Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):

    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Biopsy

TLymanP

Recommended Posts

TLymanP Rookie
TLymanP
Posted

HI all:),

Does anyone know if small intestinal biopsies are always conclusive for celiac? If your tests come back normal, does that mean you cant have celiac? I was just wondering because isnt it possible for the biopsy to come back normal, but still have damage in other places? I mean its just a small section. what if the section they took the biopsy on was normal(say in the duodenum) but there are othere spots(say in the jejunum: or however you spell it). Any input is appreciated!!

Tyler

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


celiac3270 Collaborator
celiac3270
Posted

Biopsies are not 100% accurate. If you get a positive result, that's usually pretty accurate, but if it comes out negative, you should not rule out celiac disease. Like you said, the damage can be in another area. So even if the samples they take show no damage, there could be a different section where the villi are completely gone. Also, if you have been eating little or no gluten, you might see little or no intestinal damage, even though you have celiac. That's why if someone who's been on the diet long enough (5-12 months for most) and they perform another biopsy, it will test negative for celiac disease, even if the person actually has the disease. Simply, you're right--it's not always accurate. If you have positive bloodwork or Enterolab results, I would find that conclusive enough in my mind and would not worry about negative biopsy results.

KaitiUSA Enthusiast
KaitiUSA
Posted

Yes a biopsy can miss the diagnosis altogether. I know a lot of people who have had positive blood results but negative biopsies because of lack of damage or looking in the wrong areas. I agree with celiac3270, if you have blood test and Enterolab results that are positive then I would not worry if the biopsy was negative.

plantime Contributor
plantime
Posted

I was fortunate: the doc that did my endoscopy was looking specifically for damage. He said he saw patches that were red and inflamed, so he took the biopsy samples from those patches. Otherwise, the diagnosis would have been missed, because not all of my small intestine was damaged at the time. A doctor that is not so careful might have missed it, and I would still be consuming gluten and not getting better.

gf4life Enthusiast
gf4life
Posted

I had a doctor who didn't want to find any damage. She only took 3 samples and did not go very far into my intestines. She did not look for damaged spots, and I have a feeling that she would have taken the samples from a normal looking area, just to confirm her diagnosis of IBS...I hate feeling like this about her, but she absolutely refuses to accept that I feel better off gluten, and she won't even believe that I have the gene...

BTW, my biopsy was negative, and we opted out of biopsies for the kids. Their pediatric GI doesn't like to do them unless it is absolutely necessary. I was okay with them not having the biopsy.

God bless,

Mariann

Guest BellyTimber
Guest BellyTimber
Posted

Pardon my commenting on this:

a lot of you people are very cool about not having biopsies or not thinking them important.

I think that is massively healthy.

Over here in the UK the snag however is that doctors won't send you for one in good time.

There is a rumour going around the UK that if one takes gluten to make a biopsy work, the danger to health is extreme.

Is this correct?

Everything in the UK hinges on the doctor who is a state servant so I don't see any way of being able to get a meaningful certificate to show my employer to negotiate a reasonable attendance target for on & off ailments.

Parents who change their children's diet when young, seem to get kids that are healthier than a person who has ate wrong for 50 years, whatever other consequences ...(?)

Michael

Ruth UK Newbie
Ruth UK
Posted

Hi, 'Gapspan',

I, too, am from UK - just received +ve blood tests for celiac disease from Haematologist following VERY long term (almost 30 years) iron deficiency anaemia. Been referred to GE clinic (could take up to 17 weeks!) and dietician. Haematologist mentioned I 'might need a biopsy', but wasn't sure if I should go gluten free beforehand or not!

Because I'm really desparate to get a +ve biopsy, I've actually 'upped' my gluten intake! Probably a BAD idea, because now I have 'gastro' symptoms too. Mind, that's probably 'proof' in itself that I have celiac disease - but as you said in your post, may be it's actually dangerous??

I want a +ve biopsy because otherwise I still won't know why I've been anaemic for so long and why I have all the accompanying 'symptoms' that go along with anaemia. And at last I will be able to start getting myself better. (Also can't get gluten-free food on prescription without +ve biopsy - and I really need to be able to do that! And I want my drs to ckeck my children, and I'll have more 'ammunition' to convince them with if I get +ve result.)

I think my best plan will be to go 'low' gluten until I know exactly when biopsy date will be and then pile the gluten on for a few weeks before. Knowing the NHS it will be several weeks/months after I see the GE before the biopsy takes place. Mind, as much as I hate the long waits that happen sometimes, I do LOVE the NHS - it's (mostly) free and when you need care IMMEDIATELY you usually get it - at least my husband (re acute pancreatitis) and my son (re kidney problems) did.

Sorry - I'm 'waffling' as usual! I should be studying for my degree now, not writing an essay on the benefits or otherwise of the NHS!

All the best

Ruth

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


MySuicidalTurtle Enthusiast
MySuicidalTurtle
Posted

I personally do not think you need to have the biopsy done if you do not need it.

I was diagnosed with blood and improved 100% on the diet. The diagnosis made sense to me right away and I didn't think to go for further testing on it.

However, my brother had a biopsy done even though blood came back positive along with the fmaily line but he wanted to be more confirmed.

In instances like his I don't see any need to have the procedure but to have a double check.

I don't think I could ever go back on gluten just to see what a biopsy says.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):


  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      129,175
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    Jess9757
    Newest Member
    Jess9757
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.2k
    • Total Posts
      71.5k
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):


  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • DebJ14
      Fodzyme

      By DebJ14 · Posted

      I had an Elisa blood test for 90 Antigens run looking at IgG4 and there were 23 foods on the list that I reacted to.  Some reactions were mild, some moderate and some severe.  My yeast numbers were off the charts so they also did traditional allergy testing for IgE on both brewers and bakers yeast,  They came back super positive, so all yeast is out.  The other 21 foods were eliminated from my diet for about 2 years to give my overtaxed immune system time to calm down once on the gluten-free and Casein Free diet.  I added them back one at a time, one serving per day every other day and then had to keep track of pulse, BP, rashes, digestive issues etc.  Then I had to wait 2 weeks before trying another food.  I was able to put back everything except blueberries, oysters, cranberries, dairy, vanilla (I have to use the fake stuff) manufactured citric acid (because it is grown on aspergillus), clams, chocolate, black tea and cinnamon.  All cause a rise in my pulse within hours and BP is higher the next day.  Vanilla, chocolate, blueberries and cranberries also caused hives and dairy products gave me diarrhea within hours, every single time.   Once I accepted my fate, I felt so much better.  Lemon, orange, peach and strawberry became my dessert flavors and I really no longer miss the chocolate, vanilla and cinnamon.   Once I stopped cheating I was fine and 
    • Sanna King
      Getting sick much more often

      By Sanna King · Posted

      I’m doing OK except for an instance of cross contamination that knocked me for a loop over the weekend. Feeling much better today with still a little fatigue. Picking up tips on how to avoid future such incidents and becoming aware of just how sensitive I am. Looking forward to better days with more hope for improved health than prior to diagnosis. 
    • Sanna King
      Getting sick much more often

      By Sanna King · Posted

    • DebJ14
      Does anyone here also have Afib

      By DebJ14 · Posted

      My husband has had occasional A fib since 1986.  He spent years on Digoxin and Quinidine, with no reduction in the number of episodes.  Then, he was put on Verapamil as a pill in the pocket and did fine for about 5 years until it stopped working for him.  Then he went on Flecainide as a pill in the pocket.  His first 2 cardiologists had him on a "heart healthy diet" that was low in fat, practically no red meat, and high in pasta, Cheerios and Oatmeal and other carbs,  and he regularly went into A Fib.   His new, younger, cardiologist reviewed over 30 years of his medical records and said there was never any indication of heart disease.  All the cardio tests were perfectly normal,  He is Vietnamese and has a more holistic practice than most cardiologists.  My husband's BP has been rising as he ages, but he has had severe adverse reactions to every drug they tried, so instead he is on Vitamin C to bowel tolerance, Hawthorne, Hibiscus, Celery Seed, Grape Seed Extract and Resveratrol and his BP has come down 35 points, to a level acceptable to the doctor for his age.  He has an MTHFR mutation, which they believe causes the drug reactions due to his inability to detox.  The only  levels he seems concerned about are how high is the HDL and how low are the triglycerides, and how high is his Vitamin D level.  HDL was 77, Triglycerides were 62 and Vitamin D was 86.  He is only concerned with LDL is the particle types  and he has the good kind, the "fluffy" ones, and they are in a good range.  He only uses statins as a drug of last resort because of the side effects.  My husband was on one years ago and within 6 months developed a cataract, which the cardiologist and eye doctor at the time recognized as a side effect so they said no more. As a matter of routine he puts all his cardiology patients on a Sugar, gluten-free and Dairy free diet because it is his firm belief that inflammation is the root cause of all chronic disease and sugar, gluten and dairy are the foods he considers the worst offenders. They inflame the heart and the lining of the blood vessels leading to those blockages.   He also put him on Keto and severely restricted his carb intake.  Lo and behold, the A Fib disappeared.  My husband had to keep a food diary and  every episode of A Fib, which only occurred in the middle of the night, could be traced to his meals.  He was referred to a gastroenterologist.  His digestion is really poor.  So many foods cause him gas and that also puts him into A Fib.  The ran a test where they pumped his stomach full of air and on the table he went into A Fib.  They determined that his gut was pushing up on his diaphragm which in turn pushed on his heart triggering A Fib. So, no more Heart Healty beans!  His history told the tale too!  Abdominal radiation at age 21 for cancer damaged his gut and led to his dyspepsia, which led to A Fib. He now has a diagnosis of Roemheld Syndrome. If he sticks to his very low carb, no gas producing, gluten, dairy and sugar free diet he is fine.  He also was told to take a probiotic daily and digestive enzymes with his lunch and dinner.  He is on an annual visit basis with both gastro and cardiologist.  He has a Kardio Mobile and has to send results to the cardiologist, along with his food diary for any day he has A Fib.  Every single time we are able to pinpoint the cause.  Sometimes he just can't help himself and eats a banana, an orange, cookies and pretzels on the same day and then no one is surprised when he goes into A Fib.  His cardiologist prescribes Flecainide as a pill in the pocket to stop an attack, which always happens within 2-3 hours.  The gastro recommends brands and dosages of probiotics and digestive enzymes after running annual blood tests to test his digestive enzyme levels.   Having doctors get to the root cause, instead of just doling out prescriptions to mask symptoms has made all the difference in the world.  His cardio said no Covid jabs because of his tendency for A Fib and he also has a long history of blood clots related to his prior cancer treatment.  He also recommended that our adult son, with a history of pericarditis, skip them.  Thankfully  my doctor also said no because my other autoimmune diseases, Hashimoto's and Psoriasis, were finally both totally under control.
    • knitty kitty
      Getting sick much more often

      By knitty kitty · Posted

      Yes, zinc is very important to immune system and health.   @Sanna King, how are you doing?  I got really frustrated reading labels!  On the Autoimmune Protocol Diet I don't have to.  The AIP diet includes meat and veggies and some fruit.  No processed foods.  No dairy, no nuts, no nightshades (tomatoes, potatoes, peppers and eggplant).  The AIP diet has been shown to promote intestinal healing.  It gets the inflammation down really quickly, so the intestines can heal.  But the AIP diet can be lacking in essential nutrients, so supplementing is important.  Remember, you're no longer eating gluten breads that are enriched or fortified with vitamin supplements already.   It's important to get checked for deficiencies before you start taking supplements. Otherwise the tests will give false results.  Have you been checked for nutritional deficiencies?    Talk to your doctor and nutritionist about supplementing while you're healing.   Keep us posted on your progress.  
×
×
  • Create New...