Jump to content

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

When To Do A Skin Biopsy

krisb

By krisb
in Dermatitis Herpetiformis

Recommended Posts

krisb Contributor
krisb
Posted

Since I've been gluten free a year ago the blisters on my elbows have been perfect unless I go out to eat and don't question the food. I never had a biopsy but I might in the future. Anyway, I went to Friendly's to eat the other day and my elbows are raging and I have blisters all in my mouth. I didn't question what I ate because I am pregnant and was starving. I'm assuming that the sauces on my chicken had gluten. Should I go and have it biopsied while it's inflamed? Or maybe I should just wait until I'm done being prego. Either way i know gluten does this to me but it would be good to know if it was DH. How long after a breakout can you do a biopsy? I figure that by time I get an appointment to do it my elbows will be better.

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


Michi8 Contributor
Michi8
Posted
Since I've been gluten free a year ago the blisters on my elbows have been perfect unless I go out to eat and don't question the food. I never had a biopsy but I might in the future. Anyway, I went to Friendly's to eat the other day and my elbows are raging and I have blisters all in my mouth. I didn't question what I ate because I am pregnant and was starving. I'm assuming that the sauces on my chicken had gluten. Should I go and have it biopsied while it's inflamed? Or maybe I should just wait until I'm done being prego. Either way i know gluten does this to me but it would be good to know if it was DH. How long after a breakout can you do a biopsy? I figure that by time I get an appointment to do it my elbows will be better.

I believe a biopsy can be done at any point (regardless if a lesion is active or not.) The key is that the tissue is taken from the normal skin beside the lesion, not the lesion itself.

In terms of biopsing during pregnancy, that is up to you. However, I believe you should be vigilant about staying 100% gluten free to ensure you have a healthy pregnancy and birth.

Michelle

Guest Educator
Guest Educator
Posted

My drmatologist said the biopsy has to be done on a blister that has not yet opened to get accurate results, otherwise the test will return non-conslusive or maybe as a false negative. I say get it ithere as soon as you can. Being pregnant doesn't matter. The biopsy is a simple slice of the effected area where the non bursted blister is. Good luck and best wishes. Kris

My drmatologist said the biopsy has to be done on a blister that has not yet opened to get accurate results, otherwise the test will return non-conslusive or maybe as a false negative. I say get it ithere as soon as you can. Being pregnant doesn't matter. The biopsy is a simple slice of the effected area where the non bursted blister is. Good luck and best wishes. Kris

Michi8 Contributor
Michi8
Posted
My drmatologist said the biopsy has to be done on a blister that has not yet opened to get accurate results, otherwise the test will return non-conslusive or maybe as a false negative. I say get it ithere as soon as you can. Being pregnant doesn't matter. The biopsy is a simple slice of the effected area where the non bursted blister is. Good luck and best wishes. Kris

Is your dermatologist saying that the sample must be taken from the lesion or beside the lesion? If it is from the lesion, then he is incorrect... Peter H.R. Green, MD, Director of the Celiac Disease Center at Columbia University, wrote on the subject of skin biopsy for DH in his recent book.

From Celiac Disease: A Hidden Epidemic:

"The gold standard for diagnosis is a skin biopsy of uninvolved skin adjacent to an eruption -- best taken within millimeteres of a lesion. The biopsy must be done by a knowledgeable dermatologist because a sampling of tissue from the eruption itself can be confused with other skin conditions. A biopsy of the actual lesion will give a characteristic appearance, but it is not possible to do the immunological staining that is necessary to make the diagnosis. This is because the inflammatory reaction in the blistering lesion destroys the early signs of the immune deposits that are still present in adjacent tissue."

I believe not all (or many?) dermatologists are familiar enough with Celiac and DH to test properly, and some will even insist that the biopsy must be of the actual lesion. Perhaps that is standard when testing for other health issues, but as mentioned in the above quote, testing for DH in this manner gives inaccurate results.

Michelle

krisb Contributor
krisb
Posted
  • Author

How do you find a good dermatologist that knows how to do it right?

Michi8 Contributor
Michi8
Posted
How do you find a good dermatologist that knows how to do it right?

I'd ask here to see if anyone has recommendations of drs in your area. I can't give you my dermatologist's name, because he did the biopsy wrong (and got a negative result of course!) :angry:

Michelle

Fiddle-Faddle Community Regular
Fiddle-Faddle
Posted

Does anyone know why UNINVOLVED, apparently healthy skin should be biopsied? I know Peter Green is the reigning deity of celiac MD's, but he also says the gold standard of diagnosis is the intestinal biopsy, and I certainly don't agree with him there!

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


Michi8 Contributor
Michi8
Posted
Does anyone know why UNINVOLVED, apparently healthy skin should be biopsied? I know Peter Green is the reigning deity of celiac MD's, but he also says the gold standard of diagnosis is the intestinal biopsy, and I certainly don't agree with him there!

The reason was in the paragraph I quoted. :) Dr Green is not the only source of this information. Biopsy (skin & intestinal), for good or bad, is still considered to be the gold standard, and will be until other testing methods become standard. Personally, I put more faith in the word of a Dr who specializes in the study and treatment of celiac disease, than in a dermatologist who does not specialize in it.

Michelle

Fiddle-Faddle Community Regular
Fiddle-Faddle
Posted
The reason was in the paragraph I quoted. :) Dr Green is not the only source of this information. Biopsy (skin & intestinal), for good or bad, is still considered to be the gold standard, and will be until other testing methods become standard. Personally, I put more faith in the word of a Dr who specializes in the study and treatment of celiac disease, than in a dermatologist who does not specialize in it.

Michelle

Absolutely! Hmm, somehow I missed the paragraph of explanation. Serves me right for skimming, I suppose!

I'm just questioning it because I had what I'm reasonably sure was DH (it led to the blood test that showed my IgA off the charts), and when I went off gluten, the rash disappeared (as did the stomach problems that I had been ignoring to the point where I didn't realize I had any until they went away). My skin biopsy--taken from unblemished skin next to the lesions--was totally negative.

Dr. Green does not address the fact that most PCP's and even most dermatologists, will prescrible Prednisone to get rid of the rash way before they decide to biopsy to find the cause of it. I believe that Prednisone taken within a month or two (or maybe more?) of the biopsy screws up the test results.

I don't give a flying fig about gold standards: there is no good reason to biopsy the intestines if there is a positive response to the diet and no other problems. Intestinal biopsy is not only invasive, it is only useful if the MD happens to biopsy the right sites. Not all villi are affected at the same rate!

Michi8 Contributor
Michi8
Posted
Absolutely! Hmm, somehow I missed the paragraph of explanation. Serves me right for skimming, I suppose!

I'm just questioning it because I had what I'm reasonably sure was DH (it led to the blood test that showed my IgA off the charts), and when I went off gluten, the rash disappeared (as did the stomach problems that I had been ignoring to the point where I didn't realize I had any until they went away). My skin biopsy--taken from unblemished skin next to the lesions--was totally negative.

Dr. Green does not address the fact that most PCP's and even most dermatologists, will prescrible Prednisone to get rid of the rash way before they decide to biopsy to find the cause of it. I believe that Prednisone taken within a month or two (or maybe more?) of the biopsy screws up the test results.

Dr Green does go on to say, "No tests in medicine are 100 percent, not everyone with dermatitis herpetiformis will have a positive skin biopsy. A negative biopsy should not necessarily be used to exclude the diagnosis if the legions look and act like dermatitis herpetiformis and occur after the ingestion of gluten. Patients should be retested, making sure that both the lab technique and specimen taken are appropriate for determining the diagnosis."

Michelle

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Celiac.com:
    Join eNewsletter
    Donate
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):



    Celiac.com Sponsors (A17-M):



  • Recent Activity

    1. Rejoicephd
      - Rejoicephd commented on Scott Adams's article in Origins of Celiac Disease
      8

      Do Antibiotics in Babies Increase Celiac Disease Risk Later in Life? (+Video)

      I had actually forgot about the stretch of time that I was on antibiotics for acne. The more I think back on it, I was on antibiotics for a very good chunk of my childhood and into teenage years for a range of issues.
    2. knitty kitty
      - knitty kitty replied to Known1's topic in Gluten-Free Foods, Products, Shopping & Medications
      1

      Reverse Osmosis (RO) Water

      I've heard RO water is bad, too. Distilled water has all the minerals distilled out of it, so it will pull minerals out of your bones, too. I only use distilled water to fill up my clothes iron so it won't get mineral deposits inside and quit working. I drink mineral or spring water.
    3. Yaya
      - Yaya replied to Yaya's topic in Gluten-Free Foods, Products, Shopping & Medications
      2

      Great Value Veggies cannot be trusted.

      Scott. Thank you for your reply. I'm still having symptoms, but significantly better. I will go back to batch cooking and freezing vegetables. I have had success with Pict Sweet frozen, single item (not mixed) vegetables. My Kroger carries very little Pict Sweet variety. Regards, Yaya
    4. Known1
      - Known1 posted a topic in Gluten-Free Foods, Products, Shopping & Medications
      1

      Reverse Osmosis (RO) Water

      I am hesitant to post this as I have seen many people here recommending RO water. With that said, I want to share my experience and how RO water now impacts me. Three or four years ago a local store installed a RO water refill station. I had been buying gallons of distilled and spring water prior to that. I switched over to using the RO water refill station...
    5. Known1
      - Known1 posted a topic in Gluten-Free Foods, Products, Shopping & Medications
      0

      What would you do - neighbor brought gluten-free pizza from Papa Murphy's

      My neighbor's mom was diagnosed with celiac disease 16 years ago. She is a very kind person and has shared some info about local grocery stores and daily (soon to expire) meat deals. This evening she brought over 2 slices of Papa Murphy's gluten-free pizza. It looks to be topped with chicken and spinach. I asked, "aren't you concerned with cross contamination...
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      133,446
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    DH Larry
    Newest Member
    DH Larry
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.6k
    • Total Posts
      1m
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):

  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • knitty kitty
      Reverse Osmosis (RO) Water

      By knitty kitty · Posted

      I've heard RO water is bad, too.   Distilled water has all the minerals distilled out of it, so it will pull minerals out of your bones, too.  I only use distilled water to fill up my clothes iron so it won't get mineral deposits inside and quit working. I drink mineral or spring water.  
    • Yaya
      Great Value Veggies cannot be trusted.

      By Yaya · Posted

      Scott.  Thank you for your reply. I'm still having symptoms, but significantly better.  I will go back to batch cooking and freezing vegetables.  I have had success with Pict Sweet frozen, single item (not mixed) vegetables.  My Kroger carries very little Pict Sweet variety. Regards, Yaya
    • Known1
      Reverse Osmosis (RO) Water

      By Known1 · Posted

      I am hesitant to post this as I have seen many people here recommending RO water.  With that said, I want to share my experience and how RO water now impacts me.  Three or four years ago a local store installed a RO water refill station.  I had been buying gallons of distilled and spring water prior to that.  I switched over to using the RO water refill station saving money by brining in my own clean empty gallon jugs.  Every 6-months I would replace the jugs by buying new gallons of distilled water.  This RO water is the only water I would drink while at home.  Two huge glasses every morning before work and two more after work.  I would also use the RO water to make coffee and hot coco. This past December, prior to my celiac diagnosis, my gut was making more noise than anything I had ever experienced.  Seriously, it was crazy, almost like fire works going off in my stomach.  I happened to pick up some distilled water for my 6-month jug rotation.  Literally, as soon as I started drinking the distilled water my stomach settled a great deal.  I could honestly feel the difference after the first glass of water.  I thought that maybe the RO water from the store's refill station was contaminated with some sort of cleaning agent.  I swore to myself I would never drink from that RO refill station again.  Instead I went back to buying distilled along with gallon jugs of spring water.  No issues with either of those as far as an upset stomach is concerned.  Cost, well that's a different story all together. After being diagnosed marsh 3c, I went shopping at Aldi's for the first time in my life.  I noticed they also sell water by the gallon.  Over the course of the last few weeks, I have purchased a total of 6-gallons of their water.  (Thankfully they were out on two of my visits.)  After having my stomach starting to make noises similar to mid-December again, it dawned on me, maybe its the Aldi water?  Initially I had contributed my bubble gut to some sort of gluten exposure or cross contamination.  Even though everything I have put into my stomach is naturally gluten-free or has been labeled gluten-free / certified gluten-free.  I had assumed that the Aldi water was spring water.  Come to find out, that was a bad assumption.  Looking close at the label it says purified by RO or distillation (or something like that). Again, I switched to different water.  Just like last December, the non-RO water instantly calmed my stomach and even felt better going down the hatch.  This was earlier today by the way.  Prior to creating this post, I did a few searches via Uncle Google.  I bumped into a thread on Reddit (where I am not a member) that has multiple people complaining of GI issues related to RO water.  So my initial thoughts on a cleaning agent in the refill station RO water were likely not correct.  Unfortunately, it seems the RO water itself causing me problems.  I am not sure if we are allowed to post links to other sites and hopefully I will not get into trouble for doing so.  I did try printing the Reddit thread to a PDF file.  Unfortunately, the file is 2MB in size, which is well over the 500KB file attachment limit here on this amazing forum.  Again, hopefully this is ok.  🤞  Here is the Reddit thread. This may not be a popular opinion here, but personally, I will not willingly drink another glass of RO water for the remainder of my life.  Who knows, maybe drinking RO water for the past several years is part of what activated my celiac?  No proof, but just a thought.  Come to find out RO water is well known to leech minerals from your body.  With people like us often lacking minerals to begin with, RO water does not seem like a wise choice.  As the Reddit thread mentions, there are RO water filtration systems that will inject minerals back into the water.  However, those systems are likely not being used at the grocery store refill stations nor by the bottling companies producing RO water for sale at your local store. Please do not shoot the messenger as I am just sharing my personal experience and letting others know that most RO water will leech minerals from your body. God bless and stay well, Known1
    • Known1
      What would you do - neighbor brought gluten-free pizza from Papa Murphy's

      By Known1 · Posted

      My neighbor's mom was diagnosed with celiac disease 16 years ago.  She is a very kind person and has shared some info about local grocery stores and daily (soon to expire) meat deals.  This evening she brought over 2 slices of Papa Murphy's gluten-free pizza.  It looks to be topped with chicken and spinach.  I asked, "aren't you concerned with cross contamination"?  She said no and apparently eats it on a somewhat regular basis. I found an old article here along with another thread pertaining to Papa Murphy's gluten-free pizza.  The article is quite old, so I do not think it holds much weight nowadays.  The thread I found was also a bit dated, but certainly more recent and relevant.  The information in the thread I found was a bit inconclusive.  Some said they trust Papa Murphy's gluten-free pizza and others were a big no way.  One person even took time to train their local franchise on how to ensure the pizza remains gluten-free without cross contamination. Anyway, being recently diagnosed as marsh 3c, I am currently working on week 3 or 4 in my new gluten-free journey.  I do not want to be rude and toss the pizza out, but I also do not want to have a reaction.  Since she has celiac and obviously ate much or at least some of the pizza, I am leaning towards eating the two slices for lunch tomorrow.  As this thread's title states, what would you do?  Would you eat it or toss it out?  I suppose I could also just give it back to my neighbor to polish off. I look forward to reading your thoughts. Thanks, Known1
    • Scott Adams
      Great Value Veggies cannot be trusted.

      By Scott Adams · Posted

      That must have been really upsetting to discover, especially after relying on a product you believed was safe. Labeling can change at any time due to supplier shifts or shared equipment, so it’s always important to double-check packaging—even on products we’ve trusted for years. A “may contain wheat” statement usually indicates potential cross-contact risk rather than an added ingredient, but for people with celiac disease that risk can still be significant. If you’ve been having symptoms, it may take days to weeks to fully settle, depending on the level and duration of exposure. In the meantime, switching to fresh produce or brands that clearly state gluten-free status is a reasonable step. It may also help to contact the manufacturer directly to ask when the labeling changed and what their current cross-contact controls are.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

NOTICE: This site places This site places cookies on your device (Cookie settings). on your device. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.