Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×
  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.




  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):



    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):


  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Soy and celiac question


disgruntledceliac

Recommended Posts

disgruntledceliac Explorer

Prior to going on the Fasano diet my celiac wasn't improving, and I would have nasty reactions to foods including dairy and soy. I did six months on the Fasano diet and can now feel great and can handle dairy. Is it likely that I can now handle foods that contain (or are cross-contaminated with) soy, or should I continue to steer clear of it?


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



GFinDC Veteran

Lactose intolerance is fairly common in untreated celiac disease.  So it is reasonable to expect it may improve after being gluten-free awhile.  Soy intolerance is a different thing and there isn't any reason to expect it to go away.  But then again it might.  Soy is a top 8 allergen in the USA.

Ennis-TX Grand Master
2 hours ago, disgruntledceliac said:

Prior to going on the Fasano diet my celiac wasn't improving, and I would have nasty reactions to foods including dairy and soy. I did six months on the Fasano diet and can now feel great and can handle dairy. Is it likely that I can now handle foods that contain (or are cross-contaminated with) soy, or should I continue to steer clear of it?

Lactose intolerance, the enzymes to break down lactose are made introduced by our villi. Celiac destroys these and with healing the ability to digest it sometimes comes back (not for me, I also later got a whey allergy). Soy....as mentioned not so much, I myself still can not tolerate soy proteins...oddly soy lectin no longer bothers me.

apprehensiveengineer Community Regular

I think that soy "intolerance" is a bit of an urban legend/very much overstated for people with celiac disease. Soy is often cross-contamined with gluten (like other legumes), or implemented in a manner that does contain gluten (soy sauce), which I think leads to many people coming to the incorrect conclusion that they have a soy intolerance. If you're buying soy products processed in Asia that are not labelled gluten-free (a good chunk of such products), then I'd hazard that your problem is gluten, not soy.

I am allergic to soy. My mouth and throat get itchy nearly immediately upon ingestion of soy, as well as hives. My reaction is mostly limited to this, and I have never had a problem with "may contain soy" products. I also eat products containing soy lecithin and soybean oil, as those do not contain any soy protein (theoretically).

Awol cast iron stomach Experienced

All excellent advice above. I had 13 intolerances after my diagnosis. I am down to 2 milk and corn including derivatives of. Personally for me I could not handle many of my 13 foods or I found I had a threshold limit and limited inflammatory foods until 26 months post. The corn and corn derivatives appear to be here to stay for me as they rip my GI up and trigger inflammation and joint/muscle aches. I tried some sheep cheese once and a gluten-free pizza with milk based cheese on it and found it passed the joint and muscle test, but did seemed to trigger constipation. Milk stays off the list. 

It was a shock after diagnosis to have so may issues. I appeared to initially be reactive to every food I ate within a 2 day period when my Dr was checking me out. As she told me what my body was reacting to I responded "wow you just told me every food item I ate within the past 2 day period!" My GI tract was apparently annihilated and every thing felt and appeared to confirm it just dumped into my blood stream.

As others say if it is a true food intolerance it is here to stay. If it is the result of a damaged gut dumping things into the blood stream in time you maybe able to eat it as it heals. In my opinion the 2-3 year mark will let you know for sure if it is here to stay, if you are unsure.

 

Good luck

  • 2 weeks later...
disgruntledceliac Explorer

Thanks all for sharing your experiences. I'll keep it in mind moving forward.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):



  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      127,983
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748

    Kari Shover
    Newest Member
    Kari Shover
    Joined

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):


  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121k
    • Total Posts
      70.5k

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):





  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):



  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • WildFlower1
      Thank you for your help, I am currently in the middle of the gluten challenge. A bit over 6 weeks in. At 4 weeks I got the celiac blood tests and that is when they were negative. So to rule out the false negative, since I’m in the middle of the gluten challenge right now and will never do this again, I wanted to continue consuming gluten to the point to make sure the blood tests are not a false negative - which I did not receive a firm answer for how many weeks total.    My issue is, with these blood tests the doctors say “you are not celiac” and rule it out completely as a potential cause of my issues, when the symptoms scream of it. I want to rule out this 30 year mystery for my own health since I’m in the middle of it right now. Thank you!
    • trents
      I am a male and had developed osteopenia by age 50 which is when I finally got dx with celiac disease. I am sure I had it for at least 13 years before that because it was then I developed idiopathic elevated liver enzymes. I now have a little scoliosis and pronounced kyphosis (upper spine curvature).  All of your symptoms scream of celiac disease, even if the testing you have had done does not. You may be an atypical celiac, meaning the disease is not manifesting itself in your gut but is attacking other body systems. There is such a thing as sero negative celiac disease. But you still have not given me a satisfactory answer to my question of why do you need a differential dx between celiac disease and NCGS when either one would call for complete abstinence from gluten, which you have already been practicing except for short periods when you were undergoing a gluten challenge. Why do you want to put a toxic substance into your body for weeks when, even if it did produce a positive test result for celiac disease, neither you or your doctors would do anything different? Regardless of what doctors are recommending to you, it is your body it is affecting not theirs and they don't seem to have given you any good justification for starting another gluten challenge. Where you live, are doctors kings or something?
    • WildFlower1
      Sorry to put it clearly, at 15, infertility started (tried to word it nicely) meaning menstruation stopped. Which is in correlation to celiac I mean. Thank you. 
    • WildFlower1
      Thank you for the reply! Doctors over the years have tested me for everything under the sun and tests are normal, except the decreasing bone density, high FSH (in regards to infertility), lower iron, and all the other celiac symptoms I experience. When I was 15 the infertility started (my whole life growing up I always ate gluten, and always had severe stomach problems, I’m an adult now and I still remember the stomach pain as a child) and then from here, they couldn’t figure out why. At the same time I was having all these celiac symptoms but nobody ever put two and two together.   Eventually in adulthood I went off gluten and dairy and felt better. Later in life, the topic was brought up by doctors, but they could never actually test for celiac because I was off gluten for years.   Just recently multiple doctors brought it up again, and said I should rule it out. So the ruling out of celiac, which is direct correlation with these symptoms, infertility at a younge age, on the edge and getting into osteopenia, etc. etc. is the concern. I was off of dairy for the same time as gluten because it made me sick. I did not surely have adequate calcium/D intake as well over these years.   The matter of concern is to once and for all get celiac ruled out for my own health, a gastro doctor recommended I get it done and other doctors to confirm yes or no to officially rule it out.  For these 6 weeks I have not been eating enough gluten then it seems, if 2-3 slices of bread a day is not really enough. I should increase my intake of gluten then and extend the test time?   Thank you very much for your help!! The test for Immunoglobulin IgA being a value of —> “1.25” shows it is in the normal range of 0.54-4.17 g/L on the test. 
    • trents
      Welcome to the forum, @WildFlower1! The reason you are seeing conflicting results when you research the length of time recommended for doing the "gluten challenge" is that the guidelines have recently been under revision. So there are two components: 1. amount of daily gluten consumption and 2. duration of that amount of daily gluten consumption Recently, the guidelines have been under revision because the medical community was sensing the previous standards were too relaxed, particularly in the daily amount of recommended gluten consumption. The more recent guidelines seem to be calling for higher amounts of daily gluten consumption over (perhaps) as shorter period of time. So, it is becoming a daily minimum of 10g of gluten daily (about the amount in 4-6 slices of wheat bread) for a minimum of two weeks. Personally, I would recommend that amount of consumption be extended from two weeks to four weeks to ensure valid testing. Your Immunoglobulin IgA at 1.25. Was that within normal range? If that one is low, you are IgA deficient and other IgA test results cannot be trusted. But regardless of whether or not you have celiac disease or NCGS (Non Celiac Gluten Sensitivity) the antidote is the same, namely, a gluten free diet. What would you do different if you had a more confident differential diagnosis? And there are other reasons for the development of osteopenia/osteoporosis that you probably should explore. Are you on any serious supplementation for D3 and magnesium?
×
×
  • Create New...