Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×
  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.




  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):



    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):


  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Cfs And Chocolate


frec

Recommended Posts

frec Contributor

Open Original Shared Link

I just ran into this article and thought some people on the forum might be interested, since many celiacs have CFS/FM type problems. At least it's a fun idea--chocolate as a medical treatment--that's the only reason I eat it, of course!


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



ShayFL Enthusiast

Man....I love chocolate....but it doesnt love me. I can eat it and feel fine, but a day later SEVERE DEPRESSION. I quit eating it for a year or so and then try eating it again. The same result every time. I just ate some 3 weeks ago in chocolate chip cookies (gluten-free of course). And within 24 hours I was in the depression "pit". Rats!!

RiceGuy Collaborator

I wonder if it's the magnesium which provides the benefits, and caffeine or theobromine withdrawal which causes the subsequent crash.

ShayFL:

Does the same happen with carob? Not that it would taste the same, but it has magnesium and of course no caffeine or Open Original Shared Link. See also Open Original Shared Link

ShayFL Enthusiast

Im not a fan of carob. It DOES NOT taste the same. :( Plus it is a legume which I am avoiding at present. All is not lost though....I have found yummies I can enjoy. :)

It is a neat thought though that something like chocolate can help people feel better. Just not me......

1grnthmb Newbie

This is really interesting that you feel more depressed after eating chocolate. I did an internet search about chocolate+depression and could not get any clear answer, some articles said it could happen while others said that chocolate helped people with depression. A lot of contradiction out there. One article did say that they felt it was the sugar that caused the uplift and then the down that some people feel after eating chocolate. Sugar is know for causing a quick rise in mood followed by a severe down turn as its affects wear off. So the question is could it be the sugar you are reacting to and not the chocolate?

Have you tried any of the low sugar dark chocolates? Hershey's just released one that they call heart smart or something like that. I am not a real fan of dark chocolate but I actually liked it. The one I tried had blueberries in it.

Mark

ShayFL Enthusiast

Mark...I can eat sugar in any other form without rebound depression. Chocolate just kills me. I will go a year without it and then try it again. I have retried it probably once every year for the last 15 years. EVERY TIME I get rebound depression. And it isnt just the "blues" either. It is in the "pit".....thoughts of suicide....nothing interests me. I cry. I lay in bed. And I am NEVER like this any other time. It is an odd depression for me.

Believe me. I wish it wasnt so. I love chocolate. And I have no explanation for my reaction but I do have a theory. It is documented that for some people who go off of anti-depressants they get "rebound depression" that is worse than the original depression. Chocolate has compounds in it that are anti-depressive. So I eat it one day and the next, my brain is screaming for those little receptor sites to be filled again.....and I get depressed so bad. Oddly, I do not crave the chocolate when I am depressed......

RiceGuy Collaborator
Im not a fan of carob. It DOES NOT taste the same.

Agreed, as I noted in my post.

But what strikes me as somewhat perplexing, is that most of the comments regarding carob are just that - it doesn't taste like chocolate. I mean, why would it, and why should we expect it to? Peanuts don't taste like chocolate either, but plenty of chocolate lovers seem to like peanuts. Almonds don't taste like walnuts, but lots of people like both. Raspberries don't taste like strawberries, but lots of people like both. So that's where I just don't get the carob-ain't-cocoa argument. Only thing I can figure, is maybe it has been suggested as a sub for chocolate too much, drilling it into everyone's head that that's how it is to be used.

Anyway, though I'm not really a fan of carob (or cocoa), I'm finding uses for carob lately. Often I just use a teaspoon or two, just because walnuts are so much more costly. Sure, they're different, but either one usually adds something likable to the resulting flavor.

Did you know there are at least two kinds of carob? I've found the light Virginia roast, and the dark roasted. Each has its own uniqueness.

I recall having a carob orange bar when I was little, and it was sooooo gooood! I can't say I ever got to taste that ever again, but I'm planning on duplicating it one of these days.


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



ShayFL Enthusiast

You are right. It is like comparing apples to oranges. But you suggested it to me in place of chocolate...hence my comparison. :)

If you can look at it as being carob and not a replacement for cocoa then you might be on to something. A long time ago when I was vegan I used to make my own homemade "raw" almond milk and I would add a scoop of carob to it with a few drops of Stevia. I thought it was delicious. But at the time my diet consisted mainly of sprouted horse food and grasses. My tastes are far more refined now....LOL

I might try carob again sometime. I challenged "legumes' in the form of black beans about a week ago. Next morning I had stiff hands and a stuffed up nose.

RiceGuy Collaborator
You are right. It is like comparing apples to oranges. But you suggested it to me in place of chocolate...hence my comparison. :)

OK, I guess that fair :lol: I was just wondering about the aftereffects, if any.

I might try carob again sometime. I challenged "legumes' in the form of black beans about a week ago. Next morning I had stiff hands and a stuffed up nose.

Not to drag this thread off topic any further, but do all things that come in pods have some particular substance in common, that isn't in most other things? I mean, little bean plants seem very different than trees. What about ordinary garden variety green peas? Those are technically legumes too, or so they say.

ShayFL Enthusiast

Ha ha ha....of course you drug it off topic even more. :P

I am avoiding all legumes right now including fake cinnamon (saigon and 90% of the cinnamon sold in the U.S.) It is really Cassia.

I bought some REAL cinnamon. It isnt as strongly flavored but still good.

RiceGuy Collaborator
Ha ha ha....of course you drug it off topic even more. :P

I am avoiding all legumes right now including fake cinnamon (saigon and 90% of the cinnamon sold in the U.S.) It is really Cassia.

I bought some REAL cinnamon. It isnt as strongly flavored but still good.

You're right that most of the cinnamon in the USA isn't regarded as true cinnamon, but apparently it's closely related. From what I've read, all cinnamon comes from certain related species of tree:

Open Original Shared Link

I've seen nothing about cinnamon being made from a legume. However, it seems that "Cassia" can refer to different things, one of which is a leguminous tree:

Open Original Shared Link

ShayFL Enthusiast

Just playing it safe. ;)

ShayFL Enthusiast

Look what I found....I'm not the only one!!!!!

Open Original Shared Link

And this explains it:

Open Original Shared Link

And proof that Chocolate is a drug:

Open Original Shared Link

Ha!!

Gemini Experienced
Look what I found....I'm not the only one!!!!!

Open Original Shared Link

And this explains it:

Open Original Shared Link

And proof that Chocolate is a drug:

Open Original Shared Link

Ha!!

Chocolate does influence seratonin levels...absolutely. My sister was put on an antidepressant (a seratonin re-uptake) and right on the label that gives all the pharmaceutical information it stated that chocolate should be eaten in much smaller doses and to watch how much is consumed because it will interfere with the meds. I would have ditched the meds, personally! :o

ShayFL Enthusiast

But my problem is that chocolate "gives me depression" and not the "Im down in the dumps kind"....but the "life is completely hopeless, I feel numb and I want to kill myself pit kind".........sigh

frec Contributor

Do you suppose that it is like the drugs used to treat hyperactivity and attention deficit? Drugs like Ritalin will make most people MORE hyperactive, but they make some hyperactive people calmer. I've had hyperactive students who said they get calmer with caffeine also, though I don't know for sure if that is true. (I teach nine year olds.)

ShayFL Enthusiast

Im not sure what it is....but it is weird....I have a history of things working "opposite" for me. Like Valium wakes me up.....LOL Go figure. These brains!!! :o

frec Contributor

Codeine makes me hyper--I had surgery once and was up all night wanting to go for a run--the doctor said a small percentage have that reaction. And goodness knows celiacs are already in the small percentage of weird reactions category.

I've read some research about drug reactions being genetically linked--redheads having different reactions to painkillers and anesthetics than other people.

  • 3 weeks later...
heiko.d.26 Newbie

:D How funny that some things seem to work opposite for you?

Lucky me, I don't get depressed from chocolate - I guess I couldn't take it if I would - I absolutely love alll kinds of Open Original Shared Link and to me it also has a positive effect.

The article was really interesting, thanks for posting!

On Wikipedia they have also got a short paragraph on Open Original Shared Link where it also says that dark chocolate is more healthy.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):



  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      127,727
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748

    AdamGF2023
    Newest Member
    AdamGF2023
    Joined

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):


  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121k
    • Total Posts
      70.4k

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):





  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):



  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • Marie70
      Wow!! Scott, Trent and Christiana thank you so much for your fast replies!! The information you have shared with me has helped me tremendously.   Thank you for all the articles.  I appreciate you all so much!! I’ll keep you posted in this post.  I will encourage her to get tested.  I feel a little better!
    • DayaInTheSun
      It was gradual, just not being able to catch my breathe like I always had to take a deep breathe even taking a few steps I would be winded.
    • cristiana
      Hi Marie Welcome to the forum. I am so sorry your daughter is pointing the finger at you like this.   I am afraid children of any age can be very cruel to their parents - I certainly look back at some of the things I said to my mother and father in the past, and wish I could unsay them.  Sometimes people just need a safe place to vent, and unfortunately having a go at one's parents is the all too easy option.  If she is anything like me, she will regret what she says one day.  (Oh... if only I had the chance rewind the clock!) I just wanted to add one more thing to Trent's and Scott's excellent posts and that is regarding diet:  I have to say, not one person  (my nutritionist, my gastroenterologist or GP) has EVER suggested that a poor diet was the cause of my coeliac disease.    In all the various clinics I have attended these past nearly 12 years no-one has ever asked if I was brought up on processed food, or questioned if I eat 5 fruit and veg a day.  Sure, unfortunately I am only too well aware that I could do a lot better with my diet and it's a constant challenge for me not to give into what I like (unfortunately I've always had a sweet tooth).   But I know some super healthy 10 fruit and veg a day types who still got coeliac disease, and equally, a lot of people who eat all the wrong stuff and they still have cast iron stomachs. Do encourage her to get checked though - it may be that she hasn't got coeliac disease at all. Come back to us if you need any more support through the process. Cristiana
    • trents
      Welcome to the forum, @Marie70! The first thing to know is that celiac disease has a genetic base. The two main genes that have been identified as providing the potential to develop celiac disease are HLA-DQ2 and HLA-DQ8. About 40% of  the general population carries one or both of these genes. However, only about 1% of the general population ever develops celiac disease. So, we know that in addition to possessing the genetic potential to develop celiac disease, there has to be some triggering environmental or medical "stress" factor (or factors) that switches the gene or genes on such that they are awakened from their latent condition and become active. What may be the triggering factor (or factors) is the subject of much debate. Here is an article that discusses this subject: Second, what will your daughter have to say if her testing for celiac disease is negative? She may have to add crow to her diet. Third, and this is what I really want to focus on because my wife and I are dealing with something similar in our relationship with our own adult daughter: the real problem is not whatever shortcomings you, as the family cook, may have had when providing meals, the real problem is with your daughter's heart/soul/attitude. If it turns out to be true that she has celiac disease, it is likely she would have developed the condition sooner or later even if her diet had been healthier while growing up. She is angry about the prospect of having to deal with the dietary and social limitations that having celiac disease would impose upon her. She doesn't want to face up to the fact that this may be a new reality that will dramatically changer her life and she is looking for someone or something to blame. And she has conveniently turned her wrath on you rather than saying to herself, "Okay, this is what it is. Now what can I do to make adjustments in order to with it the best way I can?"  When faced with a life-changing reality, people will either accept it for what it is, make adjustments and move on or they will become angry and look for something or someone to blame and get stuck. For now, at least, your daughter has chosen the latter option. Don't let her problem destroy both of you.
    • Scott Adams
      It sounds like you’re carrying a lot of guilt, but please know that you didn’t cause your daughter’s potential celiac disease or your son’s Crohn’s. These conditions have strong genetic components, and while diet can influence symptoms, it does not cause autoimmune diseases. You did the best you could with the knowledge you had at the time, and no parent is perfect. Your daughter’s frustration is understandable, but it’s likely coming from a place of fear and uncertainty rather than true blame. Let her get tested, and if she does have celiac disease, you can support her moving forward. Instead of focusing on guilt, try shifting the conversation toward healing and learning together. You’re not alone, and you don’t deserve to carry this weight on your own. This article might be helpful. She needs to be screened for celiac disease before she can be sure that she has it. Another approach not discussed in the article is a genetic test for celiac disease, which she could do without eating gluten.      
×
×
  • Create New...