Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×
  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.




  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):



    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):


  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

News: Celiac.com: The science is in — why gluten sensitivity is probably fake


Scott Adams

Recommended Posts

Scott Adams Grand Master

Unless you have Celiac Disease, your sensitivity to "gluten" probably has nothing to do with gluten at all. Following is ... But it's also in gluten-free foods like agave, artichokes, asparagus, garlic, leeks, and onion. ... The people weren't allergic to gluten but they ate gluten-free due to digestion sensitivity.

Open Original Shared Link

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



Victoria1234 Experienced
4 hours ago, admin said:

Unless you have Celiac Disease, your sensitivity to "gluten" probably has nothing to do with gluten at all. Following is ... But it's also in gluten-free foods like agave, artichokes, asparagus, garlic, leeks, and onion. ... The people weren't allergic to gluten but they ate gluten-free due to digestion sensitivity.

Open Original Shared Link

Also see this: Open Original Shared Link

Wonder if this will help self diagnosed people decide if they are celiac or not? 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Feeneyja Collaborator

This is a much better paper than the article posted above.

Open Original Shared LinkThe Overlapping Area of Non-Celiac Gluten Sensitivity (NCGS) and Wheat-Sensitive Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS): An Update

 It is very thorough, and describes the complications in illucidating the causes of NCGS and how to separate it from IBS. Of note from this paper: Fodmaps do NOT cause extra intestinal symptoms.  Also noted is the difficulty in recruiting subjects to investigate NCGS since most refuse to reintroduce gluten for testing. So there may be some bias in these studies towards those with less severe/complex symptoms. 

There is much more to this paper. I’m just scratching the surface and need to give it a thorough going over.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Jmg Mentor
29 minutes ago, Feeneyja said:

Of note from this paper: Fodmaps do NOT cause extra intestinal symptoms.

That was one of the faults of the Monash experiments in my view. They specifically selected patients with IBS symptoms. They then established that most of them weren't responding to gluten and from that finding came a spate of 'no such thing as gluten sensitivity' articles. Of course the reality is that NCGS is primarily non intestinal so the entire area of gluten ataxia and NCGS has been summarily dismissed due to Monash's headline grabbing research. 

The damage from that is still being felt to this day. I regularly see smug, vacuous, statements from people who wouldn't know a polyol from a polythene bag saying that NCGS has been proved not to exist. I've long since lost the will to direct them to the relevant papers etc. 

I know however that anyone coming up to me and telling me:

22 hours ago, admin said:

Unless you have Celiac Disease, your sensitivity to "gluten" probably has nothing to do with gluten at all. 

is going to have a very bad day!

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Victoria1234 Experienced
2 hours ago, Jmg said:

saying that NCGS has been proved not to exist.

Including my doctor. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Jmg Mentor
13 hours ago, Victoria1234 said:

Including my doctor. 

It's just bad science for them to say that. Certainly if he or she is going off the Monash research. When studies are conducted according to the Salerno criteria the results are different:

Open Original Shared Link

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Gluten-free-01 Enthusiast

I’m getting tired of reading about fructans. Let’s say someone thinks they might be gluten sensitive. They get tested for celiac and the results are negative. So they remove gluten from their diet and see a huge improvement in their symptoms.

If fructans were to blame, wouldn’t they get rid of the symptoms only after removing BOTH wheat, rye and barley AND other high-fructan foods such as onions, garlic, Brussels sprouts, cabbage, broccoli, artichoke, asparagus and leeks?    

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):



  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      125,744
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748

    TootsSherry
    Newest Member
    TootsSherry
    Joined

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):


  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      120.8k
    • Total Posts
      1m

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):





  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):



  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • Dhruv
      , I m writing this email for my 18 years old son. We are resident in USA from past 18 years. My son is born in India, and I got him here when he was 3 months.   He has been playing cricket since he is 4 years. In 2015 we went to india for a vacation, there he had severe stomach pain for 10 days, we went to hospital and they found out gastro! He got all ok, since then he was having stomach pain when he eats bread, only bread not other wheat recipes. Hence we saw GI to make sure,they did bloodwork and diagnosis was celiac weak postive, so they decided to do endoscopy to make sure hence got endoscopy done, endoscopy came negative so Doctor did not inform us about celiac! Although its was shoing weak positive,But after that luckily he started having regular bowl moments which he was bit off earlier, then his appetite got better, he never complained about any stomach issues. Now he is 18 and 5"8 tall and a good athlete. He is a national cricket player,  He is left arm spinner and righty batsman. He works out daily, goes for practice and eats all healthy home made food, sometimes junk but very rare. Since 2021 his billirubin came high in every annual bloodwork, so this year's his Doctor asked us to visit GI, billirubin is 1.4 not more in last 3 years. It's not that high high but out of range.   Now we went to GI, he ran multiple test and now his bloodwork shows celiac positive. (tTG)IgA >100 (tTG)IgG 57 is result reflectting on bloodwork. He is totally asymptomatic, no complaints touch wood. His GI is recommended to go for another endoscopy to make sure. Being mom i m very stressed now. He has national selection next week in California, and don't know what to do. They asked him to stop gluten, we will definitely do but I need correct guidance on few questions.    1. If we do endoscopy and he comes negative , he will be positive or negative for celiac? I do not want to be mislead.   2. In endoscopy do they check small intestines health? If any damage over the period due to not following gluten free diet?   3. What can cause in long run if he fail to follow gluten free diet if he is positive for celiac?   4. It's very difficult to keep him off chapati as that's the most source for his carbs. He does not like rice that much. Being india it's very hard for me too ,to keep him away from chapati.(wheat tortila) And at home I could still manage with bhakri/ or gluten free, but what when he goes on tour?    5. Do you suggest endoscopy? I don't want to poke him if it's not required.   
    • Patty harrigan
      That’s exactly what happens to me. I have been unconscious twice, vomiting afterwards for up to 9 hours and then the bone breaking chills start. I have never vomited while unconscious, thank god.  It’s an unusual presentation and my doctors were reluctant to think it was due to gluten ingestion. However, I know it was gluten as both times it happened within 2-2.5 hrs of eating. I no longer eat food that I haven’t prepared myself and it’s been 6 yrs since it happened.  I was behind the wheel once and was lucky to get off the road before I went out. I feel, and all my doctors reluctantly agree, that it’s a vasovagal reaction. If I can lay down it seems I don’t pass out but I still vomit and get the chills. It’s terrifying to say the least. I could have killed myself or others. I’m as strict as I can be for that reason. 
    • trents
      I assume you were on antibiotics for the E-coli infection? C-diff almost always is the result of prolonged and/or repeated antibiotic treatment. And there is a growing consensus that celiac disease is connected with gut dysbiosis which in turn is likely connected with first world overuse of antibiotics, preservatives and carbohydrate intensive/low nutrient diets. We are wrecking our gut microbiomes and those with genetic potential for celiac disease are reaping the fruit of it.  Can you repost post those antibody test scores but this time include the ranges for positive vs. negative. Each lab uses their own scale for these. There is no industry standard yet. Recently revised "gluten challenge" guidelines recommend the daily consumption of at least 10g of gluten (about the amount in 4-6 slices of wheat bread) for at least two weeks leading up to the antibody testing blood draw. To be sure, I would extend that to four weeks. Sadly, many practitioners neglect to (or don't know to) inform their patients of this before testing and so much testing done results in unclear outcomes. In your original post you mentioned lab analysis done from a colonoscopy. Colonoscopies cannot be used to diagnose celiac disease because they cannot get into the small bowel from the bottom end. Celiac disease causes damage to the lining of the small bowel which is accessed by an endoscopy. They take biopsies and send them to a lab for microscopic analysis.
    • Scott Adams
      A simple blood test should be done, and is usually the first step in diagnosing celiac disease. To do this you need to be eating lots of gluten daily for 6-8 weeks before doing the test. This article might be helpful. It breaks down each type of test, and what a positive results means in terms of the probability that you might have celiac disease. One test that always needs to be done is the IgA Levels/Deficiency Test (often called "Total IGA") because some people are naturally IGA deficient, and if this is the case, then certain blood tests for celiac disease might be false-negative, and other types of tests need to be done to make an accurate diagnosis. The article includes the "Mayo Clinic Protocol," which is the best overall protocol for results to be ~98% accurate.    
    • Sking
      Trents,  Thank you for the informative information. It's interesting that you suggested an infection or something 'triggers' celiac disease. I have been wondering if this happened because I was hospitalized with E-Coli last December and then hospitalized in June with C-Diff. So, they did do the Antibody Testing but never told me anything about needing to prep by eating a good amount of gluten for several weeks prior. My doctor thinks we would have to re-test as she isn't sure the results were entirely accurate. I did not 'abstain' from gluten but I didn't know I was supposed to purposely eat a certaim amount of gluten for 6 weeks prior. They failed to tell me this before I got the blood test. Here are the results of my antibody testing from September: Deamidated Gliadin Abs, IgG: 27 t-Transglutaminase (tTG) IgA: 3 Endomysial Antibody IgA: Negative Immunoglobulin A, Qn, Serum: 111   Thanks for any input, I appreciate this site.
×
×
  • Create New...