Jump to content

  • You are not alone. Join Celiac.com for trusted gluten-free answers and forum support.



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

Doctor Doesn't Think I Have It...

Chelle15

Recommended Posts

Chelle15 Apprentice
Chelle15
Posted

Ugh! It was not that I wanted to have a disease, but I wanted to have the ability to control my symptoms instead of it being IBS.

I went to see the GI doctor, he was a very nice man and listened intently to me. He went over the blood tests that my primary doctor did. He said they did a panel of 4, I think. He said, yes two did come back positive, but they are the least two significant positives on the panel. The other two more significant came back negative.

He is going to do the endoscope and colonoscopy. But he believes it is IBS, which I was diagnosed with before.

I felt like crying, I just want an answer to all of my problems and IBS is not a good enough answer for me. Based on what a lot of you have said in my prior posts, I may try a gluten free diet even if the endoscope comes back negative.

Any opinions would be appreciated. Thank you

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


Guest nini
Guest nini
Posted

personal opinion is to stop messing with Dr.s and just try the diet. If it works then viola! you have your answer. As much as the Dr.s like to rely on quantifiable tests, the truth is that the most valid diagnostic tool is how do you respond to the diet. Not, do you have sufficient damage YET to show up on tests... The blood tests and biopsy's are archaic and are only looking for the digestive symptom damage, not looking at any of the neurological symptoms or anything else for that matter. Based on my research even ONE positive in the panel is enough to suspect Celiac and then that can be CONFIRMED with positive dietary response. I was dx'ed with IBS 12 YEARS before I was dx'ed with Celiac. Had I been properly dx'ed back then how different would my life had been? First came the IBS dx, then came the Fibromyalgia dx, then the Infertility and Miscarriage issues, Depression/Anxiety disorder and on and on...

If YOU need a quantifiable test result, then Enterolab has a much better track record than any of the more conventional testing methods.

plantime Contributor
plantime
Posted

Even one positive result is still a positive result. Why do you need a doctor to do more tests? Try the gluten-free diet for 6 weeks, then evaluate how you feel.

ravenwoodglass Mentor
ravenwoodglass
Posted

I am going to strongly agree with the other posters. Get on the diet and see what happens. Relying on the doctors I relied on delayed my diagnosis by many painfull years and resulted in complications both neurological and physical that would never have happened if they had told me to try the diet instead of relying on their imperfect tests. The diet has given me my life, health and sanity back. Trust yourself and how you feel on the diet. IMHO doctors are very reluctant to diagnose us because then we would know how long we had been misdiagnosed for. Do the diet and see how you feel that is the truest test.

Chelle15 Apprentice
Chelle15
Posted
  • Author

Again, thank you for all of your support and time. Your posts have been very helpful. I guess I just want a dx because I feel like everyone will think it is some weird thing I am doing and that it is all in my head. I know I should not care about that, but I just so sick of everyone telling me it's IBS or nothing is wrong. I do believe I will try the gluten free diet. I want to feel better, so much! My family has history and crohns and stuff so I will go forward with the other tests, just in case there is anything else in there.

rinne Apprentice
rinne
Posted

I agree with everyone above, try the diet as a diagnostic tool. See for yourself how you feel.

I am proceeding with tests to rule out other problems but I went gluten free the day I learned about Celiac and that my sister has it too. That was in early May and I am still not okay but I am doing better. I have also had to cut out dairy and nightshades and coffee and sugar....and what I have realized is that to get to the point where I lost 40 pounds, over 5 months, means that I am ill and that it will take time to recover.

My sister was diagnosed with IBS prior to the Celiac diagnosis, she was told that her primary problem was the IBS and that she had a wheat allergy and should avoid it. :angry: Not one word about gluten from the Doctor, she continued for five years to eat gluten and has gotten sicker and sicker. Do I trust Doctors? No.

bklynceliac Apprentice
bklynceliac
Posted

I'm surprised he was so discouraging even with some positive bloods. I had negative blood work and negative biopsies, but have responded extremely well to the diet. I have been told with certainty that I don't have the disease, and received a somewhat perfunctory "maybe it's ibs". I just saw a new doctor yesterday and he said "forgot the other doctors, do what's make you feel better". I was very happy to hear that. He told me I was crazy if I started eating gluten again if i knew it was making me sick. And he's a real doctor, not some hippy dippy herbalist or something. It's seems so obvious, but I really appreciated having a doctor say it.

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


wacky~jackie Rookie
wacky~jackie
Posted
Again, thank you for all of your support and time. Your posts have been very helpful. I guess I just want a dx because I feel like everyone will think it is some weird thing I am doing and that it is all in my head. I know I should not care about that, but I just so sick of everyone telling me it's IBS or nothing is wrong. I do believe I will try the gluten free diet. I want to feel better, so much! My family has history and crohns and stuff so I will go forward with the other tests, just in case there is anything else in there.

I can relate to your wanting a definite dx. I know we shouldn't worry about what others think but I know my family (not my husband & kids - but my in-laws and such) will think I'm just on another crazy diet like Atkins. I think I'll just tell them that I have been diagnosed. How will they know the difference. B)

Nancym Enthusiast
Nancym
Posted

IBS isn't a diagnosis. It's a catch-all for "we don't know".

I suggest, you just go on the gluten-free diet and see how it works. That's how I came by my diagnosis, and I had IBS for years and years. If you want something official looking, get tested by Enterolab.com. It's the only decent test out there (IMHO).

Deb O (UK) Apprentice
Deb O (UK)
Posted
personal opinion is to stop messing with Dr.s and just try the diet. If it works then viola! you have your answer. As much as the Dr.s like to rely on quantifiable tests, the truth is that the most valid diagnostic tool is how do you respond to the diet. Not, do you have sufficient damage YET to show up on tests... The blood tests and biopsy's are archaic and are only looking for the digestive symptom damage, not looking at any of the neurological symptoms or anything else for that matter. Based on my research even ONE positive in the panel is enough to suspect Celiac and then that can be CONFIRMED with positive dietary response. I was dx'ed with IBS 12 YEARS before I was dx'ed with Celiac. Had I been properly dx'ed back then how different would my life had been? First came the IBS dx, then came the Fibromyalgia dx, then the Infertility and Miscarriage issues, Depression/Anxiety disorder and on and on...

If YOU need a quantifiable test result, then Enterolab has a much better track record than any of the more conventional testing methods.

I agree!! I have recently tested positive on 1 antibody and like so many others I've spent time wondering what that means and if I ought to have a biopsy etc. I was dx with IBS about 12 years ago and it was about 20 years ago that my stomach started bloating. I've now got a new doctor who, when I described my symptoms, said straight away that he'd check my blood for celiac (and many other things). On getting the result he referred me to a dietician. I saw him again yesterday to talk with him about a biopsy. He was brilliant - he discussed it WITH me and said it was an option, but like Nini he asked what is the point? He encouraged me to get started on the diet and said that feeling better on a gluten-free diet would be my diagnosis. What with the support I've recieved from this board, and a sensible doctor, I feel I'm on my way to recovery, without yet going gluten-free :D

I'm getting things in place and hope to start gluten-free in a couple of weeks and I can't wait :lol:

Chelle15 Apprentice
Chelle15
Posted
  • Author

Thank you so much for your responses. It really helps. I guess I just always feel like a hypocondriac(sp?), and I feel like everyone else thinks that too. That is the reason for a dx, for my own peace of mind. I LOVE this board.

Thank you , thank you...

jcc Rookie
jcc
Posted
Ugh! It was not that I wanted to have a disease, but I wanted to have the ability to control my symptoms instead of it being IBS.

I went to see the GI doctor, he was a very nice man and listened intently to me. He went over the blood tests that my primary doctor did. He said they did a panel of 4, I think. He said, yes two did come back positive, but they are the least two significant positives on the panel. The other two more significant came back negative.

He is going to do the endoscope and colonoscopy. But he believes it is IBS, which I was diagnosed with before.

I felt like crying, I just want an answer to all of my problems and IBS is not a good enough answer for me. Based on what a lot of you have said in my prior posts, I may try a gluten free diet even if the endoscope comes back negative.

Any opinions would be appreciated. Thank you

Check out the pages on Diagnostic Testing (including Delay of Diagnosis) and Fibromyalgia (there is more "IBS" in there). I agree with others who say that a dietary trial is a wise move. My daughter had only an isolated antigliadin IgG of 30, the weakest of the markers. She had chronic diarrhea for two years and neurological symptoms...and some rashes...everything resolved gluten free.

Open Original Shared Link

Be sure to request copies of your blood results and your biopsy report!

jcc

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Celiac.com:
    Donate
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):



    Celiac.com Sponsors (A17-M):



  • Recent Activity

    1. Aretaeus Cappadocia
      - Aretaeus Cappadocia replied to cristiana's topic in Related Issues & Disorders
      1

      Low iron/high normal haemoglobin

      Not sure what you mean by "poor iron levels" if 30 is normal (upper end of normal range) and you are 29. (at least, that's how I read your post. Seems to me that your iron (ferritin) is normal, whereas before it was too high (40). At any rate, your post made me curious, so I copy pasted "Does it actually matters if my iron levels are poor, if my hemoglobin...
    2. cristiana
      - cristiana posted a topic in Related Issues & Disorders
      1

      Low iron/high normal haemoglobin

      Hello All I think I started a thread on this subject some time ago, but now can't find it. Or possibly it was someone else's thread that I hijacked - and that's why I can't find it! Anyway, I have a rather complicated issue with iron and I'm wondering what to do about it. Or even if it matters. Pre-menopause, when I was first diagnosed with...
    3. Scott Adams
      - Scott Adams replied to JForman's topic in Coping with Celiac Disease
      11

      7yo struggling!

      This would definitely be an interesting study. We did an article on this a while back:
    4. Scott Adams
      50

      Celiac Disease Treatment and Continuing Symptoms

    5. Scott Adams
      - Scott Adams commented on Scott Adams's article in Diagnosis, Testing & Treatment
      4

      New Study Reveals Hidden Gut Damage in Celiac Disease—Even Without Gluten (+Video)

      Inulin fiber may help:
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      134,170
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      10,442
    yvonne jacobs
    Newest Member
    yvonne jacobs
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.7k
    • Total Posts
      1m
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):

  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • Aretaeus Cappadocia
      Low iron/high normal haemoglobin

      By Aretaeus Cappadocia · Posted

      Not sure what you mean by "poor iron levels" if 30 is normal (upper end of normal range) and you are 29. (at least, that's how I read your post. Seems to me that your iron (ferritin) is normal, whereas before it was too high (40). At any rate, your post made me curious, so I copy pasted "Does it actually matters if my iron levels are poor, if my hemoglobin is normal" into the google search bar. According to Dr google, it does matter and they had a lot to say about it.
    • cristiana
      Low iron/high normal haemoglobin

      By cristiana · Posted

      Hello All I think I started a thread on this subject some time ago, but now can't find it.  Or possibly it was someone else's thread that I hijacked - and that's why I can't find it! Anyway, I have a rather complicated issue with iron and I'm wondering what to do about it.  Or even if it matters. Pre-menopause, when I was first diagnosed with coeliac,  my ferritin levels were dreadful and I had to supplement.  It soon became apparent that I had to stop, as once my iron anemia cleared up, my hemoglobin levels reached high normal, verging on a condition known as polycythemia.   High normal in my lab is 15.5 for women, and my level has hovered between 15 and 15.5 The highest my ferritin levels have ever been is 40 (30 being normal) since I started my gluten-free journey - I reached that level about three years ago., about a year post menopause.  18 months later my ferritin had gone down to 29, which I think I can explain because I've been avoiding red meat.  This was a conscious decision as I have  discovered that I can keep my hemoglobin levels at safe levels so long as I don't consume too much iron.  My gastroenterologist also told me not to supplement it.     I have recently had a colonoscopy and have done a FIT test to detect bleeding, both came back normal.  So I feel that the reduced iron consumption is probably the reason for this new deficiency.  But I have two questions: A. Does it actually matters if my iron levels are poor, if my hemoglobin is normal?  (I do feel a bit tired, but surely if my hemoglobin levels are normal I shouldn't?) B. Would my last TTG blood result of 10 (cut off point for normal levels at my lab)  be affecting my absorption of iron? Thanks! Cristinaa  
    • Scott Adams
      7yo struggling!

      By Scott Adams · Posted

      This would definitely be an interesting study. We did an article on this a while back:  
    • Scott Adams
      Fiber-Metabolizing Bacteria Could Boost Gut Health in Celiac Disease

      By Scott Adams · Posted

      We recently posted a summary here:  
    • Aretaeus Cappadocia
      7yo struggling!

      By Aretaeus Cappadocia · Posted

      For people of European ancestry, 2% is about average, depending on which study you look at. For Asian ancestry it can be higher. For full Sub-Saharan African ancestry it is zero, but in practice they tend to have trace amounts due to migration back into Africa. While each individual may have 1-3% Neanderthal DNA, it is not always the same DNA that is Neanderthal. Estimates are 20-70% for which parts of the human genome might be Neanderthal in any given individual. Another way of saying this is that 20-70% of the Neanderthal genome survives in the human population. The HLA genotypes that confer susceptibility to celiac (necessary but not sufficient) are known to be of human in origin. There are some other genes known to be associated with a higher probability for getting celiac (with the right HLA genotype) that are associated with Neanderthal DNA. However, there is no correlation between quantity of Neanderthal DNA and probability of getting celiac. Neanderthal DNA is associated with other autoimmune diseases. Lupus, Crohn's disease, and rheumatoid arthritis are probably the most strongly associated diseases.
×
×
  • Create New...