with coeliac disease can be deficient in lactase at diagnosis. Once established on a gluten free diet, the gut is able to heal and lactose digestion returns to normal. Lactose intolerance is therefore usually temporary." So if this helps your daughter, this doesn't mean you have to give up lactose forever, especially as dairy is such a good source of calcium for growing kids.   Bear in mind you should be able to reintroduce it. As for fatigue, this can be due to vitamin and mineral deficiencies,such as iron, vitamin D and B12.  Were these levels tested?  If not, I would suggest you get them done.  If your daughter is deficient in these, it is vital you address the deficiencies, and get the tests redone in a few months, particularly the iron, because too much can be dangerous.
    • knitty kitty
      Hello,   The medication in these inhalers can cause a thiamine deficiency if used by someone already low in thiamine.  We don't absorb sufficient amounts of vitamins and minerals due to the inflammation and damage done to our villi in Celiac Disease.  Even a long term strict gluten free diet may not provide sufficient amounts of vitamins and minerals.  There are eight B vitamins that all work together.  Thiamine deficiency often shows up first because our bodies use so much of it and it can't be stored very long. Thiamine deficiency symptoms can appear in as little as three days.  Without thiamine, the other B vitamins may not be able to function properly.   Thiamine is needed to clear lactic acid accumulation caused by the inhalers: Shoshin beriberi provoked by the inhalation of salbutamol https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12951730/    Significant Lactic Acidosis from Albuterol https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5965110/ Albuterol-Induced Type B Lactic Acidosis: Not an Uncommon Finding https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7263006/ Lessons of the month 1: Salbutamol induced lactic acidosis: clinically recognised but often forgotten https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6964186/ An Overview of Type B Lactic Acidosis Due to Thiamine (B1) Deficiency https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10731935/   Thiamine has antifungal and antibacterial properties.  Thiamine helps keep Candida in check.  Thiamine helps keep SIBO in check.  Thiamine helps with black mold, Aspergillis infection.  Riboflavin helps fight Candida infection in the mouth. Riboflavin Targets the Cellular Metabolic and Ribosomal Pathways of Candida albicans In Vitro and Exhibits Efficacy against Oropharyngeal Candidiasis https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36625571/   Thiamine deficiency can make ones voice hoarse and can cause localized edema.  Niacin deficiency can make ones voice hoarse.  (Niacin deficiency and Thiamine deficiency can each cause irritability, agitation, and lability.) Hoarseness in pellagra https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21507655/ Hidden Hunger: A Pellagra Case Report https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8152714/   Anesthesia can cause B12 deficiency.  B12 deficiency can show up as mouth sores and geographic tongue, diarrhea, and dementia. Vitamin deficiency, a neglected risk factor for post-anesthesia complications: a systematic review https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11823251/ Neurologic degeneration associated with nitrous oxide anesthesia in patients with vitamin B12 deficiency https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8250714/ Subacute combined degeneration of the spinal cord following nitrous oxide anesthesia: A systematic review of cases https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30144777/ The Effect of Vitamin B12 Infusion on Prevention of Nitrous Oxide-induced Homocysteine Increase: A Double-blind Randomized Controlled Trial https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4052402/     Eating a diet that is heavy in carbohydrates can precipitate a thiamine deficiency.  As the amount of carbohydrates consumed increases, additional thiamine is needed, otherwise the carbs will be stored as fat.   Thiamine deficiency disorders: a clinical perspective https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8451766/   Hiding in Plain Sight: Modern Thiamine Deficiency https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8533683/   The deficiency symptoms of some of the B vitamins cause gastrointestinal symptoms that resemble the same symptoms as when being glutened.   Thiamine deficiency can present as vomiting, diarrhea and abdominal pain (Gastrointestinal Beriberi).  Niacin deficiency can present as diarrhea (Pellagra = diarrhea, dermatitis, dementia, then death ).  B12 deficiency can present as diarrhea or dementia.  Not everything is caused by hidden gluten.  Gluten free processed foods are not required to be enriched with vitamins lost in processing like gluten containing foods are. Blood tests are not accurate measurements of vitamin levels, but do talk to your doctor and nutritionist about supplementing with the eight B vitamins, Vitamin C, the four fat soluble vitamins and minerals like magnesium.  Your physician can give you a shot of B12 before anesthesia administration.   By the way, Celiac Disease genes have been traced back to having originated in Neanderthals.  I'm not a singing teacher on the net.  I earned a degree in Microbiology after studying nutrition because I wanted to know what vitamins are doing inside the body.  I've experienced nutritional deficiencies myself. Hope this helps!  Keep us posted on your progress!
×
×
  • Create New...