Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×
  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.




  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):



    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):


  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Diagnosis


Kmorley

Recommended Posts

Kmorley Rookie

Hi 

I had a positive coeliac ttg result of 205 back in February and due to covid only recently had a biopsy.

My biopsy came back normal but my consultant isn't happy with that he is adamant I have coeliac due to having all the symptoms and a positive ttg. I now have to undergo more tests and he doesnt want to do the biopsy again unless necessary due to my reaction when under sedation.

He has now told me to start on a gluten free diet until I get my letter to book in for more tests.

I dont know what to think now do I have it or do I not and what are the chances of having a false positive result with a ttg level of 205.

 

Sorry for the long winded question im just very confused.


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



trents Grand Master

False positives on both the blood tests and endoscopy do happen and a number of our forum members can attest to that. Not every GI doc seems to do a good job of taking the biopsies in the right place to show the disease. The proof is in the pudding, so to speak. If you feel better after a few months on the gluten-free diet that is all you need.

Scott Adams Grand Master

I think the chances of a false positive blood test is rather small compared to the chance of a false negative biopsy result. Any chance you can share the details if your blood test results, including the scale they use?

  • 2 weeks later...
Kmorley Rookie
On 11/16/2020 at 2:56 AM, Scott Adams said:

I think the chances of a false positive blood test is rather small compared to the chance of a false negative biopsy result. Any chance you can share the details if your blood test results, including the scale they use?

I am not to sure to be honest. Alls I know is my ttg result was 205, I was slightly anemic and have vitamin D deficiency. Doctors in the UK are very vague with what information they share with you and could not give me an explanation as to why my ttg result was so high but my biopsy was normal.

trents Grand Master

High antibody scores with negative biopsy is certainly not a rare phenomenon. Several forum posters have shared the same experience. I would likely attribute that to the skill/experience (or lack of it) of the one doing the biopsy. It's not uncommon for the physician doing the biopsy to miss the affected area of the small bowel and take the samples instead from unaffected areas.

Kmorley Rookie
14 minutes ago, trents said:

High antibody scores with negative biopsy is certainly not a rare phenomenon. Several forum posters have shared the same experience. I would likely attribute that to the skill/experience (or lack of it) of the one doing the biopsy. It's not uncommon for the physician doing the biopsy to miss the affected area of the small bowel and take the samples instead from unaffected areas.

Thank you, I've got to undergo more tests when I finally receive my letters through the post that I am still waiting for 6 weeks later. I have been put on a gluten free diet now so just got to see what comes of everything.

trents Grand Master

Being on a gluten-free diet will likely invalidate any tests done for Celiac Disease.


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



Kmorley Rookie
12 minutes ago, trents said:

Being on a gluten-free diet will likely invalidate any tests done for Celiac Disease.

My consultant said the tests I will be having will not be affected by me going on a gluten free diet

trents Grand Master

Can you be more specific about the tests? I am not aware of any testing for Celiac Disease that would not be affected by going on a gluten-free diet for any length of time.

"Consultant?" Is this person a physician? 

If you research this question I don't think you will find this consultant's advice to be true.

RMJ Mentor

If the TTG result goes down on the gluten free diet that would be another indicator that you have celiac disease.

Kmorley Rookie

I have no idea i have to have more blood tests and he said we will take it from there. I think that is why I have to start the diet to see if the ttg levels drop. The doctor specialises in coeliac. He says I have all the symptoms the ttg result to back it up he just doesn't want to repeat the biopsy as I didnt do well with the first one.

  • 3 weeks later...
frieze Community Regular

Perhaps checking for genes, as well?

Kmorley Rookie

I finally received my letter and some of the tests I have to have are HLA DQ2 & DQ8, antigliadin test, they are redoing my TTG and there was something else but I can't remember what it was.

Scott Adams Grand Master

Let us know how it turns out!

Kmorley Rookie
38 minutes ago, Scott Adams said:

Let us know how it turns out!

I will do, thanks for everything had my bloods done Monday so hopefully should get my results after Christmas.

GFinDC Veteran

Hi Kmorley,

the HLA tests are the gene tests.  They don't require you to be on a gluten-free diet.  Anybody can take the gene tests at any time.

The antibody tests do depend on eating gluten for a while before them.  But if your doctor is trying to verify the antibodies have declined since starting the gluten-free diet, then you don't need or want to eat gluten before them.

Did you feel any difference on the gluten-free diet?

Kmorley Rookie
12 minutes ago, GFinDC said:

Hi Kmorley,

the HLA tests are the gene tests.  They don't require you to be on a gluten-free diet.  Anybody can take the gene tests at any time.

The antibody tests do depend on eating gluten for a while before them.  But if your doctor is trying to verify the antibodies have declined since starting the gluten-free diet, then you don't need or want to eat gluten before them.

Did you feel any difference on the gluten-free diet?

There was about 8 different tests and when my nurse contacted the pathology lab one of the tests that was requested was for transfusions so she was just as confused as me. 

I do feel a lot better to be honest I don't feel bloated anymore and a few other symptoms seem to have settled. It is just the cost of the foods now lol.

GFinDC Veteran
(edited)
15 hours ago, Kmorley said:

There was about 8 different tests and when my nurse contacted the pathology lab one of the tests that was requested was for transfusions so she was just as confused as me. 

I do feel a lot better to be honest I don't feel bloated anymore and a few other symptoms seem to have settled. It is just the cost of the foods now lol.

Feeling better is great! :)

Your body must be having some kind of reaction to gluten if you feel different after stopping eating gluten.  There are multiple antibody tests that they do for a complete celiac test panel.  DGP IgA, DGP IgG, EMA, total serum IgA, ttg IgA,  All these different antibody types are relevant and a positive on any of them can indicate celiac disease.

If you concentrate on eating  meats, veggies, eggs, nuts and fruit your diet won't be any more expensive than any other person who eats those naturally gluten-free foods.  Also, eating naturally gluten-free foods it is easier to avoid accidental gluten consumption.  Processed foods are always more risky than naturally gluten-free whole foods.

You may find it better to avoid oats and milk for  few months too.  Our intestinal villi make an enzyme called lactase that helps digest the sugar called lactose in cow dairy.  So dairy can be hard to digest  for a few months during healing.  After the villi grow back they may start making that lactase enzyme again.

Some 10% or so of people with celiac also react to oats.  So it's not a bad idea to avoid the oats for a few months just in case you are one of those 10%.  If you are one of those 10% you'll have a hard time recovering while eating oats.

Edited by GFinDC
Kmorley Rookie
22 minutes ago, GFinDC said:

Feeling better is great! :)

Your body must be having some kind of reaction to gluten if you feel different after stopping eating gluten.  There are multiple antibody tests that they do for a complete celiac test panel.  DGP IgA, DGP IgG, EMA, total serum IgA, ttg IgA,  All these different antibody types are relevant and a positive on any of them can indicate celiac disease.

If you concentrate on eating  meats, veggies, eggs, nuts and fruit your diet won't be any more expensive than any other person who eats those naturally gluten-free foods.  Also, eating naturally gluten-free foods it is easier to avoid accidental gluten consumption.  Processed foods are always more risky than naturally gluten-free whole foods.

You may find it better to avoid oats and milk for  few months too.  Our intestinal villi make an enzyme called lactase that helps digest the sugar called lactose in cow dairy.  So dairy can be hard to digest  for a few months during healing.  After the villi grow back they may start making that lactase enzyme again.

Some 10% or so of people with celiac also react to oats.  So it's not a bad idea to avoid the oats for a few months just in case you are one of those 10%.  If you are one of those 10% you'll have a hard time recovering while eating oats.

Thanks for that honestly, I dont know when I will get my results back. Had a mistake of having the Christmas Dinner at work yesterday and having a very bad day today so it just show that gluten is affecting me.

GFinDC Veteran
(edited)

Hi K,

The first 6 months or so of the gluten-free diet are the hardest IMHO.  After that people generally learn the basics and have made enough mistakes to learn to eat less riskily, if that's a wurd. :)

 The holidays are a bit disturbing to some people who are gluten-free because of all the holiday foods they can't eat.  Other people may have reason to be depressed around the holidays but we have reason to be downright grouchy. :) 

It all gets easier with time and experience though.  There are gluten-free holiday cookie recipes that float around the web some near Christmas.  There may even be gluten-free cookie recipes on this forum.  Flour free peanut butter cookies comes to mind, but I haven't made them in a while.

For the baking adverse there are Enjoy Life brand gluten-free cookies and others.  And gluten-free breads are available and dairy free ice cream subs.  Etc, etc.

There was a what's for dinner tonight thread a while back with lots of ideas in it.  And a microwave bun thread too.

You'll be an expert in no time! :)

 

Edited by GFinDC
Kmorley Rookie
1 hour ago, GFinDC said:

Hi K,

The first 6 months or so of the gluten-free diet are the hardest IMHO.  After that people generally learn the basics and have made enough mistakes to learn to eat less riskily, if that's a wurd. :)

 The holidays are a bit disturbing to some people who are gluten-free because of all the holiday foods they can't eat.  Other people may have reason to be depressed around the holidays but we have reason to be downright grouchy. :) 

It all gets easier with time and experience though.  There are gluten-free holiday cookie recipes that float around the web some near Christmas.  There may even be gluten-free cookie recipes on this forum.  Flour free peanut butter cookies comes to mind, but I haven't made them in a while.

For the baking adverse there are Enjoy Life brand gluten-free cookies and others.  And gluten-free breads are available and dairy free ice cream subs.  Etc, etc.

There was a what's for dinner tonight thread a while back with lots of ideas in it.  And a microwave bun thread too.

You'll be an expert in no time! :)

 

Thank you so much, you don't understand how much this is all helping at the moment. 🙂

My health isn't doing to good at the moment as well as dealing with ceoliac so listening to others is helping. So thank you honestly. 🙂

  • 1 month later...
Kmorley Rookie

Hi everyone so..........

This is where I am at now, I have had more blood tests but not heard anything back yet. I have had a telephone call with the dietician as our current lockdown restrictions won't allow use to go into a doctors surgery or hospital. She has said there is a lot of confusion with my results and the consultant is trying his best to find your diagnosis as my ttg levels are 205.

I am still on the gluten free diet but just getting very frustrated as I don't have a diagnosis yet after a year.

Anyone any ideas? 

Scott Adams Grand Master

Many doctors are now diagnosing celiac disease based on blood tests alone, especially if your results are 10x the celiac level range. If you can find the celiac disease cut off level for your ttg test and share it, it would be more helpful. For example, if it were 20, then you'd be 10x the celiac level.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):



  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      128,152
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748

    TopRealtorBeach
    Newest Member
    TopRealtorBeach
    Joined

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):


  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.1k
    • Total Posts
      70.7k

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):





  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):



  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • Matt13
      Hi Guys, i did repeat biopsy after marsh3b (without erosion) and results are now: normal villi without atrtophy, 25/100 iel and moderate mononuclear inflamation in lamia propria, with occesional granulocytes. Doc says the he saw little erosion on duodenum. Is this good ? I mean is this progress? Please help!
    • Scott Adams
      In case you decide to go the route of a gluten challenge for a celiac disease blood test or biopsy: Here is more info about how to do a gluten challenge for a celiac disease blood panel, or for an endoscopy: and this recent study recommends 4-6 slices of wheat bread per day:    
    • Wheatwacked
      Kosher salt is not usually iodized. Shortly after starting GFD in 2014, I realized I wasn't getting enough iodine.  Growing up in the 50's and 60's we ate bread that used iodine as a dough modifier so each slice had about 100 mcg of iodine.  A sandwich and glass of milk supplied 300 mcg a day.  In the 70's they stopped using iodine as a conditioner in the US.  Then everyone got scared of milk.  The US intake of iodine dropped 50% since 1974.  Prescriptions of Thyroxine for hypothyroid disease doubled in the same period.  I tried using iodized salt and seaweed and took an expensive thyroid supplement but it wasn't enough.  In 2014 I had a sebaceous cyst (third eye blind).  The previous 6 cysts on my face had all drained and healed with no problem back in the 1990,s.  One on my check had sugically removed. They are genetic from my mom and my brother and son also get them in the same places.  This one I did not have surgery for because I wanted a bellweather to moniter healing.  It did not start healing until I started until 10 years when I started taking 600 mcg of Liquid Iodine a year ago Nov 2023. Lot's of comment about how it was offputting and maybe cancer, it was deep, down to the bone, but I can be obstenant.  Now it is scabbing over and healing normally.  Vision is returning to my right eye (glucoma), musle tone in my chest was the first sign of improvement.  For healing, iodine breaks down defective and aging cells to make room for new growth. I take Liquid Iodine drops from Pipingrock.com but there is also Strong Iodine and Lugols Solution. 50 mcg/drop a dropper full is 12 drops, 600 mcg.,  usually I put it in a can of Red Bull, My brother, son and his family also started taking it. https://www.pipingrock.com/iodine/liquid-iodine-2-fl-oz-59-ml-dropper-bottle-14690 390 drops for $8.  They ship internationally if you can't find it locally. It the US the Safe Tolerable Upper Limit is 1000 mcg a day.  In Japan it is 3000 mcg a day.  The Japanese traditional diet has 50% less breast cancer, nicer hair, skin and nails, and in the 80's the US educational system dropped down comared to the rest of the world while Japanese kids moved up to the top.  Low iodine affects brain fog. According to most education rankings, Japan generally has a higher education rating than the United States, with Japan often ranking within the top 10 globally while the US usually places slightly lower.  In the 1960s, the United States was near the top of the world for education, especially for young people.  About why iodine was removed from medicint: The Wolff-Chaikoff Effect: Crying Wolf? About why over 40% of us are vitamin D deficient: Mayo Proceedings,  Vitamin D Is Not as Toxic as Was Once Thought:  
    • trents
      Current "gluten challenge" recommendations are the daily consumption of at least 10g of gluten (about the amount found in 4-6 slices of wheat bread) daily leading up to the day of the biopsy.
    • Bebee
      Thank you for your input!  I would really like to know if I have celiac disease because you need make sure you are not getting any cross contamination due to cancer concerns.  I guess I need to start with a knowledgeable Gastroenterologist. Thank you again!
×
×
  • Create New...