Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×
  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.




  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):



    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):


  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Soy?


alyssasgabby

Recommended Posts

alyssasgabby Rookie

Hi everyone!

Just a quick question. I have noted that Celiac's should avoid Soy Sauce. In my attempt to be completely gluten free, I am having trouble determining which products to avoid. Do I need to stay away from anything containing soy? Basically, right now I am not eating anything containing Wheat, but are there other ingredients I should be looking for on labels.

I am surviving on Rice and Black Beans :lol: but trying to add eggs and some meats back in. I really appreciate the info posted on Dairy in other posts, I didn't realize I needed to stop my dairy intake initially and will begin to do so tomorrow!! What can I use in my morning coffee? I usually use half & half and obviously can't do that now!

Thanks for your help!


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



super-sally888 Contributor

Hi,

Soy sauce is usually out because it is made with wheat (as well as soy). There are some wheat free brands available - maybe some of the others here can recommend (none available in my part of the world).

Soy is not a problem, unless you are also sensitive to it. However, the health benefits of soy are currently under review so don't go overboard on it (particularly the texturised soy protein - fake meats etc. (check out the soy page on Open Original Shared Link if you are interested)), but can use soy milk in place of regular dairy in your coffee.

You may find that dairy doesn't bother you. Try taking it out for a while and see if it makes a difference. If you are not sure, try adding it back in after eliminating it for a while and see if you have any symptoms/change when you add it back in. Not all are bothered by or sensitive to dairy. Don't eliminate things unless you know / can prove you need to, so you diet is as non-restrictive as you can make it.

Best Wishes

Sally

Ursa Major Collaborator

Even though soy in general isn't as healthy or safe as most people think, the reason to avoid soy sauce is that most of the time, wheat is the first ingredient! There are wheat-free soy sauces out there, one of them being Tamari soy sauce by Life Soy. I think I read that another one is Kikoman (or something like that).

You might want to try goats milk in your coffee. Or almond milk (haven't tried that, as I am intolerant to coffee, but it might be okay).

super-sally888 Contributor

Hi,

Some more stuff on soy, I got from various sites. Use of soy products in moderation should be fine, as long as you are not sensitive to it. (Moderators - is it ok to post this sort of info? Sorry if it's not - Please just delete the post).

S

Soy isoflavones (plant estrogens), should be limited to the 35-45 mg per day beyond which they have been shown to cause thyroid and reproductive system derailment in healthy adults. Soy isoflavones are found in all soy products.

Some examples of the amounts of isoflavones found in single serves of various products.

Food Svg Size (g) Serve Protein Isoflavone

Size g/100g mg/svg

Mature soybeans, uncooked 93 1/2 cup 37 175.6

Roasted soybeans 86 1/2 cup 35.2 167.0

Soy flour 21 1/4 cup 37.8 43.8

Textured soy protein, dry 30 1/4 cup 18.0 27.8

Green soybeans,uncooked 128 1/2 cup 16.6 70.1

Soy milk 228 1 cup 4.4 20.0

Tempeh, uncooked 114 4 oz 17.0 60.5

Tofu, uncooked 114 4 oz 15.8 38.3

Soy isolate, dry 28 1 oz 92.0 56.5

Soy concentrate, dry 28 1 oz 63.6 12.4

Abug Rookie

Silk brand (white wave) soy milk claims to make all gluten-free products as of the last time I looked them up. Kraft has stated earlier that they're thinking of making a gluten-free line, but I haven't seen anything become of it yet, though you can watch for it. On a side note, if anyone else has heard any more of this, let me know. Since I'm one of those who can't have dairy, I really know only of the substitutes in that area, but I seem to be doing fine on it, so I don't understand the health risk. I'm open minded though, so you can be assured that I'll take any valid study under due consideration once its results are presented. I'd surely be dead by now if I weren't willing to make dietary sacrifices for the sake of my health :) What makes me nervous is if I have to eliminate soy, I'm dangerously running out of options due to a number of food allergies coupled with Celiac Disease and Chronic Hypoglycemia. I don't wanna be stuck with rice and black beans like alyssasgabby :lol: That doesn't have adequate nutrition to live on anyway. You should look for more fruits and veggies too. I hope someone posts a list of things to look for on labels for you shortly. I've been gluten-free for so long that I don't have a list any more, and I couldn't list anything worth while if you asked me to. It's all in my head. I look at the ingredients, and I automatically know if I can eat it or not. It's kind of like trying to teach someone how to drive a clutch. I have no idea how! I tried to teach my sister to drive stick shift, and I kept catching myself saying things like, "Just .. GO! Just ------ go forward!" So anyway, I'll leave that up to someone else ;) Best of luck! The hardest part is the first couple weeks! As weeks turn into months, and months turn into years, it all becomes natural! :) I decided to join this forum after so long because I was afraid I might go astray if I didn't keep in contact with people like me.

You might also notice after a while that I have a bad habit of rambling :unsure:

And these little faces are so cute, lol

flowergirl Rookie

I wouldn't have any soy, dairy or coffee for a few months if I were you. At least until there are some healing... Coffee is a gut irritant and you are slowing your progress by drinking it.

darlindeb25 Collaborator

Soy did not bother me for almost 2 yrs after going gluten free, then I became intolerant of it. I too believe soy is not good for any of us. You should be wheat, rye, and barley free, not just wheat. Do not use anything with barley malt in it, or even if it simply says malt, you should avoid.


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



RiceGuy Collaborator

So far I haven't had any problems with soy. I eat tofu for the proteins and fats, and it seems to help me health-wise. I think the arguments about soy will be ongoing for some time yet. Both sides do make some good points though.

Anyway, Open Original Shared Link makes some wheat-free tamari. I don't use anything like that so I can't make any comments on the taste.

hathor Contributor

Here are some safe and forbidden lists --

https://www.celiac.com/st_main.html?p_catid...-57107623365.5f

If you want to avoid dairy and soy, you might check out almond milk. I haven't tried in in coffee (my system can't take the stuff anymore), but I think it is pretty tasty.

Abug Rookie

I also have no trouble with soy. I regularly use soy milk in my coffee and in cooking, and my mother makes soy milk out of soy beans. It's really good when she forgets to put salt in it.

NoGluGirl Contributor
Hi everyone!

Just a quick question. I have noted that Celiac's should avoid Soy Sauce. In my attempt to be completely gluten free, I am having trouble determining which products to avoid. Do I need to stay away from anything containing soy? Basically, right now I am not eating anything containing Wheat, but are there other ingredients I should be looking for on labels.

I am surviving on Rice and Black Beans :lol: but trying to add eggs and some meats back in. I really appreciate the info posted on Dairy in other posts, I didn't realize I needed to stop my dairy intake initially and will begin to do so tomorrow!! What can I use in my morning coffee? I usually use half & half and obviously can't do that now!

Thanks for your help!

Dear alyssasgabby,

Wal-Mart's Great Value Soy Sauce is Gluten Free! It is also less expensive than the organic kinds. As far as your coffee goes, many of the Coffee Mates liquid creamers are gluten free!

If they contain gluten, it will be clearly listed! You do not have to starve on this diet! There are tons of things you can have! Just to name a few:

Dinty Moore Beef Stew

Hormel Chili

Hormel Turkey Spam (oven roasted or smoked)

Buddig Deli Style Lunchmeats

Hormel Vienna Sausages

Hormel Bacon

Jimmy Dean Fresh Taste Fast Sausage

Johnsonville Original Bratwurst

Yoplait Yogurt (Whips are great, and all are clearly labeled, so if gluten is present, it will be listed)

Kraft Shredded Cheeses

Kraft Jell-O Pudding and Gelatin Snacks (Kraft Clearly labels all products, so gluten is listed if present)

Kraft Philadelphia Cream Cheese (low-fat, fat-free, original)

Heinz Ketchup

Idahoan Instant Potatoes

Daisy Sour Cream (fat-free, low-fat, and original)

Tostitos

Fritos

Cheetos

Lay's Original Potato Chips

Classico Red and White Sauces (all) my favorite is the Sweet Tomato Basil

Pace Picante Sauce

Velveeta Cheese

Kraft American Singles (Original)

Great Value Soy Milk

Pompeiian Cold Pressed Extra Virgin Olive Oil

PAM Non-Stick Cooking Sprays (all except PAM for Baking, it contains flour)

Smart Balance Light and Original

Kraft Mayonnaise (reg. and fat-free)

Kraft Miracle Whip (reg. and Fat-free)

Kraft Salad Dressings (Fat-free French and Thousand Island Fat Free I recommend)

Cool Whip

Dora The Explorer Cinnamon Stars Cereal

Cocoa Pebbles

Fruity Pebbles

Jif Peanut Butter (all varieties including Smooth Sensations)

Welch's Grape Jelly

ButterFinger Candy Bars

3 Musketeers Bars

Snickers Bars

Reese's Peanut Butter Cups

Jelly Belly Jelly Beans (all except cinnamon toast flavor)

Act II Microwave Popcorn

Cool Ranch Doritos (Not Nacho Cheese-they have gluten)

Kraft Caramels

Skittles

Coca-Cola Classic, Vanilla, Diet Coke, Diet Vanilla (caffeine free ones are okay too!)

Diet Rite

Fruit 2-0 flavored waters

Nestle Pure Life flavored waters

All Folgers Coffees (includes Instant and Cappuccinos)

Wal-Mart's Great Value canned fruits and vegetables

Dole Fruit Singles

Del Monte Canned Fruits and Vegetables

Heinz Sweet Pickle Relish

Durkee ground cinnamon

Durkee ground ginger

Durkee ground cayenne pepper

Durkee ground cloves

Durkee all liquid extracts and flavorings and food colorings

Emeril's Essence Asian, Italian, and Southwest Seasonings

Ore-Ida Tater Tots

Ore-Ida French Fries

Ore-Ida Quick Fries (The ones in the microwave) They are good and fast!

To use around the house:

Dawn Dish Soap (Includes Power Disolver)

Cascade

All Laundry Detergent

Murphy's Oil Soap

Spray'n Wash Spot Remover

Some Beauty Products and Hygiene items:

Crest Whitening Expressions Toothpastes(all)

Colgate Toothpastes (all)

Johnson & Johnson Baby Oil

Vasoline Petroleum Jelly

Crest WhiteStrips

Colgate Simply White

Glide Floss

Revlon LipGlides (I am wearing Sparkling Sangria in my avatar)

Maybelline (Read labels: Any gluten containing ingredients will be clearly labeled)

Wet'n Wild Cosmetics (all except one of the mascaras)

CoverGirl (Clearly labels any gluten containing ingredients)

Dove Shampoos, Hair Styling Aids, and Conditioners (company clearly labels gluten if present)

Suave lotions, shampoos, and conditioners (Company clearly labels gluten if present)

Anywho, I hope this helps you out!

Sincerely,

NoGluGirl

  • 3 weeks later...
alyssasgabby Rookie

You are all so AWESOME and Inspiring! I have slowly added some of the foods to my diet, including Veggies and Fruit, some Fritos for snacks, Snickers Bars for my chocolate cravings and even Hormel Black Label Bacon (on my Grocery Store's checklist of "Safe" foods).

I am feeling pretty good, though I just passed a Kidney Stone (OUCH!!). D has almost completely stopped, but I still have Back pain. I saw some other posts on that, and will discuss with my MD on Wednesday.

I want to thank all of you for all of your help! I printed out noglugirl's list and am keeping it with me at all times.

Thanks Again!!

Dear alyssasgabby,

Wal-Mart's Great Value Soy Sauce is Gluten Free! It is also less expensive than the organic kinds. As far as your coffee goes, many of the Coffee Mates liquid creamers are gluten free!

If they contain gluten, it will be clearly listed! You do not have to starve on this diet! There are tons of things you can have! Just to name a few:

Dinty Moore Beef Stew

Hormel Chili

Hormel Turkey Spam (oven roasted or smoked)

Buddig Deli Style Lunchmeats

Hormel Vienna Sausages

Hormel Bacon

Jimmy Dean Fresh Taste Fast Sausage

Johnsonville Original Bratwurst

Yoplait Yogurt (Whips are great, and all are clearly labeled, so if gluten is present, it will be listed)

Kraft Shredded Cheeses

Kraft Jell-O Pudding and Gelatin Snacks (Kraft Clearly labels all products, so gluten is listed if present)

Kraft Philadelphia Cream Cheese (low-fat, fat-free, original)

Heinz Ketchup

Idahoan Instant Potatoes

Daisy Sour Cream (fat-free, low-fat, and original)

Tostitos

Fritos

Cheetos

Lay's Original Potato Chips

Classico Red and White Sauces (all) my favorite is the Sweet Tomato Basil

Pace Picante Sauce

Velveeta Cheese

Kraft American Singles (Original)

Great Value Soy Milk

Pompeiian Cold Pressed Extra Virgin Olive Oil

PAM Non-Stick Cooking Sprays (all except PAM for Baking, it contains flour)

Smart Balance Light and Original

Kraft Mayonnaise (reg. and fat-free)

Kraft Miracle Whip (reg. and Fat-free)

Kraft Salad Dressings (Fat-free French and Thousand Island Fat Free I recommend)

Cool Whip

Dora The Explorer Cinnamon Stars Cereal

Cocoa Pebbles

Fruity Pebbles

Jif Peanut Butter (all varieties including Smooth Sensations)

Welch's Grape Jelly

ButterFinger Candy Bars

3 Musketeers Bars

Snickers Bars

Reese's Peanut Butter Cups

Jelly Belly Jelly Beans (all except cinnamon toast flavor)

Act II Microwave Popcorn

Cool Ranch Doritos (Not Nacho Cheese-they have gluten)

Kraft Caramels

Skittles

Coca-Cola Classic, Vanilla, Diet Coke, Diet Vanilla (caffeine free ones are okay too!)

Diet Rite

Fruit 2-0 flavored waters

Nestle Pure Life flavored waters

All Folgers Coffees (includes Instant and Cappuccinos)

Wal-Mart's Great Value canned fruits and vegetables

Dole Fruit Singles

Del Monte Canned Fruits and Vegetables

Heinz Sweet Pickle Relish

Durkee ground cinnamon

Durkee ground ginger

Durkee ground cayenne pepper

Durkee ground cloves

Durkee all liquid extracts and flavorings and food colorings

Emeril's Essence Asian, Italian, and Southwest Seasonings

Ore-Ida Tater Tots

Ore-Ida French Fries

Ore-Ida Quick Fries (The ones in the microwave) They are good and fast!

To use around the house:

Dawn Dish Soap (Includes Power Disolver)

Cascade

All Laundry Detergent

Murphy's Oil Soap

Spray'n Wash Spot Remover

Some Beauty Products and Hygiene items:

Crest Whitening Expressions Toothpastes(all)

Colgate Toothpastes (all)

Johnson & Johnson Baby Oil

Vasoline Petroleum Jelly

Crest WhiteStrips

Colgate Simply White

Glide Floss

Revlon LipGlides (I am wearing Sparkling Sangria in my avatar)

Maybelline (Read labels: Any gluten containing ingredients will be clearly labeled)

Wet'n Wild Cosmetics (all except one of the mascaras)

CoverGirl (Clearly labels any gluten containing ingredients)

Dove Shampoos, Hair Styling Aids, and Conditioners (company clearly labels gluten if present)

Suave lotions, shampoos, and conditioners (Company clearly labels gluten if present)

Anywho, I hope this helps you out!

Sincerely,

NoGluGirl

UNCHeel Rookie

I've used La Choy Soy Sauce because I read it was gluten free and nothing ont he ingredient list stood out as being an issue. Anyone know if that's still true?

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):



  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      128,131
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748

    Kayla Conklin
    Newest Member
    Kayla Conklin
    Joined

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):


  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.1k
    • Total Posts
      70.6k

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):





  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):



  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • Skg414228
      It is interesting you mentioned that it could be other things because I asked my gastro and she literally said it means nothing else. That that value was only considered for Celiac which is kind of why I asked here because I didn't understand how a celiac only value could be high and it wasn't celiac. 
    • Skg414228
      I did read this article and all it helped me determine was that I am too dumb lol. Plus with DGP IGA 75-95 is a huge range. I was also confused on if it meant 75-95% of people with positive dgp iga have it or if it meant that of 100% of the people that have Celiac 75-95% this value will be positive.  Most of my symptoms are GI related but the other one that stands out is inflammation. It almost felt like I had body aches and I have soreness right now that I don't have when I am on the paleo diet full time (which is gluten free when you never cheat on it, which I was occasionally). My doctor suspected Raynauds but never did a blood test for it, and then I have had ADHD which I can't remember if it was directly related or not. I have a healthy mix of a lot of stuff going on so honestly it would be a relief if it was celiac because I could at least manage that. Im a pretty healthy person exercise daily high intensity and endurance and a pretty good diet but I haven't been able to lose weight in like 7 years. 
    • trents
      Welcome to the forum, @Jo Woodard! The problem with oats is not always cross contamination with gluten from other grains. The main protein found in oats is "avenin" and it has a structure similar to the wheat/barley/rye protein "gluten". It is similar enough to cause a gluten-like reaction in some celiacs. About 10% of celiacs cannot tolerate oats.
    • trents
      You might find this interesting as it outlines the various antibody tests that can be ordered and rates them for their relative reliability: What symptoms do you experience and how long have you been experiencing them? Do you have any other blood work parameters that are out of range from say a CBC or CMP. For those with celiac disease, the immune system misinterprets gluten as an invader and sends attacking cells into the lining of the small bowel, causing inflammation. Over time, this inflammation wears down the "villi" that line the small bowel, millions and millions of tiny finger-like projections that constitute the nutrient absorbing organ of the intestinal track. This can greatly reduce the efficiency with which nutrients are absorbed and often leads to other nutrient deficiency-related medical problems such as anemia and osteopenia/osteoporosis, just to name a couple. Celiac disease is an autoimmune disorder and is often found in association with other autoimmune disorders such as Hashimoto's thyroid disease and diabetes. There are over 200 symptoms/medical problems that have been associated with celiac disease, many of them not fitting into the classic category of GI distress.
    • Ryangf
      @Scott Adams Thank you for your input- and I do think it’s best for me to just wait a little while before I do gluten challenge for a biopsy. Getting a dietitian is also a good idea.
×
×
  • Create New...