Jump to content

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):

    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Diagnosed By A Gluten Free Diet Alone?

dizzygrinch

Recommended Posts

dizzygrinch Enthusiast
dizzygrinch
Posted

Has anyone been diagnosed, either by a doctor, or themselves, just by doing a gluten free diet? and if so, is there a time frame, where you are suppose to stay gluten free, to help determine if in fact, it was the gluten causing the problems?

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


dilettantesteph Collaborator
dilettantesteph
Posted
Has anyone been diagnosed, either by a doctor, or themselves, just by doing a gluten free diet? and if so, is there a time frame, where you are suppose to stay gluten free, to help determine if in fact, it was the gluten causing the problems?

My son was diagnosed this way. The doctor wanted to do a blood test, but regretably, I didn't listen to her and tried diet alone. He seemed better within a couple of days. This is after I had tried the diet myself. My diarrhea that I had for years went away overnight. You should notice an improvement right away, but it depends on what your symptoms are, and how gluten free you go.

After my initial miraculous cure, I found that it wasn't so easy. I became more sensitive and had to cut more things out of my diet. My son seemed to follow the same trend. It takes a lot of determination to stay on the diet under these circumstances when you can't be really sure that you have celiac disease anyways. After close to a year we seem to be getting somewhat less sensitive. Either that or we are just better at keeping gluten free.

In my case it was so obvious because before I went gluten free I used to poop a whole load in my pants twice a week, and I haven't done it since!

It took about a month for my arthritis to clear up. After a couple of months I didn't need my glasses anymore. After a while more I realized how unreasonable I had been to my poor husband. My temper control improved after a couple of weeks. I was amazed by how many symptoms this condition was causing!

Good luck to you, I suggest you have the blood test first and if it is negative and you still want to try the diet, go for it.

Stephanie

fedora Enthusiast
fedora
Posted

My doctor diagnosed me with diet alone. I went off gluten without any real knowledge about the testing. Then when I read about the test I refused to eat gluten again no matter what. I did the enterolab test to help verify it for myself. When I went to see my dr I had been gluten free for 4 months. I brought in a long list of all my symptoms that had improved or gone away. He said 4 months was long enough to not be a placebo effect and that I probably had celiac.

I do recommend getting tests done before going gluten free in case it is hard to tell after going gluten free. I was lucky and responded instantly.

take care

Tim-n-VA Contributor
Tim-n-VA
Posted

Diagnose what? That something bad happens when you consume gluten? That can be done by diet alone. That might be enough.

Celiac on the other hand is a specific body response (auto immune) to gluten that mimics or overlaps with symptoms potentially caused by other things including an allergic reaction to gluten. I don't think you can get a true differential diagnosis from diet alone.

dizzygrinch Enthusiast
dizzygrinch
Posted
  • Author

Hello all. You know what. Im going to just try to stick with a gluten free diet, and see how that goes. It been years since diagnosed with IBS, did another endo and upper GI last year, that did show "flattening of the mucosa" (sp), I was also diagnosed with rhumatoid arthritis, almost non existent vit d levels, but, not one doctor can give me a diagnosis on WHY I have these problems...so, maybe, after all this time, if these symptoms start to go away, maybe its would be more clear that glutin is the culprit. I have had lots of test to try to figure out why I have IBS, arthritis, GERD, and, as alway, never have a answer. So, maybe when I can afford it Ill do the Entero labs, because I believe I can be gluten free, and have that testing done. So, I am going to keep up to date and this forum, and, keep posted on how I feel. Who knows, maybe after some months, my vitamin D levels will go back up as well. Thanks for all the replies too....

leadmeastray88 Contributor
leadmeastray88
Posted
Has anyone been diagnosed, either by a doctor, or themselves, just by doing a gluten free diet? and if so, is there a time frame, where you are suppose to stay gluten free, to help determine if in fact, it was the gluten causing the problems?

I was diagnosed on a combination of things, dietary response being one of them. My GP looked at my extremely positive dietary response and my elevated IgA levels found in Enterolab results. My cousin also has Celiac so that helped, even though I don't have the genes for it.

I truly think though that if you truly feel better gluten-free after months on the diet and ALL of your symptoms subside, then you have your answer. Otherwise, you may need to look elsewhere.

Good luck! :)

Kim

RiceGuy Collaborator
RiceGuy
Posted

I had already given up on doctors and all their ridiculous misdiagnosis, so I didn't (and still don't) have any desire to go through any "official" testing. I had unintentionally been gluten-lite, so whenever I ate gluten, the more immediate symptoms were pronounced enough to notice. The less gluten I ate, the better I felt. So although I didn't relish the idea of not having certain foods, it sure beat feeling awful. I don't have any doubts about my choice.

But, as has been said many times, if you do want a doctor to prove it on paper, remain on gluten until you get the tests done. Not only because the already inaccurate tests will be almost certainly falsely negative, but going back on gluten is likely to be most unpleasant. Symptoms often become far more pronounced, and new symptoms tend to pop up too. From what I've read, the reasons for this are not fully understood.

And no matter what the test results say, try the gluten-free diet to make sure, as it is the best test there is anyway.

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


dizzygrinch Enthusiast
dizzygrinch
Posted
  • Author

Hi RiceGuy! You know what...about a couple of months ago, I actually did try to go completely gluten free for about 2 weeks, and I started to feel better. Well, I soon realized that, I had to be consuming gluten for the blood test to be accurate, so, I ate gluten. And, I swear to God, by the time I finished my food, I started to feel a sore forming on my lip, on my gum, and on my bottom lip. I had mouth sores! just that fast! then, I had the worst headache that would not leave for 6 days straight, must have been because I introduced the gluten back into my diet, even though I was only off of it for that short time, after obviously eating it all my life. Well, Im pretty sure that gluten has been effecting me all these years. So, as I said, Im going back to gluten free. In fact, already have. I just have to be very careful and read labels, it is very, very hard. I figure, that heck, Ill probably lose weight too, because Im cutting out breads and stuff. Just not eating that is cheaper than buying the gluten free stuff anyway. Just have to stick with it huh? well, wish me luck! lol, thanks!!

Trust Birth Rookie
Trust Birth
Posted
It took about a month for my arthritis to clear up. After a couple of months I didn't need my glasses anymore. After a while more I realized how unreasonable I had been to my poor husband. My temper control improved after a couple of weeks. I was amazed by how many symptoms this condition was causing!

Can I ask about this? My son was given glasses for depth perception/far sightedness. He has been gluten-free for a few months now. Recently he told me he no longer needed them. I keep brushing it off but I have noticed that his school work and art etc is fine even without it where as it was not before. Could he not need them?!?!?!?! What do you mean you no longer needed them?!

Cinthia

Treen Bean Apprentice
Treen Bean
Posted

I have a question too. I was never tested for Celiac Disease. Instead, my doctor just had me cut gluten from my diet. I have now been gluten free for 2 years. In those two years, I have gained back the 25 pounds I lost, I have regained my energy, stopped having migraines, began having my menstrual cycle again, been able to sleep at night, gained control of my intense mood swings, etc.... I could go on forever. Is it too late to be tested for Celiac by any method? I do not want to start eating gluten again just for a test. I still have violent reactions if I am cross contaminated. Any thoughts?

Thanks!

RiceGuy Collaborator
RiceGuy
Posted

I've also noticed improvement in eyesight. I think it may have been the supplements, but being able to absorb nutrients again would hopefully be just as good if not better.

As for being tested after two years gluten-free, I'd highly doubt it. From what I've read, Enterolab says up to one year. So two years seems like a stretch even for them. But look at it this way: If all the best tests say you aren't intolerant to a given substance, but eating it makes you ill, would you keep eating it?

dilettantesteph Collaborator
dilettantesteph
Posted
Can I ask about this? My son was given glasses for depth perception/far sightedness. He has been gluten-free for a few months now. Recently he told me he no longer needed them. I keep brushing it off but I have noticed that his school work and art etc is fine even without it where as it was not before. Could he not need them?!?!?!?! What do you mean you no longer needed them?!

Cinthia

When I wore my glasses which I did all the time, my vision was becoming unfocused. At first I thought it was a side effect of diabetes, which I didn't know I had, but is related to celiac. My vision was getting worse and worse until one morning before I put on my glasses I realized that I saw better without them. I got them 10 years ago or so when I could no longer read without them. I had bad astigmatism, and couldn't see far away, one eye much worse than the other. Now I can read without them and the two eyes are about the same. I haven't been back to the eye doctor yet so I can't give you a doctor measured difference. Googling turned up celiac causing "vision problems". On this forum I heard from others who stopped needing glasses after going gluten free.

Now I see better without the glasses than I saw with them. I am a musician and I noticed some notes which I had been playing wrong because I thought a natural sign was a sharp or vise versa.

I notice when I get accidentally glutened my vision gets blurry again. I hope that's what you wanted to hear.

dilettantesteph Collaborator
dilettantesteph
Posted
I have a question too. I was never tested for Celiac Disease. Instead, my doctor just had me cut gluten from my diet. I have now been gluten free for 2 years. In those two years, I have gained back the 25 pounds I lost, I have regained my energy, stopped having migraines, began having my menstrual cycle again, been able to sleep at night, gained control of my intense mood swings, etc.... I could go on forever. Is it too late to be tested for Celiac by any method? I do not want to start eating gluten again just for a test. I still have violent reactions if I am cross contaminated. Any thoughts?

Thanks!

I hope they develop a test like that soon. I wouldn't go back on gluten for testing either. I heard some research that could lead to one, but I don't think one exists now.

Trust Birth Rookie
Trust Birth
Posted
When I wore my glasses which I did all the time, my vision was becoming unfocused. At first I thought it was a side effect of diabetes, which I didn't know I had, but is related to celiac. My vision was getting worse and worse until one morning before I put on my glasses I realized that I saw better without them. I got them 10 years ago or so when I could no longer read without them. I had bad astigmatism, and couldn't see far away, one eye much worse than the other. Now I can read without them and the two eyes are about the same. I haven't been back to the eye doctor yet so I can't give you a doctor measured difference. Googling turned up celiac causing "vision problems". On this forum I heard from others who stopped needing glasses after going gluten free.

Now I see better without the glasses than I saw with them. I am a musician and I noticed some notes which I had been playing wrong because I thought a natural sign was a sharp or vise versa.

I notice when I get accidentally glutened my vision gets blurry again. I hope that's what you wanted to hear.

This is very interesting. My son got his glasses the week we took him gluten-free. He never once complained about wearing them or put up a fuss because it opened up a whole new world for him. Even now he doesn't argue about putting them on first thing in the morning. But I have noticed when he does his school work (we home school) or some drawings etc that he's been taking his glasses off. When I ask him why he tells me to wear them makes it worse. I never thought...

Sometimes, I think I'm going insane watching all his and my symptoms disappear. I wonder how an earth gluten can be responsible for all that. I think it runs in my family. My Mom has arthritis, IBS, diabetes and Alopecia (hair loss), My Grandma has MS and a plethora of bowel problems. My symptoms are less severe and mimic more chronic fatigue like symptoms. But they are all gone now since I have eliminated gluten as well as other proteins that resemble gluten.

I want to get our whole family tested through the lab in US. I want a diagnosis. The change in diet definately has shown us it's a serious problem but I want a diagnosis for validity and also so that I can share with others in my family so they can look into it to. kwim?

Cinthia

Amyleigh0007 Enthusiast
Amyleigh0007
Posted
Has anyone been diagnosed, either by a doctor, or themselves, just by doing a gluten free diet? and if so, is there a time frame, where you are suppose to stay gluten free, to help determine if in fact, it was the gluten causing the problems?

My allergist dx me with gluten intolerance based on response to diet plus a few other factors. I don't know about a time frame but when I went completely gluten free I felt better within a few days and much, much better after a few weeks. I am certain gluten was causing my problems since I feel so much better.

dilettantesteph Collaborator
dilettantesteph
Posted
Diagnose what? That something bad happens when you consume gluten? That can be done by diet alone. That might be enough.

Celiac on the other hand is a specific body response (auto immune) to gluten that mimics or overlaps with symptoms potentially caused by other things including an allergic reaction to gluten. I don't think you can get a true differential diagnosis from diet alone.

If you have a variety of symptoms which go away when you start a gluten free diet, and a lot of them could not be caused by allergy, then they come back when you eat gluten, and they go away again when you stop, how could that be anything but celiac disease?

  • 3 weeks later...
grommet Newbie
grommet
Posted
If you have a variety of symptoms which go away when you start a gluten free diet, and a lot of them could not be caused by allergy, then they come back when you eat gluten, and they go away again when you stop, how could that be anything but celiac disease?

It could be gluten intolerance as opposed to celiac disease?

At the moment as you know, the gold std for diagnosis of celiac disease is positive biopsy. but if this comes back negative, you are often not diagnosed with coeliac disease. So, what do you have?

Far be it from me to put words into the OP's mouth but I think he was saying you would not be able to differentiate between celiac disease and Gluten Intolerance just by diet alone.

You know gluten causes you a problem but you don't know whether you have celiac disease.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Celiac.com:
    Join eNewsletter
    Donate
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):



    Celiac.com Sponsors (A17-M):



  • Recent Activity

    1. Mari
      - Mari replied to Jmartes71's topic in Coping with Celiac Disease
      4

      Related issues

      jmartes, Thank you for sharing more information with us. Most of us Celiacs whose problems do not clear up with in a few years have to decide what to do next. We can keep seeing DR.s and hope that we will get some medication or advice that will improve our health. Or we can go looking for other ways to improve our health. Usually Celiac Disease is...
    2. Scott Adams
      - Scott Adams replied to catsrlife's topic in Celiac Disease Pre-Diagnosis, Testing & Symptoms
      4

      Patiently Waiting to See Results

      It's unfortunate that they won't work with you on this, but in the end sometimes we have to take charge of our own health--which is exactly what happened to me. I did finally get the tests done, but only after years of going down various rabbit holes and suffering. Just quitting gluten may be the best path for you at this point.
    3. catsrlife
      - catsrlife replied to catsrlife's topic in Celiac Disease Pre-Diagnosis, Testing & Symptoms
      4

      Patiently Waiting to See Results

      My doctor didn't take the time to listen to anything. I don't even think she knows what it means. She is more concerned about my blood pressure that is caused by her presence than anything else and just wants to push pills at me. The so-called dermatologist wouldn't do a skin test. she prescribed all of these silly antihistamine skin meds. This lady...
    4. Jmartes71
      - Jmartes71 replied to Jmartes71's topic in Coping with Celiac Disease
      4

      Related issues

      I had the test done by one of the specialist through second pcp I had only a few months because he was saying I wasn't.Even though Im positive HLA-DQ2 .My celiac is down played.I am with new pcp, seeing another girl doctor who wants to do another breathe test next month though Im positive sibo this year.I have high blood pressure not sure if its pain from...
    5. Scott Adams
      0

      Gluten-Free Peanut Butter Cup Swirl Brownies

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):


  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      132,260
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    sbr
    Newest Member
    sbr
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.5k
    • Total Posts
      1m
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):


  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • Mari
      Related issues

      By Mari · Posted

      jmartes, Thank you for sharing  more information with us. Most of us Celiacs whose problems do not clear up with in a few years have to decide what to do next. We can keep seeing DR.s and hope that we will get some  medication or advice that will improve our health. Or we can go looking for other ways to improve our health. Usually Celiac Disease is not a killer disease, it is a disabling disease as  you have found out. You have time to find some ways to help you recover. Stay on your gluten-free diet and be more careful in avoiding cross contamination . KnittyKitty  and others here can give you advice about avoiding some foods that can give you the gluten auto immune reaction and advice about vitamins and supplement that help celiacs. You may need to take higher doses of Vit. B12  and D3.  About 20 years before a Dr. suggested I might have Celiac disease I had health problems that all other Dr said they could not identify or treat. I was very opposed to alternative providers and treatments. So many people were getting help from a local healer I decided to try that out. It was a little helpful but then, because I had a good education in medical laboraties she gave me a book  to read and what did I think. With great skeptism I started reading and before I was half way through it I began using the methods outlined in the book. Using those herbs and supplements I went from hardly able to work to being able to work almost fulltime. I still use that program. But because I had undiagnosed celiac disease by 10 years later some  of my problems returned and I started to loose weight.    So how does a person find a program that will benefit them? Among the programs you can find online there are many that are snake oil scams and some that will be beneficial. by asking around, as I did. Is there an ND in your area? Do they reccomend that person? If you would like to read about the program I use go to www.drclark.net   
    • Scott Adams
      Patiently Waiting to See Results

      By Scott Adams · Posted

      It's unfortunate that they won't work with you on this, but in the end sometimes we have to take charge of our own health--which is exactly what happened to me. I did finally get the tests done, but only after years of going down various rabbit holes and suffering. Just quitting gluten may be the best path for you at this point.
    • catsrlife
      Patiently Waiting to See Results

      By catsrlife · Posted

      My doctor didn't take the time to listen to anything. I don't even think she knows what it means. She is more concerned about my blood pressure that is caused by her presence than anything else and just wants to push pills at me. The so-called dermatologist wouldn't do a skin test. she prescribed all of these silly antihistamine skin meds. This lady didn't even know what she was talking about and said "they never turn out as celiac, they usually just say it's dermatitis so here's your meds," just like my regular quack. I'm trying to change insurance companies at the moment and that has been a battle because of red tape, wrong turns, and workers having wrong phone numbers. What a joke! The allergy blood days say I have a wheat allergy of .31. Hopefully it's just that and until I find a decent doctor and dermatologist, I'll just lay off the wheat anyway, since it gives me asthma, high blood sugar, and joint pain. So frustrated at this point. The rash on my back of arms/elbows is mostly gone. Both calves and chest have started up. smh. It comes and goes. It fades faster now, though, although my forearms still produce one or two bumps on each side. The itching has calmed down a lot except for the bump area. I have dry skin to begin with so anything affecting it just makes it crazy. i'm never going to eat wheat again. I don't care if they need it to produce results or if it is just an intolerance, allergy, or celiac. It gives me hell.
    • Jmartes71
      Related issues

      By Jmartes71 · Posted

      I had the test done by one of the specialist through second pcp I had only a few months because he was saying I wasn't.Even though Im positive HLA-DQ2 .My celiac is down played.I am with new pcp, seeing another girl doctor who wants to do another breathe test next month though Im positive sibo this year.I have high blood pressure not sure if its pain from sciatica or sibo, ibs or hidden gluten. Im in disability limbo and I should have never been a bus driver because im still suffering and trying to heal with zero income except for my husband. This isnt fare that my health is dictating my living and having ti beg for being revalidation of my disregarded celiac disease. Its an emotional roller coaster I don't want to be on and the medical made it worse.New pcp new gi, exhausted, tired and really fed up. GI doctor NOT girl..
    • Mari
      Related issues

      By Mari · Posted

      Hi Jmartes, It sure is difficult to get useful advice from medical providers. Almost 20 years  ago a Dr suggested that I might have Celiacs and I took a Celiac Panel blood test. No gluten challenge diet. On that test the tTG was in normal range but an alpha antibody was very high. I went online and read about celiac disease and saw how I could investigate this low tTG and still have celiac disease. Normal tTG can happen when a person had been reacting for many years. Another way is that the person has not been eating enough gluten to raise the antibody level. Another reason is that the tTG does not show up on a blood but may show up on a fecal test. Almost all Celiacs inherit at least one of the 2 main Celiac genes. I had genetic tests for the Celiac genes at Enterolab.com. I inherited one main Celiac gene from one parent and the report said that the DQ gene I inherited from my other parent, DQ6, could cause a person to have more problems or symptoms with that combination. One of my grandmother's had fairly typical symptoms of Celiacs but the other grandmother had severe food intolerances. I seem to show some problems inherited from both grandmothers. Human physiology is very complex and researchers are just beginning to understand how different body systems interact.  If you have taken an autosomal DNA test you can download your raw data file and upload it to Prometheuw.com for a small fee and search for Celiac Disease. If you don't find any Cekiac genes or information about Celiac disease  you may not have autoimmune gluten intolerance because more than 99% of Celiacs have one or both of these genes.  PLEASE ASK QUESTIONS IF YOU WANT TO KNOW EHAT i HAVE DONE TO HELP WITH SYMPTOMS.  
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

NOTICE: This site places This site places cookies on your device (Cookie settings). on your device. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.