Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×
  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.




  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):



    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):


  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Could Diagnosis Be Wrong?


ana

Recommended Posts

ana Rookie

I had a positive blood test and a slight flattening of my villi in the biopsy results. My Dr. felt it was definitive Celiac. I often wonder if he wuold have felt like that had i not told him my family history, my mom and nephew with it. I really don't want to have this diagnosis. I find it hard to adhere to the diet. I told my dad, maybe the dr. was wrong, i don't have a huge anti-body count or my villi wasn't totally damaged. my dad agreed, but he doesn't want to think i have it either.

but the Dr. felt i was healing because i'd been on Gluten free for 3 weeks before the biopsy, endoscopy. i have had something gluten, tortillas, and get the big D, but then i have tried it again and it was just an upset tummy, bloating and gas for a couple days. i didn't get violently ill like some people here say they do when they get glutened. I've been diagnosed since October and have been trying to be gluten-free since then.

So is it possible to have a false positive diagnosis?


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



happygirl Collaborator

Ana,

You have classic, textbook-case Celiac Disease. Your doctor is correct. Any flattening of the villi is indicative of Celiac (that is what Celiac is). You have positive bloodwork and a positive biopsy...your doctor is right when he said that this is definitively Celiac. You have what Celiac experts call a 'gold standard' diagnosis.

It doesn't matter the level of your antibodies, or the level of damage. Its kind of like being pregnant. You either are or you aren't----you can't be a little bit pregnant. You had the two positive tests: you are just as much of a Celiac as someone who technically had "higher" counts or "worse" villi damage. Plus, if you had biopsies taken in another area, it could have shown even worse damage (the disease is not uniform...parts might be fine, parts may be damaged).

Symptoms vary: from person to person, and even within the same person. You might have one symptom one time, and another symptom another time. There are even (medically documented) Celiacs with absolutely no symptoms, but villi damage. So difference in symptoms, or comparing your symptoms to someone else does not diagnose/undiagnose you :) Sorry!

Let us know what we can do to help make the diet easier. It is a hard thing to get used to, but I am confident that you can do it.

Laura

Lisa Mentor

Ana:

Celiac is celiac. With a positive blood test and positive endoscopy that's a pretty clear definition.

I, myself, when feeling my lowest, thought that I had intestinal cancer. And to be finally diagnosed with Celiac was something to celebrate. I did not have cancer or other ailments that needed drugs to cure, or just maintain.

I can control this disease. I don't have to take drugs and if I control my diet, I can live a healthy life style.

Every gluten that you consume will continue to destroy your intestines. You need to know that gluten is considered "rat poison".

I want to welcome you to this board and would suggest that you read, read and read somemore. It is the best source of information that you can get.

I am sure that others will post and welcome you as well. Your health is in information. You are in good company here. :)

Fiddle-Faddle Community Regular

Welcome, Ana!

If it makes you feel any better, some of us here have only mild bloating, mild constipation/looses stools when we have a whole spaghetti dinner! (That would describe me--I have NEVER gotten violently ill from gluten.)

What keeps me adhering to the gluten-free diet (besides for actually seeing my waist again after the bloating went away!) is the knowledge that I will develop other autoimmune disorders if I go back to gluten. I already have autoimmune thyroid disease, and that's more than enough for me. There are so many long-timers here who have or had fibromyalgia, lupus, rheumatoid arthritis, MS symptoms, etc. I don't want to go down that path, and there is only one way to avoid it.

The good news is that there are geniuses out there who have figured out how to make EVERYTHING we like gluten-free (and good-tasting!), from pizza crust to bread to cakes to cookies to pie crusts to biscuits to pancakes to pasta to.....

Whatever you might be craving, put up a post about it, and 10 people will respond with recipes or websites to order it!

The only difficulty is eating out--but many of us have found that we are getting far fewer viruses now that we eat out so much less! And many restaurants are starting to have gluten-free menus, and you nkow the # will only go up! And a nice side benefit is that most of us find that we are making much more healthy food choices now.

A little denial is probably a normal reaction--but you can only stick your head in the sand for so long. At least you found your way here--whatever you need--support, shoulders to cry on, a safe place to vent, recipes, ideas, where to buy things, etc--this is the best place to be!

Now--what part of this diet is the hardest for you? Maybe we can help you find ways around the difficulties.

Aerin328 Apprentice

It's really hard to face, and difficult to do. But as the previous poster commented, you don't want to wait until it is too late. I was healthy for years, and then *bam*- I was bed-ridden for months. Auto-immune illness is terrible to escape from once you're in its cycle, so try to avoid getting sucked into the cycle! Go gluten-free! :) All here will be available to support you. Good luck!

Christian

Jestgar Rising Star

Hi Ana,

I know the diet is hard to adjust to when you're first getting started, but like anything, it gets easier with practice. Stick with it, and stick with the board, we'll get you through it!

chrissy Collaborator

i know about those thought of denial----i had them when my 3 girls were diagnosed------and we only had one "iffy" biopsy between the 3 of them. they were diagnosed with positive bloodwork. since being gluten free, one daughter's nausea went away, one daughter's rashes cleared up and the other one did not have obvious symptoms, although since being gluten free we have seen some of her old problems reoccure when she gets gluten. all three of my girls have had their antibody levels drop since going gluten free, so there is no doubt that they havae celiac.

non-celiacs seem to think the diet is much harder than celiacs do. after i had several meltdowns before one of my girls made some good tasting bread-----then i quit crying. my twins have become quite good cooks since going gluten free, and my 11 yr old makes a fantastic caramel corn (gluten-free, of course).

it will eventually get easier, i promise.


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



tarnalberry Community Regular

You have positive blood tests (even after being gluten free).

You have a positive biopsy (even after being gluten free).

You have symptoms after eating gluten.

You have celiac. There is *no* question about it, and thank goodness it's such a clear cut case!

You need to be gluten-free. For life.

I know it's hard now, but it will get easier with time if you make the effort to adapt to the change. Many of us find it only just a small inconvenience in our lives, even if we're dealing with other food intolerances as well, after a while. Keep reading and keep researching for lots of ways to make the transition easier - it's not easy; it's a tough psychological change, but you can do it!

lovegrov Collaborator

I'd agree there's no question you have celiac.

richard

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):



  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      127,983
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748

    Kari Shover
    Newest Member
    Kari Shover
    Joined

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):


  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121k
    • Total Posts
      70.5k

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):





  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):



  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • trents
      I am a male and had developed osteopenia by age 50 which is when I finally got dx with celiac disease. I am sure I had it for at least 13 years before that because it was then I developed idiopathic elevated liver enzymes. I now have a little scoliosis and pronounced kyphosis (upper spine curvature).  All of your symptoms scream of celiac disease, even if the testing you have had done does not. You may be an atypical celiac, meaning the disease is not manifesting itself in your gut but is attacking other body systems. There is such a thing as sero negative celiac disease. But you still have not given me a satisfactory answer to my question of why do you need a differential dx between celiac disease and NCGS when either one would call for complete abstinence from gluten, which you have already been practicing except for short periods when you were undergoing a gluten challenge. Why do you want to put a toxic substance into your body for weeks when, even if it did produce a positive test result for celiac disease, neither you or your doctors would do anything different? Regardless of what doctors are recommending to you, it is your body it is affecting not theirs and they don't seem to have given you any good justification for starting another gluten challenge. Where you live, are doctors kings or something?
    • WildFlower1
      Sorry to put it clearly, at 15, infertility started (tried to word it nicely) meaning menstruation stopped. Which is in correlation to celiac I mean. Thank you. 
    • WildFlower1
      Thank you for the reply! Doctors over the years have tested me for everything under the sun and tests are normal, except the decreasing bone density, high FSH (in regards to infertility), lower iron, and all the other celiac symptoms I experience. When I was 15 the infertility started (my whole life growing up I always ate gluten, and always had severe stomach problems, I’m an adult now and I still remember the stomach pain as a child) and then from here, they couldn’t figure out why. At the same time I was having all these celiac symptoms but nobody ever put two and two together.   Eventually in adulthood I went off gluten and dairy and felt better. Later in life, the topic was brought up by doctors, but they could never actually test for celiac because I was off gluten for years.   Just recently multiple doctors brought it up again, and said I should rule it out. So the ruling out of celiac, which is direct correlation with these symptoms, infertility at a younge age, on the edge and getting into osteopenia, etc. etc. is the concern. I was off of dairy for the same time as gluten because it made me sick. I did not surely have adequate calcium/D intake as well over these years.   The matter of concern is to once and for all get celiac ruled out for my own health, a gastro doctor recommended I get it done and other doctors to confirm yes or no to officially rule it out.  For these 6 weeks I have not been eating enough gluten then it seems, if 2-3 slices of bread a day is not really enough. I should increase my intake of gluten then and extend the test time?   Thank you very much for your help!! The test for Immunoglobulin IgA being a value of —> “1.25” shows it is in the normal range of 0.54-4.17 g/L on the test. 
    • trents
      Welcome to the forum, @WildFlower1! The reason you are seeing conflicting results when you research the length of time recommended for doing the "gluten challenge" is that the guidelines have recently been under revision. So there are two components: 1. amount of daily gluten consumption and 2. duration of that amount of daily gluten consumption Recently, the guidelines have been under revision because the medical community was sensing the previous standards were too relaxed, particularly in the daily amount of recommended gluten consumption. The more recent guidelines seem to be calling for higher amounts of daily gluten consumption over (perhaps) as shorter period of time. So, it is becoming a daily minimum of 10g of gluten daily (about the amount in 4-6 slices of wheat bread) for a minimum of two weeks. Personally, I would recommend that amount of consumption be extended from two weeks to four weeks to ensure valid testing. Your Immunoglobulin IgA at 1.25. Was that within normal range? If that one is low, you are IgA deficient and other IgA test results cannot be trusted. But regardless of whether or not you have celiac disease or NCGS (Non Celiac Gluten Sensitivity) the antidote is the same, namely, a gluten free diet. What would you do different if you had a more confident differential diagnosis? And there are other reasons for the development of osteopenia/osteoporosis that you probably should explore. Are you on any serious supplementation for D3 and magnesium?
    • WildFlower1
      The results of my blood tests after 4 weeks: *Tissue Transglutaminase Ab IgA —->   “<0.5 NEGATIVE” *Immunoglobulin IgA —-> “1.25” *Deamidated Gliadin peptide Ab IgG —-> “<0.5 NEGATIVE”    
×
×
  • Create New...