Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):

    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Confused!

clhsc

Recommended Posts

clhsc Apprentice
clhsc
Posted

I am so confused! I just got the results of my blood test and they came back normal. How can this be? I have proven to myself time and time again that I have some problems with digesting wheat and wheat products.

At my appointment, my doctor said that I have classic celiac symptoms and was obviously having some malabsorption problems. My response to the diet (when I did it before my exam and now) have been overwhelmingly positive. What's the deal? I am confused and frustrated because I feel like I am back to square one. Should I go through with the colonoscopy (scheduled for Dec. 4) and the scope (will talk about it on Dec. 4) or cancel? Should I stay on the gluten free diet? Is it possible to have celiac disease or gluten sensitivity without a positive blood test?

I know it's not all in my head because I try to convince myself that I feel better than I do. I need some advice - quick - before I completely lose it! Please help me!

Thank you!

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


mommida Enthusiast
mommida
Posted

It is not uncommon for blood tests to show nothing and a person has very obvious symptoms after ingesting gluten. I can not even try and count all the members on the board are self diagnosed, because of negative blood work and negative biopsy. If you still have other concerns, have the other testing done to be sure there are not other issues along with the "gluten intolerance". Stay on the gluten free diet and never have to get a label of "pre-existing condition" for health insurance or pay a higher premium for life insurance.

I know it is very frustrating , but it may the nicest gift not to have a paperwork diagnoses. ;)

L.

Guest nini
Guest nini
Posted

you do have your answer you know... positive dietary response is more valid than any diagnostic tool out there. The rate of false negatives with the blood tests is way higher than the medical community will publicly acknowledge. If you have already been gluten-free before testing that would skew your test results, and since you've already been playing around with the gluten-free diet, if you do the biopsy, the chances are you could easily get a false negative with that as well. My personal opinion is that how your body responds to the diet is a much clearer indication of what is going on then any tests... reason? The tests are only looking for specific markers which only show up in the latter (more final) stages of the disease, so you may have caught it early enough that your body is reacting, but you haven't yet produced enough of the antibodies to show up in conventional testing. You may be IgA deficient, which would also make your results appear negative...

More and more Dr's are starting to recognize dietary response as a valid diagnostic tool when the blood tests and even biopsies are inconclusive.The advantage of not having an "official" dx is that it does not appear on your permanent medical records and you can't be denied health insurance or life insurance coverage because of it.

I doubted my "self dx" for too long and I let an ignorant Dr. talk me into going back to eating gluten when I was pregnant with my daughter, and I ended up having a very complicated pregnancy, a premature baby, very nearly died, and it took another 3 years before I was OFFICIALLY dx'ed with Celiac, by that time I was VERY ill. Don't wait until you are extremely ill to change your diet and accept that you are gluten intolerant. You do not need a official dx from a Dr. in order to stay on the diet. It's all up to you.

mommida Enthusiast
mommida
Posted

Thanks Nini,

You said that way better than I did. :D

L.

clhsc Apprentice
clhsc
Posted
  • Author

Thanks for your help! I truly appreciate it. :)

What is an IgA deficiency?

Guest nini
Guest nini
Posted
Thanks for your help! I truly appreciate it. :)

What is an IgA deficiency?

Open Original Shared Link

here's a link that explains it... a lot of people that have had false negatives for Celiac have been found to have IgA deficiency, which puts you at risk for other autoimmune disorders as well. The bottom line is that it doesn't matter if it's Celiac or not, if your body is reacting to gluten, you need to avoid it. If you wish to be tested for other autoimmune disorders that is fine, but you don't have to be eating gluten for any of those tests... and a lot of the autoimmune disorders, like Lupus and Arthritis, have shown improvement of symptoms on a gluten free diet, so is it Celiac??? Maybe not, is it something else? Maybe. Is your body reacting to gluten? YES. Do you need to be gluten free? Yes. Can you still have other autoimmune disorders? Yes.

tarnalberry Community Regular
tarnalberry
Posted

I'd have a couple questions for more details before I could be helpful:

1) Which tests were run and what were the results?

2) Had you been gluten free prior to blood testing, and if so, for how long gluten-free and how long back on gluten?

In the end, however, a postive response on the dietary challenge is the most important - a blood test does not overrule your body's response.

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


clhsc Apprentice
clhsc
Posted
  • Author
I'd have a couple questions for more details before I could be helpful:

1) Which tests were run and what were the results?

2) Had you been gluten free prior to blood testing, and if so, for how long gluten-free and how long back on gluten?

In the end, however, a postive response on the dietary challenge is the most important - a blood test does not overrule your body's response.

1. They ran the Celiac Disease Andibody Screening with Reflex Profile, Sedimentation Rate-Westergren, and C-Reactive Protein (Quantative). The C-Reactive Protein was low (.80 mg/L) out of a range of 0.0 to 4.9. I couldn't read the others on the fax so I have called the office to find out the numbers.

2. I had been gluten-lite (very lite - like if I accidentally ate some, none on purpose) since July.

I am so glad I found this forum - it's nice to know there are others like me out there!

Ursa Major Collaborator
Ursa Major
Posted

Unfortunately, you have one of those ignorant doctors who doesn't know that being gluten-free for four months would result in a false negative, even if you would have tested positive in July. And it is very likely that the endoscopy will be negative for celiac disease as well, same reason.

However, if you want to really know and have an 'official' paper, try Open Original Shared Link. You don't have to be eating gluten for their test, which is way more sensitive than conventional testing.

Also, it doesn't look like your doctor ordered the right tests, anyway. Not that it would have mattered.

The bottom line is, that you feel terrible eating gluten, and feel much better without it. That is enough evidence of at least gluten intolerance, anyway. Stay off it (and don't be talked into a gluten challenge, either) and be happy you figured it out.

clhsc Apprentice
clhsc
Posted
  • Author
1. They ran the Celiac Disease Andibody Screening with Reflex Profile, Sedimentation Rate-Westergren, and C-Reactive Protein (Quantative). The C-Reactive Protein was low (.80 mg/L) out of a range of 0.0 to 4.9. I couldn't read the others on the fax so I have called the office to find out the numbers.

2. I had been gluten-lite (very lite - like if I accidentally ate some, none on purpose) since July.

I am so glad I found this forum - it's nice to know there are others like me out there!

Here are the results. Please advise as to what the heck this means...

Celiac Antibody Screening:

IgA: 1 with Negative being 0 - 4

TIgA: 1 with Negative being 0 - 3

Immunoglobin A: 86 with ranges of 70 - 400

Sedimentation Rate: 1 with ranges of 0 - 20 (Mom borderline Lupus)

C-Reactive Protein: 0.8 with ranges of 0 - 4.9 (Dad has colitis)

aikiducky Apprentice
aikiducky
Posted

What Ursula said - you have been gluten free for too long to get a positive test result. In order to have a positive test at this point you would need to go back on gluten, and not gluten lite but three four slices of bread every day, for several months. Personally I wouldn't do it, but it's your decision.

Pauliina

tarnalberry Community Regular
tarnalberry
Posted
1. They ran the Celiac Disease Andibody Screening with Reflex Profile, Sedimentation Rate-Westergren, and C-Reactive Protein (Quantative). The C-Reactive Protein was low (.80 mg/L) out of a range of 0.0 to 4.9. I couldn't read the others on the fax so I have called the office to find out the numbers.

2. I had been gluten-lite (very lite - like if I accidentally ate some, none on purpose) since July.

I am so glad I found this forum - it's nice to know there are others like me out there!

Well, what tests are in the celiac screening? It should have included, at least, antigliadin IgA, antigliadin IgG, tissue transglutamase (tTg) IgA, tTg IgG, and total IgA.

If you've been essentially gluten-free for five months, then there's a good chance that your tests would be negative, even if you had celiac disease. You can't show antibodies to something that isn't in your body, even if your body *would* react if that thing were to be there.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):


  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      127,836
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    RyanOB
    Newest Member
    RyanOB
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121k
    • Total Posts
      70.4k
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):


  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • knitty kitty
      Hidden Gluten in distilled vinegar

      By knitty kitty · Posted

      @Manaan2,  I'm so happy to hear you're going to try thiamine and magnesium!  Do let us know the results!   You may want to add a B 50 Complex with two meals of the day to help boost absorption.  Thiamine interacts with each of the other B vitamins which are all water soluble.   When supplementing magnesium, make sure to get sufficient calcium.  Calcium and magnesium need to be kept in balance.  If you choose a calcium supplement, take two hours apart from magnesium as they compete for absorption.  Take Calcium with Vitamin D.  Vitamin D helps calm the immune system.   For pain, I use a combination of thiamine, B12 Cobalamine, and Pyridoxine B6.  These three vitamins together have analgesic effects.  My preferred brand is "GSG 12X Takeda ALINAMIN EX Plus Vitamin B1 B6 B12 Health Supplementary from Japan 120 Tablets".  Alinamin is another form of thiamine.  It really is excellent at relieving my back pain from crushed vertebrae without side effects and no grogginess.   Look into the low histamine version of the Autoimmune Protocol Duet (Dr. Sarah Ballentyne, a Celiac herself, developed it.)  It really helps heal the intestines, too.  It's like a vacation for the digestive system.  Add foods back gradually over several weeks after feeling better.   I'm so happy to have pointed the way on your journey!  Let us know how the journey progresses! P. S. Add a Potassium supplement, too.  Potassium is another electrolyte, like magnessium, that we need.
    • Manaan2
      Hidden Gluten in distilled vinegar

      By Manaan2 · Posted

      @knitty kitty I can't thank you enough!  My husband and I already started looking into those supplements.  We definitely plan to give it a try.  We've been against the Miralax since it was originally advised by PCP, but because of the level of pain she experienced on a daily basis, we decided to try it.  We've made many attempts to gradually decrease but due to her pain and related symptoms, we've kept her on it while trying all sorts of other dietary adjustments pre and post diagnosis specific to food; so far none of those efforts have made a significant difference.  I will definitely share how she's doing along the way!
    • BIg Nodge
      Opinions on my test results/symptoms

      By BIg Nodge · Posted

      Hi, I have recently embarked on the gluten-free journey. I have what to me seems like a somewhat confusing set of test results and symptoms. I have been impressed by the accumulated knowledge and thoughtfulness as I browse this forum, so I figured I'd make a post to see if anyone can offer any insight. I know there are many posts like this from new users, so I have tried to do my baseline research first and not ask super obvious questions.  I'm 43, overall very healthy. No history of gluten sensitivity or really any of the classic GI symptoms. About three years ago I started to experience intermittent bouts of fatigue, chills/cold intolerance, and shortness of breath/air hunger (sometimes feels like a hollowness in my chest, hard to describe). The symptoms over time have become fairly significant, though not debilitating, I am able to exercise regularly and am fairly physically active, continue to perform well at work. But for example I have gone from someone who consistently ran hot, was always cranking the a/c, to someone who wears a down vest inside at work in winter and get chills if the a/c even blows on me in summer. I get tired and lose energy even when getting decent amounts of sleep, and have to have my wife take over on long drives that I could previously handle with no problems. More generally when I am experiencing these symptoms they seem to crowd out space in my mind for focusing on my family, my hobbies/activities etc, I sort of withdraw into myself.   I happened to be experiencing these symptoms during an annual physical with my PCP a few years ago, he observed post nasal drip and suggested it was allergies and that I treat it with claritin. At first it seemed to respond to claritin (though not zyrtex), but over time I became unsatisfied with that answer. There didn't seem to be any seasonal rhyme or reason to my symptoms, and I felt like I was on an endless loop of taking claritin, then stopping, not being sure if it was even making a difference. I did eventually get allergy tests and found modest allergies to dust and pollen, which didn't feel like a smoking gun.  I then started seeing a natural medicine doctor who was much more willing to explore my symptoms via testing. The first thing that came back abnormal was elevated thyroid peroxidase antibodies/TPOs, 137 IU/mL vs a reference range of <9. At the same time my thyroid panel showed normal thyroid hormone levels. So it appears my immune system is attacking my thyroid even though it is working fine. I got a thyroid ultrasound at the time, it was clear, but with some abnormalities such that they suggested I get is scanned again in a year. These are certainly risk factors for a thyroid autoimmune disease, though my thyroid seems to be working fine for now.  From here my doctor considered celiac due to the murky thyroid/celiac links, so we did a panel. Results were as follows: TT IGA <1 U/ml, TT IGG <1 U/ml, deamidated gliadin IGA 24.6 U/ml, deamidated gliadin IGG <1 U/ml, IGAs 170 mg/dL. Readings greater than 15 considered high by my lab for the first four, my IGAs are within reference range. So basically just the deamidated IGA popped, but my IGAs are normal. I also notice on the tests that my thyroglobulin was high, 86.7 ng/ml vs a range of 2.8 - 40.9.  My doctor suggested that it certainly wasn't conclusive for celiac, but it was possible, and likely that I have some sort of gluten sensitivity. She suggested going gluten free and seeing how I felt as opposed to doing a biopsy. The best theory I can come up with is perhaps I am a silent celiac or just have a gluten sensitivity that doesn't produce immediate GI symptoms, but is still doing damage and over time has caused leaky gut. So now gluten is getting into my blood, and my immune system is attacking it but also mistakingly attacking my thyroid.  So that's what I did, went gluten free in October. It's been about four months, and I am really not feeling any difference. I still get the same symptoms that come and go. My bowel movements may be a bit more regular, but it was never a major issue before so I would consider that a minor improvement. I know that it can take a while to see improvements, and I am going to remain gluten-free and see how I feel. But I am definitely questioning whether I really understand what is going on, and am open to any thoughts or suggestions from the forum. Sometimes I wish I just went ahead with the biopsy before going gluten-free. While I would certainly be down to start drinking IPAs again ahead of a biopsy, you know, for science, I feel like at this point I would be throwing away four months of work and am better off staying the course and seeing what happens. But I'm really not sure.  I know there is a lot of thyroid knowledge on these boards, along with the celiac expertise, so I'm curious if this resonates with anyone's experience. And I'm interested in what sort of timelines people have experienced in terms of feeling improvements for some of these non-GI symptoms like chills, SOB, brain fog etc. Thanks in advance. 
    • cameo674
      Testing positive for antibodies, are there visible changes to the colon that could be seen without a biopsy?

      By cameo674 · Posted

      Does it taste like black licorice?  It said it was chewable.  I do not like that flavor.     Since the burn at the back of my throat is there everyday, I usually only take something when it is unbearable and keeping me from ADL especially sleep.  
    • Scott Adams
      Nandos improper preparion celiac childrens food

      By Scott Adams · Posted

      Your concerns about Nando's cross-contamination practices are valid and important for the celiac community. It's disappointing that Nando's does not have stricter protocols for children's portions, especially given the risk of cross-contact with gluten-containing items like garlic bread. Cooking gluten-free items on shared surfaces, even if cleaned, is not safe for individuals with celiac disease, as even trace amounts of gluten can cause harm. While the adult butterfly chicken may be a safer option, the inconsistency in practices for children's meals is concerning. It's frustrating that Nando's headquarters did not take responsibility, but sharing your experience raises awareness and may encourage them to improve their protocols. Consider reaching out to celiac advocacy organizations to amplify your concerns and push for better standards. Always double-check with staff and emphasize the importance of avoiding cross-contamination when dining out.
×
×
  • Create New...