Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):

    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

When To Do A Skin Biopsy

krisb

By krisb
in Dermatitis Herpetiformis

Recommended Posts

krisb Contributor
krisb
Posted

Since I've been gluten free a year ago the blisters on my elbows have been perfect unless I go out to eat and don't question the food. I never had a biopsy but I might in the future. Anyway, I went to Friendly's to eat the other day and my elbows are raging and I have blisters all in my mouth. I didn't question what I ate because I am pregnant and was starving. I'm assuming that the sauces on my chicken had gluten. Should I go and have it biopsied while it's inflamed? Or maybe I should just wait until I'm done being prego. Either way i know gluten does this to me but it would be good to know if it was DH. How long after a breakout can you do a biopsy? I figure that by time I get an appointment to do it my elbows will be better.

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


Michi8 Contributor
Michi8
Posted
Since I've been gluten free a year ago the blisters on my elbows have been perfect unless I go out to eat and don't question the food. I never had a biopsy but I might in the future. Anyway, I went to Friendly's to eat the other day and my elbows are raging and I have blisters all in my mouth. I didn't question what I ate because I am pregnant and was starving. I'm assuming that the sauces on my chicken had gluten. Should I go and have it biopsied while it's inflamed? Or maybe I should just wait until I'm done being prego. Either way i know gluten does this to me but it would be good to know if it was DH. How long after a breakout can you do a biopsy? I figure that by time I get an appointment to do it my elbows will be better.

I believe a biopsy can be done at any point (regardless if a lesion is active or not.) The key is that the tissue is taken from the normal skin beside the lesion, not the lesion itself.

In terms of biopsing during pregnancy, that is up to you. However, I believe you should be vigilant about staying 100% gluten free to ensure you have a healthy pregnancy and birth.

Michelle

Guest Educator
Guest Educator
Posted

My drmatologist said the biopsy has to be done on a blister that has not yet opened to get accurate results, otherwise the test will return non-conslusive or maybe as a false negative. I say get it ithere as soon as you can. Being pregnant doesn't matter. The biopsy is a simple slice of the effected area where the non bursted blister is. Good luck and best wishes. Kris

My drmatologist said the biopsy has to be done on a blister that has not yet opened to get accurate results, otherwise the test will return non-conslusive or maybe as a false negative. I say get it ithere as soon as you can. Being pregnant doesn't matter. The biopsy is a simple slice of the effected area where the non bursted blister is. Good luck and best wishes. Kris

Michi8 Contributor
Michi8
Posted
My drmatologist said the biopsy has to be done on a blister that has not yet opened to get accurate results, otherwise the test will return non-conslusive or maybe as a false negative. I say get it ithere as soon as you can. Being pregnant doesn't matter. The biopsy is a simple slice of the effected area where the non bursted blister is. Good luck and best wishes. Kris

Is your dermatologist saying that the sample must be taken from the lesion or beside the lesion? If it is from the lesion, then he is incorrect... Peter H.R. Green, MD, Director of the Celiac Disease Center at Columbia University, wrote on the subject of skin biopsy for DH in his recent book.

From Celiac Disease: A Hidden Epidemic:

"The gold standard for diagnosis is a skin biopsy of uninvolved skin adjacent to an eruption -- best taken within millimeteres of a lesion. The biopsy must be done by a knowledgeable dermatologist because a sampling of tissue from the eruption itself can be confused with other skin conditions. A biopsy of the actual lesion will give a characteristic appearance, but it is not possible to do the immunological staining that is necessary to make the diagnosis. This is because the inflammatory reaction in the blistering lesion destroys the early signs of the immune deposits that are still present in adjacent tissue."

I believe not all (or many?) dermatologists are familiar enough with Celiac and DH to test properly, and some will even insist that the biopsy must be of the actual lesion. Perhaps that is standard when testing for other health issues, but as mentioned in the above quote, testing for DH in this manner gives inaccurate results.

Michelle

krisb Contributor
krisb
Posted
  • Author

How do you find a good dermatologist that knows how to do it right?

Michi8 Contributor
Michi8
Posted
How do you find a good dermatologist that knows how to do it right?

I'd ask here to see if anyone has recommendations of drs in your area. I can't give you my dermatologist's name, because he did the biopsy wrong (and got a negative result of course!) :angry:

Michelle

Fiddle-Faddle Community Regular
Fiddle-Faddle
Posted

Does anyone know why UNINVOLVED, apparently healthy skin should be biopsied? I know Peter Green is the reigning deity of celiac MD's, but he also says the gold standard of diagnosis is the intestinal biopsy, and I certainly don't agree with him there!

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


Michi8 Contributor
Michi8
Posted
Does anyone know why UNINVOLVED, apparently healthy skin should be biopsied? I know Peter Green is the reigning deity of celiac MD's, but he also says the gold standard of diagnosis is the intestinal biopsy, and I certainly don't agree with him there!

The reason was in the paragraph I quoted. :) Dr Green is not the only source of this information. Biopsy (skin & intestinal), for good or bad, is still considered to be the gold standard, and will be until other testing methods become standard. Personally, I put more faith in the word of a Dr who specializes in the study and treatment of celiac disease, than in a dermatologist who does not specialize in it.

Michelle

Fiddle-Faddle Community Regular
Fiddle-Faddle
Posted
The reason was in the paragraph I quoted. :) Dr Green is not the only source of this information. Biopsy (skin & intestinal), for good or bad, is still considered to be the gold standard, and will be until other testing methods become standard. Personally, I put more faith in the word of a Dr who specializes in the study and treatment of celiac disease, than in a dermatologist who does not specialize in it.

Michelle

Absolutely! Hmm, somehow I missed the paragraph of explanation. Serves me right for skimming, I suppose!

I'm just questioning it because I had what I'm reasonably sure was DH (it led to the blood test that showed my IgA off the charts), and when I went off gluten, the rash disappeared (as did the stomach problems that I had been ignoring to the point where I didn't realize I had any until they went away). My skin biopsy--taken from unblemished skin next to the lesions--was totally negative.

Dr. Green does not address the fact that most PCP's and even most dermatologists, will prescrible Prednisone to get rid of the rash way before they decide to biopsy to find the cause of it. I believe that Prednisone taken within a month or two (or maybe more?) of the biopsy screws up the test results.

I don't give a flying fig about gold standards: there is no good reason to biopsy the intestines if there is a positive response to the diet and no other problems. Intestinal biopsy is not only invasive, it is only useful if the MD happens to biopsy the right sites. Not all villi are affected at the same rate!

Michi8 Contributor
Michi8
Posted
Absolutely! Hmm, somehow I missed the paragraph of explanation. Serves me right for skimming, I suppose!

I'm just questioning it because I had what I'm reasonably sure was DH (it led to the blood test that showed my IgA off the charts), and when I went off gluten, the rash disappeared (as did the stomach problems that I had been ignoring to the point where I didn't realize I had any until they went away). My skin biopsy--taken from unblemished skin next to the lesions--was totally negative.

Dr. Green does not address the fact that most PCP's and even most dermatologists, will prescrible Prednisone to get rid of the rash way before they decide to biopsy to find the cause of it. I believe that Prednisone taken within a month or two (or maybe more?) of the biopsy screws up the test results.

Dr Green does go on to say, "No tests in medicine are 100 percent, not everyone with dermatitis herpetiformis will have a positive skin biopsy. A negative biopsy should not necessarily be used to exclude the diagnosis if the legions look and act like dermatitis herpetiformis and occur after the ingestion of gluten. Patients should be retested, making sure that both the lab technique and specimen taken are appropriate for determining the diagnosis."

Michelle

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):


  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      127,053
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    Suelibrarian
    Newest Member
    Suelibrarian
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121k
    • Total Posts
      69.9k
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):


  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • knitty kitty
      Black Pepper Reactions

      By knitty kitty · Posted

      Canker sores can be more frequent if deficient in zinc, Thiamin B1, Riboflavin B2, Pyridoxine B6, Cobalamine B12, Folate B9, iron and Vitamin D.   Following a low histamine paleo diet helps heal.  Mast cells in our body make histamine and release it as a part of the inflammation process.  Foods that contain high histamine levels can make inflammation worse.  Mast cells get "itchy triggers" and can release histamine when exposed to some spices and foods.  The vitamins listed above are also required to clear histamine along with Vitamin C.  Following a low histamine diet like @Mari and @Blue Roanand keeping a food journal like @Blue Roan does are excellent ways to travel on our Celiac journey.
    • Scott Adams
      High dosage of B12 gave me life.

      By Scott Adams · Posted

      Nature Made B-Complex (Costco) contains 2mg of B6, which is close to the RDA for it.
    • knitty kitty
      Coping with celiac

      By knitty kitty · Posted

      @dlaino, Which symptoms are getting worse for you?   Which vitamins do you take?   Do you take Vitamin D?
    • knitty kitty
      Diabetic 2

      By knitty kitty · Posted

      Hello, @Lightingthunder2, I understand how confusing Celiac can be, especially when one develops other health problems. I developed Type Two Diabetes and was prescribed Metformin.  I started feeling weak and tired.  I searched for answers using my nutrition and microbiology education to find answers.   I learned that Metformin can cause Thiamin Vitamin B1 deficiency.  Metformin blocks the thiamin transporters that allow thiamin to enter cells.   Keep in mind that Celiac Disease causes poor absorption of all nutrients, vitamins and minerals that our bodies require daily to live.  Thiamin can be rapidly depleted because it cannot be stored for very long (3 - 21 days).  With Metformin blocking entry into cells and malabsorption from celiac disease, thiamine deficiency can set in quickly.  The early symptoms of thiamine insufficiency can be vague and easily be attributed to other things, like a bad day at work, and doctors can easily overlook the symptoms.  Doctors aren't well educated in nutritional deficiencies.  My doctors were clueless.   I took thiamin in the form Benfotiamine and followed the Autoimmune Paleo diet (developed by Dr. Sarah Ballentyne, a Celiac herself).  Benfotiamine has been shown to promote intestinal healing.  The Paleo diet cuts out most high carbohydrate foods.  This helps me keep my blood glucose levels under control without Metformin or other medications.  Now, I do add in occasionally rice or potatoes.  I avoid most gluten free processed foods since they are not enriched with vitamins like gluten containing products and are filled with saturated fats.  I do not take any pharmaceuticals for high blood glucose.  I control my type two diabetes with diet, and take Benfotiamine. Thiamine deficiency is found in both Type One and Type Two Diabetes.  Thiamin is not properly reabsorbed in the kidneys in both types.  Since thiamin is water soluble, it is lost easily in urine.  Type One Diabetes has a genetic component which involves thiamine transporters in cells not functioning properly due to faulty genetic information.  Type Two Diabetes may result as a consequence of thiamine insufficiency.  Ninety-eight percent of diabetics in both types are Thiamin deficient.   Discuss with your doctor and Nutrutionist any dietary changes and supplementing with essential vitamins and minerals while you are healing. Here are some articles I found helpful.  Thiamine and diabetes: back to the future? https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8505293/ The potential role of thiamine (vitamin B1) in diabetic complications https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18220605/ Thiamine Level in Type I and Type II Diabetes Mellitus Patients: A Comparative Study Focusing on Hematological and Biochemical Evaluations https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32528766/ Exploring the link between dietary thiamine and type 2 diabetes mellitus risk in US adults aged 45 years and older: Insights from a cross-sectional investigation https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39642136/ Metformin Is a Substrate and Inhibitor of the Human Thiamine Transporter, THTR-2 (SLC19A3) https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26528626/  
    • Scott Adams
      Can food allergies like milk and soy flatten villi?

      By Scott Adams · Posted

      I'm not a gastro doctor, but it seems reasonable to conclude that they would be able to spot any cancer-related issues during the endoscopy, at least in the areas that were checked.
×
×
  • Create New...