Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):

    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Gluten Challenge

debbie-doodles

Recommended Posts

debbie-doodles Contributor
debbie-doodles
Posted

My daughter has been diagnosed with celiac disease. She is now 3 and a half and was diagnosed last april. First she had the test, which came back negative, but I was told that it could come back negative in many kids. So then she had a biopsy. The doctor thought she had it, so she made me put her on a gluten free diet. We did see improvement, but she also has really bad reflux and so if she skips a pill for that, she's very sick (similar to when glutened). so then after going gluten free for a little over 7 months, he did another biopsy and said he was really sure she had it because the damage in her intestines had gotten better, etc. Now I saw him today and he said he is still trying to "rule out" celiac disease as what she has. There is a strong family history for it (a great uncle that had it and several great aunts that have wheat intolerance, but have never actually been tested). Now the doctor is ordering tests....Celiac Disease Panel. He said its to see if she has the gene for celiac disease. He also wants my husband and I tested to see if we carry the gene. Then he said if those come back positive, he wants to do a gluten challenge and that will tell us if she really has it. Isnt' that a bad idea? Isn't it feeding the very thing to my daughter that we've been trying to avoid? How much proof does this guy need? Should I refuse to do it? If the initial tests for the antibodies came back negative, then how does he know it will come back positive this time? What is he trying to accomplish by doing this?? I need help!

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


ravenwoodglass Mentor
ravenwoodglass
Posted
My daughter has been diagnosed with celiac disease. She is now 3 and a half and was diagnosed last april. First she had the test, which came back negative, but I was told that it could come back negative in many kids. So then she had a biopsy. The doctor thought she had it, so she made me put her on a gluten free diet. We did see improvement, but she also has really bad reflux and so if she skips a pill for that, she's very sick (similar to when glutened). so then after going gluten free for a little over 7 months, he did another biopsy and said he was really sure she had it because the damage in her intestines had gotten better, etc. Now I saw him today and he said he is still trying to "rule out" celiac disease as what she has. There is a strong family history for it (a great uncle that had it and several great aunts that have wheat intolerance, but have never actually been tested). Now the doctor is ordering tests....Celiac Disease Panel. He said its to see if she has the gene for celiac disease. He also wants my husband and I tested to see if we carry the gene. Then he said if those come back positive, he wants to do a gluten challenge and that will tell us if she really has it. Isnt' that a bad idea? Isn't it feeding the very thing to my daughter that we've been trying to avoid? How much proof does this guy need? Should I refuse to do it? If the initial tests for the antibodies came back negative, then how does he know it will come back positive this time? What is he trying to accomplish by doing this?? I need help!

If she has been gluten free the celiac panel tests will come back negative whether she has it or not. You do want to check everyone in the family who is still eating gluten with the panel but you can't really trust the results. The gene tests could be worthwhile but there are some who feel all the genes for celiac and gluten intolerance have not been found. Some of us just test negative no matter what. IMHO As far as the gluten challenge goes I would only do this if I had doubt. And if my child reacted at all that would be the end of the challenge. As far as the reflux goes have you eliminated dairy products? Many with celiac have a hard time with dairy. Some are able to tolerate it after it heals. The gluten type reaction you are seeing when she misses a pill may be withdrawl symptoms of a sort. Is there a possibility of talking to her doctor about weaning her off of these, even if you need to replace it with something else?

AndreaB Contributor
AndreaB
Posted

From what I understand by reading others posts is that children often come back false negative. The gene test would be a good idea. We just had the gene test done through enterolab and found out we all have 2 genes. 2 of us have 2 celiac genes and 2 of us have 1 each of celiac and gluten sensitive.

If she had a positive biopsy why does he need more proof? Have you asked him what else he thinks it could be if not celiac?

If you are eating soy that could still be causing problems with her intestines.

key Contributor
key
Posted

My son also had negative blood work when he was a year old, but at fourteen months we just took him off gluten. WE all saw the difference in him. Night and day! I think that if her intestines looked better now, then you know that gluten isn't good for her. I wouldn't do it if it were me. I don't really know what he is trying to accomplish, but the damage that it will do, will last awhile and set her back. It irritates me just to hear a doctor even suggest this.

ARe you sure she isn't getting any gluten anywhere? My friends son that doesn't have celiac (they don't know this for sure), but he is well over two and still has reflux. They don't know what causes his, but he is on meds all the time for it.

Like someone said, what about dairy?? Soy was giving me trouble. You may try eliminating these two at different times. Has she gained weight gluten free?

Obviously you have to do what is comfortable for you, but I wouldn't do it and I would maybe even find a second opinion if you are still concerned about the reflux.

Monica

  • 3 weeks later...
Guest greengirl
Guest greengirl
Posted

I think it's ridiculous that the doctor wants to put her through a gluten challenge now after she's been gluten free for 7 months! He saw improvement in the intestines and he wants to risk damaging them again just to be sure?!! Why not focus on maintaining and continuing the healing and monitoring her nutrient absorption? It really irks me that doctors doubt that dietary changes could be responsible for improvement if blood test numbers don't confirm the condition. Don't they know about the many, many people that blood tests miss!? When will the textbook knowledge that doctors live by catch up with what's going on in the real world?

I realize your post is a couple weeks old, so you may have made your decision by now. But if not, I would suggest getting a second opinion and be thankful that your daughter is healing! Good luck!

Christine

Satori Newbie
Satori
Posted

I would refuse to do it, you've seen the improvement and it could take several months to see the damage in the intestines again. Why put her through that misery just for the GI's benefit? She will surely rebel in her teens and you can test her then.

Guest nini
Guest nini
Posted

I would absolutely refuse to do it. If there is still some ongoing tummy issues, look into other intolerances as well. Like soy or dairy. If her biopsy was positive and then a follow up biopsy showed improvement after going gluten-free, she absolutely 100% has Celiac, just because her blood test results didn't concur with that is irrelevant. My daughter's blood test was negative and no biopsy, but 100% positive dietary response so she absolutely has Celiac... regardless of what blood tests show... (I'm still not convinced her Dr. even knew what he was talking about. He didn't do the complete Celiac panel)

after being gluten-free for 7 months a Celiac panel would absolutely come back negative, so I'm with you... what is he trying to prove?

the biopsy is 100% conclusive when it is positive end of discussion!

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):


  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      127,113
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    Vegan Brandy
    Newest Member
    Vegan Brandy
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121k
    • Total Posts
      69.9k
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):


  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • Soleihey
      Gluten Ataxia and Malabsorption

      By Soleihey · Posted

      I have been on supplementation for almost 11 months with no deficiencies showing up on blood work. So was just hoping to hear someone else’s story where it took longer to heal. 
    • Erain
      Orgain Protein Powder

      By Erain · Posted

      Here’s the answer from the company 😊   Hi Emily,    Thank you for reaching out to us! We can confirm the Organic Protein + 50 Superfoods Powder is gluten free. The organic barley and wheatgrasses we use are harvested prior to jointing, before the grain forms and any gluten protein is present. Rest assured appropriate measures are taken to ensure our gluten free products comply with the FDA final rule to be labeled as gluten free, as claimed on the side-panel label. Our suppliers are required to verify each ingredient and in order to ensure that our gluten free products comply with the FDA requirements, our manufacturing facilities use the ELISA test method to confirm gluten levels are less than the standard limit of <20 ppm.    If you have allergy concerns about consuming the grasses, we recommend consulting further with your healthcare provider. I hope this information helps! Please let us know if you have other questions.   
    • Erain
      Orgain Protein Powder

      By Erain · Posted

      That’s great to know. Thanks Scott
    • trents
      Postponing seeking a diagnosis?

      By trents · Posted

      Welcome to the forum, @kim-d! Recently revised guidelines or the "gluten challenge" recommends the daily consumption of at least 10g of gluten for at least two weeks up until the day of the antibody test blood draw. 10g of gluten is the amount found in about 4-6 slices of wheat bread. IMO, I would wait until you have time to do it right so as to remove all doubt as to whether or not your gluten consumption was adequate for long enough to ensure valid testing. In the meantime, focus on removing gluten from your diet and see how your symptoms improve (or not) as one piece of the diagnostic puzzle.
    • kim-d
      Postponing seeking a diagnosis?

      By kim-d · Posted

      Hello. I'm a 22 year old college student and I've had constant stomach problems since I was 14. Recently I noticed that my problems get worse when I eat more wheat. I tried to follow a gluten free diet, which didn't end up entirely gluten free, but I still had reduced my gluten consumption very much, and I felt a lot better. I also have fatigue, inability to gain any weight, iron deficiency, possible vitamin deficiencies, really bad memory and brain fog that increases by time, unexplainable muscle aches and tachycardia which all can possibly explained by celiac/NCGS.  I wasn't able to continue a completely gluten free diet as I am eating from my school and dorm's cafeteria and almost all food there have gluten so I was going very hungry. They do offer a gluten free menu with a report though. So I decided I should try getting a diagnosis if I can, especially after reading how it was much harder to do gluten challenge after quitting gluten for a while. I was able to get an appointment for next week, and started eating around 150gr of bread per day to be sure.  First 24 hours I didn't feel any worse so I was starting to doubt myself, but then bloating hit hard. It wasn't anything unbearable, but the problem is I have finals soon and I'm now realizing this is a really bad time to do this. I can't begin studying from pain distracting me. I'm thinking of cancelling the appointment and eat low gluten until exams are over.  I worry about one thing. Before I went low gluten, I was eating a lot of bread already for over a month, which is what clued me into gluten, and I only went low gluten for around 10 days before going high gluten again. I wasn't that worried about a false negative. But if I eat low gluten until my exams are over, it means over a month of low gluten, and I would need a lot more time eating high gluten later to get a correct result.  I'm not sure which one should I do, bear it until my appointment or cancel it and try again when I'm free later. And If I choose the second one, how long would I need to do the gluten challenge for a blood test?
×
×
  • Create New...