Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):

    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Celiac Diagnosis With Negative Gene Test?

SwimKat31

Recommended Posts

SwimKat31 Newbie
SwimKat31
Posted

After 3 years of unusual health problems, I've suspected for about 6 months now that I have a problem with gluten. I just had a follow-up appointment with my doctor this week to go over some lab tests I had done. In the past, I had had a negative genetic test for HLA DQ2 or 8 (I'm DQ5/6), so I was NOT expecting my lab tests this time to be positive.

But positive they were! My IgA antibodies were elevated, and I also had a positive fecal fat test for malabsorption. My doctor said these tests suggest Celiac even though I don't have the genes for it. This doctor is a world-renowned expert on Celiac disease, and apparently he said he's only heard of two or three other cases in the US like it, both at the Mayo Clinic. I have not had a biopsy yet to confirm the diagnosis.

What I was wondering is... is there anybody else out there actually diagnosed with Celiac with negative genetic tests? Thanks!

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


Ursa Major Collaborator
Ursa Major
Posted

The problem is, that here in North America the medical establishment will only recognize two official celiac disease genes, while in Europe and Asia they recognize seven I believe. Meaning that in other countries you would likely have been diagnosed earlier, and you wouldn't even ask your question!

Yes, there are people here who have been diagnosed with celiac disease by biopsy, even though they have the 'wrong' genes.

tom Contributor
tom
Posted

Plenty of celiacs don't have DQ2 or DQ8.

Admittedly, not a high %.

Genetic research is ongoing and will be for quite some time imho.

nora-n Rookie
nora-n
Posted

Hi, you can have half a DQ2 gene (0501) together with DQ5 and 6.

If they did not test for both the alpha and beta chains, they do not find this half gene.

Open Original Shared Link

And, I have some links that they find several per thousand with other genes than DQ2 and 8:

Open Original Shared Link

note you need the wiki page to decipher the alpha (DQA1) chains and beta chains (DQB1)

Open Original Shared Link

and in the case of DRB, which they sometimes mention in other articles, you need the wiki for DR

Open Original Shared Link

About only two patients being officially diagnosed with DQ1: over at the neurotalk or braintalk forum there is someone keeping track of officcially diagnosed celiacs with other genes, and I seem to recall there are more than 2. I think it was more like 20-30.

If you surf around here on the forum, there are lots of people with other genes than DQ2 or 8.

There was one about a year ago, who was properly diagnosed celiac for years, who had a gene test and it showed DQ6 and they took away her diagnosis. You have to count her in too. There were posts about this here in this thread I think.

Here is a thread about celiac and other genes:

Open Original Shared Link

The braintalk forum is here Open Original Shared Link and several are DQ1. They seem to be more sensitive to gluten than DQ2 or 8. I think they will be thrilled if you post about your diagnosis despite being DQ1.

Maybe it is jcc there that keeps track of the non-DQ2 or 8 celiacs, I do not remember.

Dr. Hadjivassiliou has written several articles about gluten ataxia. He writes he found that about 20% of his gluten ataxia patients are DQ1. You can even google hadjivassiliou and find the articles.

ravenwoodglass Mentor
ravenwoodglass
Posted

We are here. I was in the end stages of celiac before diagnosis. I am a double DQ9, here in the US my gene tests would have given me a diagnosis of RA, which I did have severe symptoms of. It makes me sad to think that so many RA patients in the US might achieve remission if they recognized DQ9s and their need to be gluten free. I am extremely thankful that I did not gene test until 5 years after diagnosis. By then the though of RA was wayyyyy in the past as I had been in remission for over 4 years. I was well on my way to demetia also by the time I was diagnosed. My brain has not totally healed because it took so dam long to diagnose me but I am worlds from where I was 6 years ago. Doctor need to get their heads out of the drug company literature and read some research.

SwimKat31 Newbie
SwimKat31
Posted
  • Author

Thank you all for your replies. I'm glad I'm not alone on this. I'm also so amazed at how little the medical community actually knows about the relationship between genetics and Celiac/gluten intolerance, especially in the US.

It appears there are too many people on this forum, me included, who are living proof that our current state of "knowledge" does not sufficiently explain the problem. I am a big believer in modern medicine, in fact I'm currently applying to medical school, but this is one case where modern medicine seems to not have the answers. The human body is just too complex to make broad generalizations like "you cannot have Celiac without DQ2 or 8". And I'm not sure why most physicians don't seem to realize a simple blood test often doesn't pick up on these intricacies.

nora-n Rookie
nora-n
Posted

I think that s of the problem is that they do not want to diagnose too many patients, because here in some places in europe diagnosed celiacs get money from the government for gluten-free food etc.

Here they get about 350 usd a month.

So they have to set some strict standards.

(on a second thought, I think I will have to ask the lab, a research lab, to re-run my gene test, since there is too much pointing to celiac in my case, like hypothyroidism and daughter diagnosed celiac. i do not even know which method they used. I could be mistyped too, see another thread here where they re-did the test and it turned out positive using another method. She turned out to be DQ8 after all. Before reading the wiki on DQ and DR (both of them), Dr. Lewey's articles on gene typing, and the thread here where someone bot a differrent result after questioning the lab, I now have the ammunition to question the gene test result )

nora

norway

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


Fiddle-Faddle Community Regular
Fiddle-Faddle
Posted
W Doctor need to get their heads out of the drug company literature and read some research.

The problem is, most of the research is funded by the drug companies. And when they get a result that doesn't point to profits (i.e., diet change resulting in cure), they don't publish their findings. :ph34r: If anything, they hush it up.

fedora Enthusiast
fedora
Posted

I did not have a biopsy or blood test

Gluten wrangler on here is double DQ5 AND has biopsy proven refractory sprue.....

Hope you heal soon

nora-n Rookie
nora-n
Posted

swimkat, here in this thread jcc says she has "crossed paths" with two celiacs with DQ1 (just like you):

Open Original Shared Link

nora

  • 2 weeks later...
nora-n Rookie
nora-n
Posted

Swimkat, here are two DQ1 subtype 6 in Spain:

Open Original Shared Link

weird taht they do not say they are DQ1, maybe noone wants to give Dr. Hadjuvassiliou right? He found 20% of his gluten ataxia patients to be DQ1.

nora

dollamasgetceliac? Explorer
dollamasgetceliac?
Posted
We are here. I was in the end stages of celiac before diagnosis. I am a double DQ9, here in the US my gene tests would have given me a diagnosis of RA, which I did have severe symptoms of. It makes me sad to think that so many RA patients in the US might achieve remission if they recognized DQ9s and their need to be gluten free. I am extremely thankful that I did not gene test until 5 years after diagnosis. By then the though of RA was wayyyyy in the past as I had been in remission for over 4 years. I was well on my way to demetia also by the time I was diagnosed. My brain has not totally healed because it took so dam long to diagnose me but I am worlds from where I was 6 years ago. Doctor need to get their heads out of the drug company literature and read some research.

:huh: Sorry what is RA? I am not computer savvy so I really am bad at abriviations.

Fiddle-Faddle Community Regular
Fiddle-Faddle
Posted
:huh: Sorry what is RA? I am not computer savvy so I really am bad at abriviations.

RA is rheumatoid arthritis, often diagnosed YEARS before celiac, and symptoms frequently improve or disappear on a gluten-free (and sometimes casein-free) diet.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Celiac.com:
    Join eNewsletter
    Donate
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):



    Celiac.com Sponsors (A17-M):



  • Recent Activity

    1. cristiana
      - cristiana commented on Jefferson Adams's article in Origins of Celiac Disease
      7

      Why Bananas No Longer Cure Celiac Disease

      I missed this article when it was first put up. It is interesting to read, as my old neighbour who sadly passed away a few years ago was a trainee midwife during WWII. Bananas disappeared from the shops in Britain during the war, but she told me that those that did get to the UK were kept back for infants with coeliac disease. I didn't realise that...
    2. trents
      - trents replied to Dawn Meyers's topic in Related Issues & Disorders
      23

      Vaccines

      @GeoPeanut, milk is one of the better sources of iodine. Iodine is known to exacerbate dermatitis herpetiformis. Many people find that a low iodine diet helps them avoid dermatitis herpetiformis outbreaks. So, maybe the fact that you have limited your dairy intake of late is helping with that.
    3. GeoPeanut
      - GeoPeanut replied to Dawn Meyers's topic in Related Issues & Disorders
      23

      Vaccines

      Hi, I'm new here. Sorry for your troubles.herenis a thought to mull over. I recently was diagnosed with celiac disease, and hashimoto's and dermatitis herpetiformis after getting covid 19. I eat butter, and 1/2 cup of Nancy's yogurt daily. I stopped all other dairy and dermatitis herpetiformis is gone! I also make grass fed beef bone broth to help with...
    4. trents
      - trents replied to KRipple's topic in Celiac Disease Pre-Diagnosis, Testing & Symptoms
      1

      Celiac or Addison's complications? Can someone share their experience?

      Welcome to the forum, @KRipple! Sorry to hear of all your husband's health problems. I can only imagine how anxious this makes you as when our spouse suffers we hurt right along with them. Can you post the results from the Celiac blood testing for us to look at? We would need the names of the tests run, the numeric results and (this is important...
    5. SportySue
      - SportySue commented on Jefferson Adams's article in Origins of Celiac Disease
      7

      Why Bananas No Longer Cure Celiac Disease

      I am celiac also. Dr Elaine Gotschall once stated celiac is a carbohydrate problem as well. So that was important info for me. Even fruit makes intestines upset. Therefore veggie carbs also can cause me issues. I am backing away little by little in not eating but only small amounts. gluten-free food is unhelpful. Only the manufacturer thrives on all the ...
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):


  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      128,048
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    HeatherF
    Newest Member
    HeatherF
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121k
    • Total Posts
      70.6k
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):


  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • trents
      Vaccines

      By trents · Posted

      @GeoPeanut, milk is one of the better sources of iodine. Iodine is known to exacerbate dermatitis herpetiformis. Many people find that a low iodine diet helps them avoid dermatitis herpetiformis outbreaks. So, maybe the fact that you have limited your dairy intake of late is helping with that.
    • GeoPeanut
      Vaccines

      By GeoPeanut · Posted

      Hi, I'm new here. Sorry for your troubles.herenis a thought to mull over. I recently was diagnosed with celiac disease,  and hashimoto's and dermatitis herpetiformis after getting covid 19. I eat butter, and 1/2 cup of Nancy's yogurt daily. I stopped all other dairy and  dermatitis herpetiformis is gone! I also make grass fed beef bone broth to help with myopathy that has occurred. 
    • trents
      Celiac or Addison's complications? Can someone share their experience?

      By trents · Posted

      Welcome to the forum, @KRipple! Sorry to hear of all your husband's health problems. I can only imagine how anxious this makes you as when our spouse suffers we hurt right along with them. Can you post the results from the Celiac blood testing for us to look at? We would need the names of the tests run, the numeric results and (this is important) the reference ranges for each test used to establish high/low/negative/positive. Different labs use different rating scales so this is why I ask for this. There aren't industry standards. Has your husband seen any improvement from eliminating gluten from his diet? If your husband had any positive results from his celiac blood antibody testing, this is likely what triggered the consult with a  GI doc for an endoscopy. During the endoscopy, the GI doc will likely biopsy the lining of the small bowel lining to check for the damage caused by celiac disease. This would be for confirmation of the results of the blood tests and is considered the gold standard of celiac disease diagnosis. But here is some difficult information I have for you. If your husband has been gluten free already for months leading up to the endoscopy/biopsy, it will likely invalidate the biopsy and result in a false negative. Starting the gluten free diet now will allow the lining of the small bowel to begin healing and if enough healing takes place before the biopsy happens, there will be no damage to see. How far out is the endoscopy scheduled for? There still may be time for your husband to go back on gluten, what we call a "gluten challenge" to ensure valid test results.
    • kate g
      Are they close to a drug that will help celiacs with cross contamination

      By kate g · Posted

      Ive read articles that there is stage 2 research being conducted for drugs that will limit damage to celiacs through cross contamination- how close are they to this will there be enough funding to create a mainstream drug? 
    • KRipple
      Celiac or Addison's complications? Can someone share their experience?

      By KRipple · Posted

      Hello, My husband has had issues with really bad diarreah for over nine months now. In mid November, he went to the doctor for what they thought was a bad cold, which two weeks later was diagnosed as bronchitis. A week later, in December, I had to take him back to urgent care and from there, to the emergency room cause his vitals were too low. They said he was having an Addisionan crisis and he spent five days in the ICU. Since my husband has Autoimmune Polyendocrine Syndrome Type II (type 1 diabetes, Addison's and Hashimoto's), I fought for a blood test to determine if he had Celiacs. Given the results of the test, he was told to go to a gastro for an endoscopy. It took two months to get his first appointment with the gastro. Still waiting for the endoscopy appointment. He stopped eating gluten in the hospital and has followed a gluten-free diet since. His diarreah continues to be as bad as before he stopped eating gluten. Still has a horrible cough that makes him hack. His energy is so depleted he pretty much goes to work, comes home and goes lie in bed. He is having issues regulating body temperature. He is barely eating (he's lost 20 pounds since mid-December). Body aches. Totally run down. He has been taking more prednisone lately to try to counter the symptoms.  Today, we went to his endo to discuss these things. She said to continue taking increased amount of prednisone (even though I explained that the increased dosage is only allowing him to do the bare minimum). According to the endo, this is all related to Celiacs. I am concerned because I know that both Celiacs and Addison's can have similar symptoms, but don't know if he would still be having these many symptoms (worsening, at that) related to the Celiac's after stopping gluten two months ago. If anyone in this group has a combination of Celiacs and Addison's, could you please share your experience? I am really concerned and am feeling frustrated. His primary care provider and endocrinologist don't seem to consider this serious enough to warrant prompt attention, and we'll see about the gastro.  Thanks.
×
×
  • Create New...