Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×
  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.




  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):



    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):


  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Sugar alcohols


plumbago

Recommended Posts

plumbago Experienced

Sabine Hassenfelder is a German science writer who has worked in the US and Sweden, among other places. She posts entertaining, funny videos about science, but recently did one on sugar alcohols, which I think is worth viewing. In it, she talks some about autoimmunity in general, and why symptoms often show up later in life (30s -40s, eg). ("I've probably had this my entire life," she says, but she didn't notice sooner, mostly due to age and food intolerance are mostly a threshold effect. But another part of the reason is that they're used much more so than ever, she says - even toothpaste!) She was having some post prandial digestive issues - cramps, pain, bloating - and went on a detailed search for the culprit. It turns out to have been sugar alcohols. Often called sorbitol or mannitol, it is added to things like soft cookies to keep them from drying out. There are many different sugar alcohols, with many different names, sigh. Intolerance to this food additive is something to consider (possibly) if you are still having symptoms after going gluten free for a number of months. Doctors gave her all manner of diagnoses including diverticula (nope). She cut sugar alcohols out of her diet and she says 95% of her problems disappeared.

"If you have an autoimmune problem, it will flare up along with it" she says. Whoa. She predicts diagnoses of sugar alcohol intolerance will skyrocket in the coming decade.

Sugar alcohols represent the "P" in the FODMAP diet (polyols). They are not technically an artificial sweetener, though they do have a sweet taste, so they do not have to be disclosed on food labels.

Search for her on youtube - it's worth a watch.


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



trents Grand Master

Erythritol avoids many of the problems associated with other sugar alcohols and is safe unless used in large quantities.

plumbago Experienced
(edited)

Yeah, but the point of the video was that sugar alcohols are often hidden. I know little about erythriol, and as far as I can tell, that's not what the video was talking about - ie, two different things?

Editing to add to my reply here...So erythritol is actually a polyol, which is a sugar alcohol, the topic of her video, though she does not specifically mention it in her video. She says that the body never completely breaks down this compound, and intolerance develops due to reaching a threshold. Again, she doesn't specifically mention it, but being a polyol, I would assume she considers it just as potent a future problem as those she does name.

Edited by plumbago
RMJ Mentor

I think sugar alcohols have to be listed on the ingredient portion of a food label.  They do NOT have to be included on the Nutrition Facts portion of the label unless certain claims are made about the food. 

plumbago Experienced

According to the video @RMJ -- They are not technically artificial sweeteners so they do not have to be disclosed. Labels often just say "less sugar" or "sugar substitute."

I encourage folks to watch it.

trents Grand Master
(edited)

Not sure what the FDA requirement is but I often see them listed in ingredient labels.

Most sugar alcohols are not broken down well before they reach the colon and therefore can cause a lot of flatus. Erythritol is different in that respect. It is broken down and 90% absorbed before it gets to the colon. The only knock on it that I am aware of is that when used in large quantities it can cause arrythmia. But the quantity required to cause that effect is not likely to be reached unintentionally.

It also needs to be kept in mind that sugar alcohols are naturally found in may fruits and vegetables and some of them have pretty high concentrations of sugar alcohols. Prunes, for instance.

Pears are also high in sugar alcohol.

Edited by trents
plumbago Experienced
4 minutes ago, trents said:

Not sure what the FDA requirement is but I often see them listed in ingredient labels.

They may be listed, but that doesn't mean they are required to be listed. (Again, I encourage people to watch the video)

4 minutes ago, trents said:

It also needs to be kept in mind that sugar alcohols are naturally found in may fruits and vegetables and some of them have pretty high concentrations of sugar alcohols.

So - again, in the video - she says she's 95% better, and that 5% is from the sugar alcohols found in fruits. Her point is that it is now added in more and more things, and we are getting overexposed.


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



trents Grand Master

So, all the health experts tell us we eat way too much refined sugar and it causes obesity, diabetes and cardiac disease. All true. So, the food industry, in response to that, removed the refined sugar and replaced it with "0" calorie artificial sweeteners, some of which have cancer risk attached to them. So, the food industry responds to that issue and replaces artificial sweeteners with natural "0" calorie natural sweeteners like manitol, xylitol, sorbitol, ect. (i.e., the sugar alcohols). Really, the problem is we are addicted to sweet.

plumbago Experienced

Very much so. Two things can be true at once - sugar can lead to chronic disease (including cancer BTW), and sugar alcohols (again, technically not an artificial sweetener, according to the video), can lead to intolerance, causing bloating, gas, and pain.

If you ask me, and you didn't, we should be regulating sugar, high fructose corn syrup, and I guess artificial sweeteners and possibly sugar alcohols, as well. But alas, we don't. We just have to clean up the enormous problems they cause on the daily. It's a huge pain. I work in "healthcare."

RMJ Mentor

I don’t disagree that sugar alcohols can cause digestive problems, or that Americans eat too much sugar/sweeteners.  I just disagree with the labeling (mis)information. 

Maybe it’s different in Germany where the Sabine Hassenfelder is from, but I don’t find anything in FDA laws or regulations exempting sugar alcohols from the ingredient lists of foods. They don’t meet the requirements for an exemption.

Unless health claims about sugar alcohols or sugar are made on the package, where they do not have to be listed is in the nutrition facts total sugars area - which is a bit deceptive.

If mannitol or sorbitol are present at a level where more than 20 grams (mannitol) or 50 grams (sorbitol) is expected to be ingested there has to be a warning: Excess consumption may have a laxative effect.

plumbago Experienced

Here's what the FDA says - and again, please do watch the video.

Food manufacturers may voluntarily list the amount in grams (g) per serving of sugar alcohols on the Nutrition Facts label (under Total Carbohydrate). They may also list the name of a specific sugar
alcohol if only one is added to the food. But, food manufacturers are required to list sugar alcohols if
a statement is made on the package labeling about the health effects of sugar alcohols or sugars
(when sugar alcohols are present in the food)

https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/InteractiveNutritionFactsLabel/assets/InteractiveNFL_SugarAlcohols_October2021.pdf

plumbago Experienced

Anyway, I feel like maybe the forest is being missed, here, for the trees.

There's a higher percentage of the stuff that's been added to foods, than occurs naturally in fruit. That's one. Two, and this was my main point - if people with celiac disease are still having issues, it is certainly worth considering that it could be these sugar alcohols. I found the video impressive, and can only add for the thousandth time, that I think people should watch it.

RMJ Mentor
22 minutes ago, plumbago said:

Here's what the FDA says - and again, please do watch the video.

Food manufacturers may voluntarily list the amount in grams (g) per serving of sugar alcohols on the Nutrition Facts label (under Total Carbohydrate). They may also list the name of a specific sugar
alcohol if only one is added to the food. But, food manufacturers are required to list sugar alcohols if
a statement is made on the package labeling about the health effects of sugar alcohols or sugars
(when sugar alcohols are present in the food)

https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/InteractiveNutritionFactsLabel/assets/InteractiveNFL_SugarAlcohols_October2021.pdf

That is for the nutrition facts label which is separate from the ingredient list. I tried to make that clear in each of my posts.  I give up.

knitty kitty Grand Master

Great video, @plumbago!  

I agree wholeheartedly that sugar alcohols cause problems!  I avoid them like the plague.  

I've had problems with candies, mints, toothpaste, and lots of gluten free processed foods which contain one sugar alcohol or another.  The consequences just are not worth it!  

Found some interesting articles...

https://www.nih.gov/news-events/nih-research-matters/erythritol-cardiovascular-events

And...Sorbitol malabsorption in normal volunteers and in patients with coeliac disease

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3343011/

And...A Systematic Review of the Effects of Polyols on Gastrointestinal Health and Irritable Bowel Syndrome

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5508768/

Scott Adams Grand Master
On 1/20/2024 at 7:15 PM, plumbago said:

Anyway, I feel like maybe the forest is being missed, here, for the trees.

There's a higher percentage of the stuff that's been added to foods, than occurs naturally in fruit. That's one. Two, and this was my main point - if people with celiac disease are still having issues, it is certainly worth considering that it could be these sugar alcohols. I found the video impressive, and can only add for the thousandth time, that I think people should watch it.

I think this is a great topic for a Celiac.com article. I’ve always had issues with, and have avoided sugar alcohols and artificial sweeteners. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):



  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      126,105
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748

    Karen Adamson
    Newest Member
    Karen Adamson
    Joined

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):


  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      120.9k
    • Total Posts
      69.2k

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):





  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):



  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • Scott Adams
      My mother also has celiac disease, and one of her symptoms for many years before her diagnosis was TMJ. I believe it took her many years on a gluten-free diet before this issue went away.
    • Jeff Platt
      Ear pain and ringing your entire life may or may not be TMJ related but could be something else. A good TMJ exam would be helpful to rule that out as a potential cause from a dentist who treats that. I have teens as well as adults of all ages who suffer from TMJ issues so it’s not a certain age when it shows up.   
    • cristiana
      Not sure if related to coeliac disease but my ear ringing  has stepped up a notch since diagnosis.  Even since a child silence really hurts my ears - there is always a really loud noise if there is no other noise in a quiet room - but my brain has learned to filter it out.  Since diagnosis in my forties I also get a metallic ringing in my ears, sometimes just one, sometimes both.  But it comes and goes.   My sister also suffers now, we are both in our fifties, but she is not a coeliac, so for all I know it could just be an age thing.  I do get occasional stabbing pain in my ears but that has been all my life, and I do appear to be vulnerable to outer ear infections too.  So not a particularly helpful reply here, but I suppose what I am trying to say is it might be related but then again it could just be one of those things.   I think in the UK where I live doctors like you to report if you get tinnitus in just the one ear.  I reported mine but no cause was found.  Most of the time it is nothing but sometimes it can have a cause that can be treated, so perhaps worth reporting to your GP.  
    • Scott Adams
      Welcome to the forum, and thank you for sharing your story! It sounds like you’ve been through an incredible journey with your health, and it’s no wonder you’re starting to piece things together and wonder about celiac disease. Your experiences—from childhood through adulthood—paint a picture of symptoms that are often associated with celiac disease, though they can overlap with other conditions as well. The recurring sinus infections, being underweight as a child, chronic gastrointestinal issues, nutrient-related symptoms like cramps, and the persistent fatigue and brain fog are all things that many people with undiagnosed celiac report. Your reactions to gluten also stand out. The improvement in symptoms when you reduce or remove gluten, followed by the resurgence of pain and other problems when you reintroduce it, is a common experience for those with celiac or gluten intolerance. While your frustrations and trials with elimination diets might not have given you concrete answers yet, they’ve provided valuable clues. It’s also worth noting that celiac disease doesn’t always present in the classic way. Many people, like yourself, may not experience severe gastrointestinal distress but instead have “atypical” or extraintestinal symptoms like joint pain, menstrual irregularities, fatigue, and more. It’s a condition that can go undiagnosed for years, especially when symptoms are subtle, sporadic, or mistakenly attributed to other issues. The fact that you’ve sought alternative approaches to feel better shows just how determined you’ve been to find relief, even without a definitive diagnosis. Given your history and how your body responds to gluten, it would be worth exploring celiac disease further with a medical professional. Before removing gluten completely, it’s important to get tested while you’re still eating it, as going gluten-free beforehand can affect the accuracy of the results. A blood test for celiac antibodies (like tTG-IgA) is usually the first step, and if positive, an endoscopy may follow to confirm the diagnosis. If the testing process feels daunting, keep in mind that getting answers could give you clarity and help guide your health decisions going forward. Whatever the outcome, you’ve already made significant strides in identifying triggers and managing your symptoms. Your awareness and persistence are key, and this community is here to support you as you continue to seek answers. This article might be helpful. It breaks down each type of blood test, and what a positive results means in terms of the probability that you might have celiac disease. One test that always needs to be done is the IgA Levels/Deficiency Test (often called "Total IGA") because some people are naturally IGA deficient, and if this is the case, then certain blood tests for celiac disease might be false-negative, and other types of tests need to be done to make an accurate diagnosis. The article includes the "Mayo Clinic Protocol," which is the best overall protocol for results to be ~98% accurate.    
    • More2Learn
      Hi, I am new!  (Although I've used this forum as a reference over the past couple of years.) I'm just looking for some initial reactions to if I actually might possibly have Celiac Disease, or if I'm reaching here.  I have had lifelong health issues and not once has a doctor suggested I look into celiac. I always thought it was basically an extreme allergy that needed an EpiPen, and I know that's not me.  However, I stumbled upon some symptoms, realized I was wrong, and after some research I'm almost shocked at what I have found.  It seems like anything I've ever struggled with has a potential correlation to this disease!  I'm in my 40's, now.  Here is my journey to date... Issues as a Kid: tons of allergies, and had sinus infections all the time... however I didn't have hayfever-like allergies and the scratch tests didn't register much, it was more that when I was exposed to allergens (like say I spent hours with a cat) I was certain to get a sinus infection and it lasted months. was extremely skinny and everyone always said I was anorexic (I wasn't) always getting sick and the illnesses hang on for a long time always cold (my favorite thing to do is sit in front of a space heater or be out in 90 degree weather) intermittent bad constipation (still happens but not as severe) horrible toe cramps that would wake me up in the middle of the night As I got older (teenage/college years): acid reflux diagnosis learned that beer made me EXTREMELY sick, cannot tolerate it horrible issues with menstrual cycle - I wasn't regular, had awful cramps and PMS, sometimes cannot function the first couple of days night terrors/sleep walking more stomach issues - I learned I couldn't have black coffee.  I often had issues especially when traveling.  For example I finally noticed a pattern that I could never, ever eat at a hotel buffet spread - it would always make me sick afterwards. More recent problems: always tired periodic pain on right side that can be so painful I can't stand up straight. Have had all kinds of scans and doctors always say I'm fine.  I was so sure I had gallstones or my liver was failing but... nope. chest pain brain fog not diagnosed but many, many ADHD symptoms lots of inflammation, am overweight now toe cramps evolved into leg/calf cramps None of my symptoms from any era of my life ever really resolved, except I went from being skinny to ~20/30 pounds overweight, and as I got older I got less outright sinus infections.  Largely due to the pain in my right side and the fact that I always, always seem to pick up every illness, especially when traveling, I started pursuing alternative medicine paths... I did the Pritikin lifestyle, I tried an elimination diet, I followed the Root Cause Protocol, I did a Leptin reset.  A lot of these paths recommend removing gluten, and in the past year or so some of my symptoms have gone away!  Specifically less issues with toe cramps, sometimes the side pain would go away for a long time, and my acid reflux got much better.  But, because I was never diagnosed with any specific intolerance, I wasn't militant about the gluten - I had cut out dairy, soy, all kinds of things.  So I would say cross-contamination is ok, or make an exception at a group outing. Then one day, I just got frustrated and ate some normal slices of pizza... and my side pain came back!  I started doing research and now I'm here and wondering... could I have actually had this my whole life??!? Thoughts and observations welcome.           
×
×
  • Create New...