Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):

    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

"confident it's not celiac" & how important is an "official" dx?

drejo.mcwes
 Share

Recommended Posts

drejo.mcwes Newbie
drejo.mcwes
Posted

So my daughter's doc wrote me back today that we can be "confident" she does not have celiac, and I confess I was surprised.
She has stomach pain that comes on when eating gluten, and goes away when gluten free. She gets weird, scaly/scabby rashes (not eczema) periodically and has consistent diarrhea and bloating. She's had labs done three separate times: DGP was weakly positive each time, ttg-iga was 3X the upper limit twice and 6X the upper limit once, and EMA was also positive. She also has two siblings with biopsy verified celiac disease.

But she's had two biopsies that failed to find any damage.

Quote from her doc: "This means that she does NOT have celiac disease. People can develop celiac autoantibodies that are sometimes transient, or they can persist and yet never progress to celiac disease. I think we can feel confident at this point that she doesn't have celiac, at least at this time." He suggested leaving her on gluten for now and retesting levels in a year.

We're taking her off of gluten anyway, since we have two other celiacs in the house, and we're throwing in the towel on testing. A number of folks on a celiac fb page told me that their children received a dx with a whole lot fewer presenting factors, but I'm not sure I have it in me to keep feeding her gluten while we seek a second opinion.

So I guess my question is what your take is on this, and how important you think it is for a child to have an "official" diagnosis. I was convinced she had it, and now I feel a lot of doubt and uncertainty. Certainly, it'd be nice if she didn't - but I feel like I've gotten a lot of mixed messages. I feel like I need some "certainty" to move forward and stop doubting myself. I want to believe the doctor. I really do. She certainly doesn't want to give up gluten and would also like to believe the doctor...

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


trents Grand Master
trents
Posted
(edited)

My take is your daughter has celiac disease and your doctor is full of bologna.

With those symptoms, high tTG-IGA and genetic risk factors I don't know how the doctor reached the conclusion she did. No need to torture her. And negative biopsies after positive antibody tests is certainly not unheard of. It can be due to a number of factors. Transient or not, no need to torture her. She has celiac symptoms now and if you keep shoving gluten in her there is more and more chance harm will be done to other body systems and more and more chance it will evolve into permanent celiac disease even if it is transient.

Edited by trents
Scott Adams Grand Master
Scott Adams
Posted

A formal diagnosis could be helpful to keep your daughter on a gluten-free diet for life, as some people may wander back to gluten later without this. However, it could also mean higher private health and/or life insurance costs going forward. 

I agree with @trents, high tTG-IGA levels mean she’s something like 97% likely to have it.

drejo.mcwes Newbie
drejo.mcwes
Posted
  • Author

Thank you both! I very much appreciate your input. I'm curious - would it change your opinion if her most recent EMA was negative, after being positive in November? We just got that result back today, and I felt like it threw me for another loop!

trents Grand Master
trents
Posted

No.

"The EMA-IgA test is an important marker for celiac disease, portraying a 99% accuracy rate. This test is expensive and involves a high degree of technical precision. It is used as an accompanying test along with the routine tTG-IgA test to confirm the diagnosis of celiac disease. This test implies that anyone with a high titer of EMA is sure to be a victim of celiac disease. However, the EMA test scores are much lower in sensitivity than the tTG-IgA test." From: https://factdr.com/diagnostics/blood-tests/ema-endomysial-antibodies/

Scott Adams Grand Master
Scott Adams
Posted
17 hours ago, drejo.mcwes said:

Thank you both! I very much appreciate your input. I'm curious - would it change your opinion if her most recent EMA was negative, after being positive in November? We just got that result back today, and I felt like it threw me for another loop!

It would not erase the prior results, which were positive. Was she eating gluten daily before this more recent test? She would need to eat about 2 slices of wheat bread for 6-8 weeks before taking a blood test for celiac disease. If she wasn't doing this before her recent test, it could explain why the results were lower.

drejo.mcwes Newbie
drejo.mcwes
Posted
  • Author
5 minutes ago, Scott Adams said:

It would not erase the prior results, which were positive. Was she eating gluten daily before this more recent test? She would need to eat about 2 slices of wheat bread for 6-8 weeks before taking a blood test for celiac disease. If she wasn't doing this before her recent test, it could explain why the results were lower.

She was eating gluten for 6 weeks before hand. It makes sense that the sensitivity rate is lower, like trents said, so the specificity is more telling than the sensitivity with regards to a negative test the second time. I think we're just going to let it be for now and consider a gluten challenge down the road in a few years, depending on what she actually wants as she gets older. The doc said there may be an opportunity  for her to participate in a research study in the next few years that looks at some blood markers after just a single dose of gluten, and he'll let us know more about that as things progress.

The other thing that I was thinking is just that she's relatively young still (1st grade) and things may only have just been developing when we happened to screen for it. 

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


trents Grand Master
trents
Posted
1 hour ago, drejo.mcwes said:

The other thing that I was thinking is just that she's relatively young still (1st grade) and things may only have just been developing when we happened to screen for it. 

Agree.

  • 2 weeks later...
beaver Newbie
beaver
Posted

I have not been tested or diagnosed with celiac or any other conditions but have many food eating problems one of which led me to this website today.

Last year, I was thinking the worst that I might have celiac or something as I was suffering from bloating, stomach discomfort and diarrhoea after eating bread but noticed I wasn't quite as bad eating a bought organic loaf so tried making my own.

I now make my own part white, part wholemeal bread with organic flour and can now happily eat bread again, so it might be worth trying it with your daughter.

I have no real idea why, but wonder if it's a sensitivity to the multitude of insecticides, pesticides, fungicides etc, that crops get sprayed with so now eat organic if I can.

trents Grand Master
trents
Posted
2 hours ago, beaver said:

I have not been tested or diagnosed with celiac or any other conditions but have many food eating problems one of which led me to this website today.

Last year, I was thinking the worst that I might have celiac or something as I was suffering from bloating, stomach discomfort and diarrhoea after eating bread but noticed I wasn't quite as bad eating a bought organic loaf so tried making my own.

I now make my own part white, part wholemeal bread with organic flour and can now happily eat bread again, so it might be worth trying it with your daughter.

I have no real idea why, but wonder if it's a sensitivity to the multitude of insecticides, pesticides, fungicides etc, that crops get sprayed with so now eat organic if I can.

Beaver, what's keeping you from being tested for celiac disease? It is common for people with celiac disease to develop intolerances to other foods in addition to those containing wheat, barley and rye over time. It's due to the "leaky gut" caused by damage the small bowel villi which allows larger than normal protein fractions from the food we eat to enter the blood stream and get detected as invaders. If you have celiac disease it might unlock the puzzle for you. Or, you might have non celiac gluten sensitivity (NCGS).

beaver Newbie
beaver
Posted

Hi Trents,

Reading some of the posts here has got me wondering and rather than hijack this thread, I will post again when I have had a chance to think about it.

trents Grand Master
trents
Posted
18 minutes ago, beaver said:

Hi Trents,

Reading some of the posts here has got me wondering and rather than hijack this thread, I will post again when I have had a chance to think about it.

Sounds good. Thanks for your sensitivity about thread hijacking.

drejo.mcwes Newbie
drejo.mcwes
Posted
  • Author
6 hours ago, beaver said:

I now make my own part white, part wholemeal bread with organic flour and can now happily eat bread again, so it might be worth trying it with your daughter.

I have no real idea why, but wonder if it's a sensitivity to the multitude of insecticides, pesticides, fungicides etc, that crops get sprayed with so now eat organic if I can.

I appreciate the idea and we've had a moderate amount of success with this sort of thing for other issues (e.g., US flour caused swollen tonsils and sleep disturbances for one child, while bread we had in Europe didn't affect her at all). Because of this, before she was tested for celiac, we ate homemade sourdough made with organic grain that we ground ourselves. Unfortunately, it just didn't actually affect the GI issues.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):


  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      126,204
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    DreDre
    Newest Member
    DreDre
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      120.9k
    • Total Posts
      69.2k
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):



  • Who's Online (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):


  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • kopiq
      starting to heal, vitamin d deficiant but cannot tolerate vitamins. what to do? also multiple ongoing issues.

      By kopiq · Posted

      I also have food particles left on toiet paper when i wipe and my stool is light yellow not absorbing fats. I urinate about 15 times a day and have very sticky snot,dry throat.
    • kopiq
      starting to heal, vitamin d deficiant but cannot tolerate vitamins. what to do? also multiple ongoing issues.

      By kopiq · Posted

      Hi all, I was diagnosed by blood work about 2 months ago and have since went on a strict gluten free diet. I have an endoscopy in January and the GI dr said nothing about staying on gluten for it; hes aware i went no gluten. starting to heal symptoms include: (this is huge) sensation coming back to genitals and when having a bowl movement. everything has been numb for a long time down there including lower belly button area. good size (not abnormal) bowel movements once a day or every two days. small dot size wart just fell off my finger that was there for years. have not broke out with a cold sore this winter (every winter prior for years i would develop a cold sore on my lip) Ongoing issues I don't sweat. not from my hands, or armpits or feet. I do not get butterflys in stomach. my hands have been so dry for years ive been using a crack cream as they crack and bleed very severely in the fall and winter.  (since going gluten free ive not used crack cream but they are still very very dry and chapped/flaky, no sweat or moisture in palms of hands at all. I dont crave food. i have no cravings at all, not for pizza, ice cream , nothing. my cravings are dead. smell of foods kinda make me hungry, but my stomach blocks it. pins needles in feet get weak legs standing up from sitting and dizzy, things almost turn black. i cannot tolerate veggies or vitamins. Iam vitamin D deficient according to my Dr and Ive tried vitamin D pills. they give me a massive migraine for 8 hours and upset my stomach. the heat from the direct sun make me extremely tired to the point of wanting to pass out. again i don't sweat. broccoli gives me a migraine headache as well. mushrooms, bell peppers burn my stomach. fruits burn my stomach, fats (peanut butter, any oil or fat from meats make me sick to my stomach for a couple hours or longer. salt and pepper burns my stomach. all these issues cause pain at my belly button area and expand to the rest of my upper stomach and sides the more i ingest through out the day. I currently eat bland basmati rice, chicken, pork chops (fat trim), boiled russet potatoes no skin for three meals a day. my snacks are gluten free ground buckwheat flour pancakes. (just water, no oil , salt, dairy.) how am i to get vitamins in my system if i cannot tolerate them in my stomach? i mentioned epidermal vitamin patchs but dr said no. why cant i stand the heat from the sun ? why cant i sweat? thanks for any info.                
    • trents
      Celiac Maybe a Possibility?

      By trents · Posted

      Because you have significantly reduced your gluten intake over a considerable amount of time, it is likely that you will test negative on the antibody tests. However, if the $112 for the Quest test is not a burden, it wouldn't hurt to try. It tests for total IGA (to ascertain if you are IGA deficient) and tTG-IGA. If total IGA is deficient, it can result in false negatives in other IGA tests. The tTG-IGA is the single most popular test ordered by physicians. The Quest test is not a complete celiac panel by any means (refer to the linked article above) but it might be a good place to start. Personally, I think you know enough to conclude that you need to get serious about avoiding gluten, whether you have celiac disease or NCGS. Human nature being what it is, however, many people seem to need an official diagnosis of celiac disease in order to stay on the bandwagon. Otherwise, they seem to rationalize cheating on the gluten-free diet. And there is this misconception out there that NCGS is inconvenient and uncomfortable but not harmful so it's okay to cheat. The more we learn about gluten-related disorders the more they seem to not fit into our neat little black and white categories. By the way, celiac disease is not a food allergy. It is classified as an autoimmune disorder.
    • More2Learn
      Celiac Maybe a Possibility?

      By More2Learn · Posted

      These responses are all extremely helpful, ty.  Really good reminder about omega 6.  I also know I'm low in zinc; I took the zinc test where I drank it on a spoon and couldn't taste it.  To that end, I try to eat a lot of oysters.  I do think it would be a good idea to get the blood test.  Two questions: 1-  Is there any reason you wouldn't recommend that I just buy and take a test like this as a first step? 2- I've been somewhat gluten free since ~Jan 2023 (technically organic, gluten free, soy free, light on dairy).  I eat a lot of meat, vegetables, rice -- a common breakfast for me is three eggs and a sausage link, and I can't remember the last time I had a sandwich or bread.  However, because in my mind I didn't think I had an allergy, and I more was doing gluten free to avoid artificially iron-enriched foods, I do make exceptions.  I'll eat breaded calamari.  When my Dad visits, I split mozzarella sticks with him because he loves them so much.  I'll eat the "gluten sensitive" items at a restaurant and if they asked, "is cross contamination ok?",  I always said yes.  Based on that, since I never probably fully eliminated gluten, but it was significantly reduced... is that good enough to take the blood test?  Because the pain in my side gets SO bad (really sometimes I can't function, and I absolutely thought I was dying), I am hesitant to do the gluten challenge.  Would it make sense to take the test, and if it's negative, then consider doing the challenge and seeing if I can deal with eating the bread every day? Thanks again!
    • Yaya
      Muscle Twitching

      By Yaya · Posted

      For me, with osteoporosis, Celiac and more than 1 heart condition, the slower, safer route is preferable.  I'm on 5 meds per day.  Too much of anything can disturb absorption of this or that. Have a Happy Thanksgiving.  I'm gone for a few days.  
×
×
  • Create New...