Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×
  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.




  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):



    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):


  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Response To Ny Times Article


Guest Bernice

Recommended Posts

Guest Bernice

A New York Times guest writer, Judith Warner, apparently said some things that people took issue with in a recent column titled, Less, and Less Often.

I found this reader's response in last weekend’s NY Times, but the original article is only available to paid online-subscribers, or in the printed copy. I didn't read the article in the paper, and had already thrown it out by the time the letter was printed.

To the Editor:

Judith Warner deplores parents' "joyless food-related fussiness (no gluten, no dairy, no pleasure — ever)." She should know that many of us, much as we would welcome the joy of eating gluten in our lives, cannot do so because we have celiac disease.

For us, consuming the gluten found in wheat, rye, oats and barley makes us feel unwell and threatens our long-term well-being. We fuss because we must.

Carolyn Makuen

Hartsdale, N.Y., June 30, 2006

Open Original Shared Link


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



Guest nini

this seems to be yet another instance of some author opening mouth and inserting foot, complaining about parents food fussiness, wasn't there some brou ha ha on Oprah not too long ago about the very same thing???

Some ignorant people spouting off about what they percieve to be parents just being overprotective, over reactive and just plain crazy, but they don't know a thing about Celiac or other food intolerances and what they can do.

just chalk it up to ignorance! If someone can find and share the orignial article that would be cool...

NicoleAJ Enthusiast

My school subscribes to NYT. Below is the actual paragraph the single sentence mentioning gluten came from. The article basically argues that the practice of 'grazing' on food should be reduced for American children. She believes that instead of feeding children several small portions of health foods each day that parents should give children a single cookie and milk at 4pm and somehow this will cure obesity. Even though she doesn't agree with grazing, she does believe that we need to reduce portion sizes (i.e. eating less and eating less often). Though the premise of reducing portion sizes is just fine, it seems to me that she really is ignorant about the fact gluten is not just a matter of being health conscious but that it is, in fact, a deadly substance to some and that a gluten-filled cookie and milk each day for a celiac, lactose intolerant child could actually kill said child.

"An excessive focus on ''good'' vs. ''bad'' food has its place, too, in the development of eating disorders, a much less frequent, but -- in the case of anorexia nervosa -- no less deadly problem than child obesity. And at the very least, the good-bad dichotomy feeds the joyless food-related fussiness (no gluten, no dairy, no pleasure -- ever) that's so prevalent among parents -- and that really ought, as a public mental health measure, to be targeted for extinction in the next generation."

Guest nini

I don't have time to do it right now, but ALL of us need to write the NYT and educate them that gluten free diets are NOT about weight control and not about parents having a mental disorder or feeding mental disorders...

we should demand a retraction of that paragraph and educate the author that many parents have their children on a gluten free diet because feeding them gluten causes them to be very ill and could even kill them... Most people don't even have a clue what gluten even is and think that a lot of us are just plain crazy. We need to educate as much as possible and remove this stigma that is becoming attached to gluten free. We are fussy because we HAVE to be.

gfp Enthusiast
I don't have time to do it right now, but ALL of us need to write the NYT and educate them that gluten free diets are NOT about weight control and not about parents having a mental disorder or feeding mental disorders...

we should demand a retraction of that paragraph and educate the author that many parents have their children on a gluten free diet because feeding them gluten causes them to be very ill and could even kill them... Most people don't even have a clue what gluten even is and think that a lot of us are just plain crazy. We need to educate as much as possible and remove this stigma that is becoming attached to gluten free. We are fussy because we HAVE to be.

I'm with you on that....

Not only is this insulting but it also directly causes us problems... next time you ask for gluten-free and the waiter gives you that knowing look, perhaps he has been reading the NYT.

ravenwoodglass Mentor
I don't have time to do it right now, but ALL of us need to write the NYT and educate them that gluten free diets are NOT about weight control and not about parents having a mental disorder or feeding mental disorders...

we should demand a retraction of that paragraph and educate the author that many parents have their children on a gluten free diet because feeding them gluten causes them to be very ill and could even kill them... Most people don't even have a clue what gluten even is and think that a lot of us are just plain crazy. We need to educate as much as possible and remove this stigma that is becoming attached to gluten free. We are fussy because we HAVE to be.

I agree and will do so this afternoon. If only I had known to be a 'fussy' food neurotic mother when my kids were young. My son would be more than 5' tall and my DD would not have permanent scars on her body from the psychological effects of the disease and the toxic meds they push on us. This is disgraceful and can be a real set back for folks struggling with the should I or shouldn't I question.

ms-sillyak-screwed Enthusiast
Open Original Shared Link

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



skbird Contributor

Here's the comment I made on the re-posted version of the article:

This author has no understanding of the true medical conditions that require adults and kids to eat gluten and dairy free. Celiac disease, which affects 1 person in 133 in the United States causes an autoimmune reaction in people who consume gluten. While obesity is becoming an obvious problem here in the US, Celiac is, as well, and is linked to many more fatal conditions than obesity. In fact, Celiac can also cause obesity.

This is the sentence from the author I object to, for it belittles parents who are right for making their children’s health a priority: “And at the very least, the good-bad dichotomy feeds the joyless food-related fussiness (no gluten, no dairy, no pleasure — ever) that’s so prevalent among parents — and that really ought, as a public mental health measure, to be targeted for extinction in the next generation.” It’s attitudes such as the author’s that ought to be targeted for extinction in the next generation.

I expected more compassion from a “TrueLiberal” site.

Stephanie

Comment by skbird | July 5, 2006

Stephanie

jenvan Collaborator
Here's the comment I made on the re-posted version of the article:

Stephanie

Love the response--esp the part about her attitude going extinct. Couldn't have said it better :)

queenofhearts Explorer

Wow... so now its "fussiness" to want your child to be well? Yikes. I just sent a reply too.

Leah

Guest nini

I am also a Celiac AND a parent of a child with Celiac disease, while the author makes some valid points about childhood obesity, her statement about “food related fussyness” especially in reference to no gluten, were extremely offensive to me. I wish that my parents had been that kind of fussy when I was a child. Then I wouldn’t have had years of health problems because of gluten. No, my parents fed me a diet rich in whole grains which they were told was healthy for me…

I demand a retraction of the statement about gluten in regards to food related fussyness. Unless you have been ill from food or have a child that gets violently ill from it, you have no business calling us fussy.

Comment by Nisla | July 5, 2006

here's my reply

2Boys4Me Enthusiast

Here's my reply:

The author’s comment “no gluten, no dairy” is completely out of line. I am sure the author is aware that wheat(gluten) and dairy are two of the top eight allergens. Would she consider “no peanuts” fussy? My son’s health is my first priority and you bet I’m “fussy” if it means I’m keeping gluten out of his system and maintaining his health now that we finally know that “healthy whole grain” food is the least healthy thing he can eat.

Linda

Comment by Linda | July 5, 2006

ms-sillyak-screwed Enthusiast

?

frenchiemama Collaborator

I left a comment on her blog.

"When I first heard of the ignorant “fussy” food statement regarding gluten and dairy I thought, “No, that can’t be right. She must have been misquoted. Surely anyone would do even a modest amount of research before making such a claim against gluten and dairy free diets.” Sadly, I was wrong. I can’t tell you how disappointed I am that someone would include gluten and dairy free diets in a rant against all that is wrong with eating in America.

Not only does this belittle anyone with Celiac Disease and/or dairy intolerance (I happen to have both), but it sets back our effort to have our needs taken seriously by society as a whole. Ms. Warner has done a disservice to everyone who struggles with a restrictive and MEDICALLY NECESSARY diet.

I hope that Ms. Warner receives a bit more understanding from others if she ever finds herself living such a life (with no joy, as she so thoughtfully put it). "

gfp Enthusiast

I might be wrong but I very much doubt she will really even be bothered by these comments.

Since we have several professional writers here why not write a measured complaint and let everyone add their names to it and send it to the editor as a complaint.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):



  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      128,009
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748

    cradford.cc
    Newest Member
    cradford.cc
    Joined

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):


  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121k
    • Total Posts
      70.6k

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):





  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):



  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • Bebygirl01
      Ortiz-Sánchez JP, Cabrera-Chávez F, de la Barca AM. Maize prolamins could induce a gluten-like cellular immune response in some celiac disease patients. Nutrients. 2013 Oct 21;5(10):4174-83. doi: 10.3390/nu5104174. PMID: 24152750; PMCID: PMC3820067. AND SEE: Oats Intolerance in Celiac Disease. PLoS Med. 2004 Oct;1(1):e23. doi: 10.1371/journal.pmed.0010023. Epub 2004 Oct 19. PMCID: PMC523841. AND ALSO SEE: Bascuñán KA, Orosteguí C, Rodríguez JM, Roncoroni L, Doneda L, Elli L, Araya M. Heavy Metal and Rice in Gluten-Free Diets: Are They a Risk? Nutrients. 2023 Jun 30;15(13):2975. doi: 10.3390/nu15132975. PMID: 37447301; PMCID: PMC10346754. Celiac disease is one of the most common autoimmune gastrointestinal diseases; over the last decades, its prevalence indicates a mean annual increase in frequency currently calculated at 7.5% per year [23]. celiac disease is triggered by gluten present in the diet and the disease involves autoimmune and inflammatory damage to the small intestine in genetically susceptible individuals. To develop celiac disease a person must inherit the genetic predisposition; however, about one third of the population carries the risk genes and only ~1% of the population develops the disease, indicating that genetics is not sufficient to explain the condition. The environment participates by providing the triggering factor, i.e., gluten, and the disease is activated by environmental factors which, until now, have not been fully understood, among which changes in eating habits and the intestinal microbiota are considered to be significant factors [24,25]; yet, current knowledge is insufficient to explain the mechanisms involved. Currently, the only treatment for celiac disease is a GFD for life. AND ALSO SEE: Dr. Osborne: Although rice is considered gluten-free based on the definition set forth by the FDA, rice does contain a different form of gluten prolamin called orzenin. In my experience, those with known celiac disease or non celiac gluten sensitivity issues do better when avoiding rice.
    • trents
      @Bebygirl01, if you want to play word games with the term, "gluten", we can do that. The proteins you list in these other cereal grains besides wheat, barley and rye are somewhat different from that found in wheat, barley and rye and, technically speaking, are not "gluten". Technically speaking, "gluten" should only be applied to a particular protein found in wheat, barley and rye. These other cereal grain proteins have their own names (avenin, secalinin, zein, etc). Unfortunately, confusion has been created in popular and pseudo scientific literature by the informal use of the term "gluten" when talking about the proteins found in these other cereal grains such that you sometimes read about "corn gluten", "oat gluten", "rice gluten", etc. But these are actually misnomers, with "gluten" having been added on as an informal appendage to the actual protein names. Having said that, the protein structures of these other cereal grains is close enough to gluten that, for some people, they can cause a celiac type reaction. But this is not true for most celiacs and those who fall into the NCGS category. Apparently, it is true for you. This whole idea that cereal grains are bad for all of us has been popularized by books such as Dangerous Grains for years but it is not a widely accepted idea in the scientific community.
    • Bebygirl01
      On my Celiac journey and discovered I was also reacting to other types of gluten. The FDA in it's finite wisdom only classifies 'wheat, barley and rye' as the gluten's to be considered when a company tests for and stamps their products as gluten free. I am curious as to how many of you are aware of the other types of glutens? And another question to those on a 'traditional' gluten free diet , who are also still sick and struggling, are you also reacting to these other types of gluten as listed below? NOTE:  The new movement if you want to call it that, is now called 'grain free' and that is the true definition of gluten free. I no longer suffer with ataxia, confusion, anxiety, depression, OCD, Insomnia, ADD, acid reflux, dermatitis herpetiformis, migraines, headaches, and weight issues all due to going 'grain free'. I hope to reach as many of you out there that are still struggling and unaware of what might be setting you off such as my most recent glutening was from a vegan supplement that contained 'magnesium sterate' and 'glucose syrup' both of which are from Zien (zane) gluten at 55%. I was covered in sores that were bleeding, I was seeing squigly lines when I was trying to drive, had acid reflux, insomnia, and nightmares all from the gluten in Corn. Here are the other types of glutens that Celiacs and Gluten Intolerant people also react to: Wheat -Alpha Gliadin Gluten- 69% Rye - Secalinin gluten-30-50% Oats-Avenin gluten -16% Barley-Hordein Gluten -46-52% Millet-Panicin Gluten-40% Corn-Zien Gluten -55% Rice-Orzenin Gluten-5% Sorghum-Kafirin gluten-52% and Teff-Penniseiten Gluten 11%.
    • Scott Adams
      I just want to mention again that IF thimerosal is used in a flu vaccine the amount of ethylmercury in a single vaccine dose would be extremely small, typically around 25 micrograms (µg) or less. For context, this is much lower than the levels of methylmercury found in some seafood. Ethylmercury is metabolized and excreted from the body much faster than methylmercury. Its half-life in the blood is about 7 days, compared to methylmercury, which can persist for months. The dose of ethylmercury in vaccines is far below the threshold known to cause toxicity so would not require chelation.
    • knitty kitty
      If you have poor reactions to vaccines, preservatives, sugar alcohols and metals, you may be deficient in Thiamine Vitamin B1.  Thiamine is needed in the immune response and production of antibodies.  Thiamine can be depleted by vaccines if you are already low to begin with due to the Malabsorption of Celiac Disease.  Thiamine can be destroyed by sulfide preservatives in vaccines, which can result in the body's poor response to vaccines.  Thiamine also chelates metals which allows those metals to be removed in the feces.  Chelation removes thiamine from the body, resulting in a state of thiamine deficiency.  Sugar alcohols need to be processed through the liver using thiamine.  Again, if you're low in thiamine as many Celiac are because of the Malabsorption of celiac disease, vaccines can be a tipping point, resulting in a thiamine deficient state. High doses of Thiamine required to correct thiamine deficiency states are safe and nontoxic.  Thiamine has no toxicity level.  Thiamine and the other B vitamins need to be taken together because they interact together to sustain health.   References: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25542071/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8533683/
×
×
  • Create New...