Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):

    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Biopsy Negative...

DoogiePCT

Recommended Posts

DoogiePCT Apprentice
DoogiePCT
Posted

Hi Everyone,

I'm a 22 year old male with a history of thyroid cancer. So for the past few years, I've been having fatigue issues, along with gastrointestinal symptoms....I've also had a skin rash that looks to me like herpetiforms, and I have a diagnosed thyroid disorder that is well under control. Recently, I've become aware of Celiac disease, and called my doctor, and he informed that when I had an endoscopy a few months ago, they took a piece of my intestine to biopsy for celiac sprue, which came back negative. I asked him to fax it to me, and sure enough, they did and its negative.

My question is, could the biopsy be wrong? Or could I not have been consuming enough gluten in the days before for it to show?

Thanks so much.

Doug

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


happygirl Collaborator
happygirl
Posted

Welcome to the board!

How many biopsy samples did the pathology report describe?

Gfresh404 Enthusiast
Gfresh404
Posted
Hi Everyone,

I'm a 22 year old male with a history of thyroid cancer. So for the past few years, I've been having fatigue issues, along with gastrointestinal symptoms....I've also had a skin rash that looks to me like herpetiforms, and I have a diagnosed thyroid disorder that is well under control. Recently, I've become aware of Celiac disease, and called my doctor, and he informed that when I had an endoscopy a few months ago, they took a piece of my intestine to biopsy for celiac sprue, which came back negative. I asked him to fax it to me, and sure enough, they did and its negative.

My question is, could the biopsy be wrong? Or could I not have been consuming enough gluten in the days before for it to show?

Thanks so much.

Doug

You would have had to have been gluten-free for at least four weeks for it to skew the biopsy in any way. A couple days is not going to make a difference.

I am a bit skeptical as whether or not a biopsy can miss damage. I'm sure there are people out there that will disagree with me but if enough samples are taken it is rare for a biopsy to miss damage. Keep in mind though, a biopsy can only diagnose Celiac disease. Currently there is no diagnostic criteria for "Non-Celiac Gluten Sensitivity." NCGS is however gaining more and more attention and I would not be surprised if it becomes an official diagnosis within the next few years.

It is believed that NCGS affects significantly more people than Celiac does. It has also been noted that if people with NCGS continue to consume gluten for a long enough time period, they are very likely to develop Celiac disease. Many people, myself included, believe that Celiac Disease and NCGS are essentially the same thing. In Celiac however, the first organ that is attacked just happens to be the small intestine.

I myself would be considered a non-celiac. I had negative blood work and a negative biopsy, but still responded favorably to a gluten-free diet. The best way to know for sure if gluten is effecting you in any way is to give a gluten-free diet a try. See if you feel any better. But give it some time, I noticed an improvement within a day or two while some people don't start feeling better for months.

jerseyangel Proficient
jerseyangel
Posted

It's my understanding (and the belief of my former gastroenterologist) that the patchy damage from Celiac can be missed. The small intestine is around 22 feet long, and even with the doctor taking multiple samples (they should take 6-10) it can still be missed. There is also the issue of the skill of the person reading the test--milder damage can be overlooked this way.

If your doctor indeed only took one sample, it's quite possible any damage that might be there was missed.

A positive biopsy can rule Celiac in, but a "negative" can't altogether rule it out. If you've had the biopsy and the bloodwork, I would suggest giving the diet a try for a month and see if you feel better. :)

DoogiePCT Apprentice
DoogiePCT
Posted
  • Author

Hey all--

the report from the biopsy report says, quote: "Received in formalin, labeled "biopsy duodenum" are three (3) irregular fragments of soft, tan, mucosal tissue averaging 0.3 cm, in maximum dimension which are submitted in toto. 1/3 bm/ab. Small Bowel- duodenum-BIOPSY Negative small intestinal mucosa."

That puts me at ease that I haven't been murdering my own body with what I eat, since my guess is I don't have it. I will have the blood test and then let it go, the anxiety will be too much for me. LOL.

ravenwoodglass Mentor
ravenwoodglass
Posted
Hey all--

the report from the biopsy report says, quote: "Received in formalin, labeled "biopsy duodenum" are three (3) irregular fragments of soft, tan, mucosal tissue averaging 0.3 cm, in maximum dimension which are submitted in toto. 1/3 bm/ab. Small Bowel- duodenum-BIOPSY Negative small intestinal mucosa."

That puts me at ease that I haven't been murdering my own body with what I eat, since my guess is I don't have it. I will have the blood test and then let it go, the anxiety will be too much for me. LOL.

Since all that was biopsied was the duodenum you are not in the clear. I would suggest that you give the diet a good strict try for a month or so to see if it helps. You also should see a dermatologist and get the area beside the rash biopsied looking specifically for DH. If you have DH you have celiac.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):


  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      128,392
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    Caroline Cox
    Newest Member
    Caroline Cox
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.1k
    • Total Posts
      70.9k
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):


  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • NavyMom
      I’m terrified it’s too late for me😭

      By NavyMom · Posted

      Hi CathiJean, Wipe those tears my friend.  Finding out that you have celiac just gave you the cheat code on how to start feeling better!  It may feel like a loss right now, but honestly within 6 months you will start feeling better.  Within a year you will look back and wonder how in the world did I survive feeling like that for what feels like a lifetime?  You mentioned 15 years, that's about how long I have been really ill as well.  I had told every doctor I saw that I kept getting sick, infections, hair loss, joint pain, etc. and nobody would listen to me until I turned 45.  I went in for a colonoscopy and the doc says how often do you have bowel movements and I said usually between 10-15 times a day.  Suddenly I had someone actually listen to me and the testing began.  What I can tell you is use this forum, talk to peers, read everything you can about how to gluten-free your kitchen, encourage your family to participate in your journey (trust me they love you enough to make the effort), how to order food in restaurants, and how to avoid cross contamination.  Accept that you will make mistakes and allow yourself grace as you implement your new normal and have a clear understanding that going gluten free will begin healing your body in ways that you will not even begin to understand until you actually do it.  So, have faith that the nutrient deficiencies that you are probably experiencing right now can be corrected and you are on a bright path to feeling SO much better.  Think about how incredible your mom journey is about to become as you begin to feel better!!  Your kids are going to be amazed at your energy levels, ability to play and go do stuff...you are leveling up knowing that you have Celiac.  Knowing gives you power my friend, harness it and have gratitude that it was discovered...even if the docs missed it - you know now and keep moving forward.  You got this!! 
    • trents
      Negative biopsy and seeking doctor recs in Los Angeles

      By trents · Posted

      If you have been eating the gluten equivalent of 4-6 slices of wheat bread daily for say, 4 weeks, I think a repeat blood test would be valid.
    • englishbunny
      Negative biopsy and seeking doctor recs in Los Angeles

      By englishbunny · Posted

      it did include Total Immunoglobin A which was 135, and said to be in normal range. when i did the blood test in January I would say I was on a "light' gluten diet, but def not gluten free.  I didn't have any clue about the celiac thing then.  Since then I have been eating a tonne of gluten for the purpose of the endoscopy....so I'm debating just getting my blood test redone right away to see if it has changed so I'm not waiting another month...
    • trents
      Negative biopsy and seeking doctor recs in Los Angeles

      By trents · Posted

      Welcome to the forum, @englishbunny! Did your celiac panel include a test for "Total IGA"? That is a test for IGA deficiency. If you are IGA deficient, other IGA test resultls will likely be falsely low. Were you by any chance already practicing a reduced gluten free diet when the blood draw was done?
    • englishbunny
      Negative biopsy and seeking doctor recs in Los Angeles

      By englishbunny · Posted

      I'm upset & confused and really need help finding a new gastro who specializes in celiac in California.  Also will welcome any insights on my results. I tested with an isolated positive for deamidated IGA a few months ago (it was 124.3, all other values on celiac panel <1.0), I also have low ferritin and Hashimotos. Mild gastro symptoms which don't seem to get significantly worse with gluten but I can't really tell... my main issues being extreme fatigue and joint pain. The celiac panel was done by my endocrinologist to try and get to the bottom of my fatigue and I was shocked to have a positive result. Just got negative biposy result from endoscopy. Doctor only took two biopsies from small intestine (from an area that appeared red), and both are normal. Problem is his Physician's Assistant can't give me an answer whether I have celiac or not, or what possible reason I might have for having positive antibodies if I don't have it. She wants me to retest bloods in a month and says in the meantime to either "eat gluten or not, it's up to you, but your bloodwork won't be accurate if you don't" I asked if it could be I have early stage celiac so the damage is patchy and missed by only having two samples taken, and she said doctor would've seen damaged areas when performing endoscopy (?) and that it's a good sign if my whole intestine isn't damaged all over, so even if there is spotty damage I am fine.  This doesn't exactly seem satisfactory, and seems to be contrary to so much of the reading and research I have done. I haven't seen the doctor except at my endoscopy, and he was pretty arrogant and didn't take much time to talk. I can't see him or even talk to him for another month. I'm really confused about what I should do. I don't want to just "wait and see" if I have celiac and do real damage in the meantime. Because I know celiac is more that just 'not eating bread' and if I am going to make such a huge lifestyle adjustment I need an actual diagnosis. So in summary I want to find another doctor in CA, preferably Los Angeles but I don't care at this stage if they can do telehealth! I just need some real answers from someone who doesn't talk in riddles. So recommendations would be highly welcomed. I have Blue Shield CA insurance, loads of gastros in LA don’t take insurance at all 😣
×
×
  • Create New...