Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×
  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.




  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):



    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):


  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Symptoms: Do They Heighten (after Accidental Ingestion) Once Gluten-free


Lynayah

Recommended Posts

Lynayah Enthusiast

Since there were no replies, I moved this post to post-diagnosis. Thank you! Here it is again for reference:

I am currently eating gluten every day in preparation for a Celiac test in August.

Prior to this, I would have days where I would eat gluten and days were I would not. Some days, I thought I wasn't eating gluten but in fact was probably eating hidden gluten - and on those days I would be symptomatic.

Then I studied about true gluten-free eating, and for a two week period I tried to go gluten-free.

During those two weeks, I accidently ate gluten twice, and my body exploded with GI problems.

Then, University of Chicago told me that I needed to eat gluten every day -- a couple slices of bread would do, in preparation for the test.

For the first couple weeks, I was really uncomfortable, but now my heightened sensitivity seems to be less, which I find confusing to say the least!

My questions:

1- If a person is eating gluten every day is it normal for heightened sensitivity (in some people - I understand everyone is different) to subside a bit?

2- Once a person goes gluten-free, are the symptoms worse if gluten is accidentally eaten?

Thank you,

Lyn


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



nora-n Rookie

Yes.

A note about teh two slices of bread: when i did the math, I needed at least 6 slices of bread to add up to 0,3 g per kg. Nowadays they even recommend to increase to 0,5 g per kg per day. You will need to do your own math.

If you weigh 50 kg, you will need to eat 25 g of gluten.

To find the gluten, it is about 90% of the protein content of wheat. (and of bread without added milk)

And the duration, at lest 6 weeks, better three months.

I read some abstracts and the time frame is important, they put young celiacs on a gluten challenge and after some weeks all had relapsed, but only some after four weeks I think I remember.

Lynayah Enthusiast
Yes.

A note about teh two slices of bread: when i did the math, I needed at least 6 slices of bread to add up to 0,3 g per kg. Nowadays they even recommend to increase to 0,5 g per kg per day. You will need to do your own math.

If you weigh 50 kg, you will need to eat 25 g of gluten.

To find the gluten, it is about 90% of the protein content of wheat. (and of bread without added milk)

And the duration, at lest 6 weeks, better three months.

I read some abstracts and the time frame is important, they put young celiacs on a gluten challenge and after some weeks all had relapsed, but only some after four weeks I think I remember.

Thank you so very much for this information.

Oh my gosh. I hope I wasn't given wrong information -- my doctor's nurse told me the gluten I ate each day "didn't have to be much." This information came from the University of Chicago Celiac Center, and I assumed they were completely up on things.

I've been questioning the amount all along and have been very unsure and confused about so very, very, very much. There's such a hodgepodge of information out there. Augh!

I pray what U of C told me is true. I cringe at the idea of having to start all over again forcing myself to eat poison every day. I am feeling more down than I have felt in years, and it doesn't help that I am gaining weight no matter what I do, which is horribly depressing, too.

Worse yet, we are going to Disney in October and I have been PRAYING AND PRAYING that I'd be able to get my diagnosis before then so I could go gluten-free, be comfortable and have a good time.

I am feeling horribly sorry for myself this morning, for which I apologize. I just gotta say it: PREPARATION FOR THE TEST REALLY STINCKS!

Usually my attitude is more positive but I have been through so very many years of this, finally am just -- with hope -- getting to the other side of it, and I just don't know how many more months of making myself sick I can take.

I can handle the other symptoms but the weight gain has been the breaker for me. I've kept over 100 pounds off for almost 17 years and the fear of having to deal with weight gain until I have to get to the other side of this is very difficult.

Okay, now that I've had my pity party, I'll continue with a better attitude . . .

What you say is excellent informaton and very much appreciated. I just pray that I will get an accurate reading and won't have to start all over again.

nora-n Rookie

Hi, I did read your other note..

The information about 0,3 g per kg I found here in some article at celiac.com, and the part about 0,5g per kg I found in an abstract at www.pubmed.com .

I think one might get apositive biopsy on less gluten, but it is so individual.

When I went on a gluten challenge, I ate 21 or so g of gluten per day, and my weight went down slightly during the time.....I think it was because it was so much gluten that the villi were damaged. I was hungry all the time too.

But the biopsy was too soon, only 5 weeks. I should have asked for a later date. I thought I had eaten enough gluten in the time before but later realized it was way too little, just occasionally.

I did not have a hard time, but my DH skin sensations returned on the challenge (burning sensation) and just after the cchallenge the neurological sensations returned, and I went gluten-free again. Not fun when the feet and arms disappear (I did not know where they were)

a while ago I had some scio treatment (alternative stuff) and before christmas I was glutenend at a restaurant and the scio said my fatty acids were off. later I was glutened again with the same message from the scio.

Now fatty acids have a lot to do with weight.

I would think you will be able to have a normal weight afterwards when you go gluten-free again.

My weight just kept dropping afterwards.

nora

Lynayah Enthusiast
Hi, I did read your other note..

The information about 0,3 g per kg I found here in some article at celiac.com, and the part about 0,5g per kg I found in an abstract at www.pubmed.com .

I think one might get apositive biopsy on less gluten, but it is so individual.

When I went on a gluten challenge, I ate 21 or so g of gluten per day, and my weight went down slightly during the time.....I think it was because it was so much gluten that the villi were damaged. I was hungry all the time too.

But the biopsy was too soon, only 5 weeks. I should have asked for a later date. I thought I had eaten enough gluten in the time before but later realized it was way too little, just occasionally.

I did not have a hard time, but my DH skin sensations returned on the challenge (burning sensation) and just after the cchallenge the neurological sensations returned, and I went gluten-free again. Not fun when the feet and arms disappear (I did not know where they were)

a while ago I had some scio treatment (alternative stuff) and before christmas I was glutenend at a restaurant and the scio said my fatty acids were off. later I was glutened again with the same message from the scio.

Now fatty acids have a lot to do with weight.

I would think you will be able to have a normal weight afterwards when you go gluten-free again.

My weight just kept dropping afterwards.

nora

Very interesting, thank you. I have left a message for my upcoming doctor to see if I need to be eating more gluten.

What is SCIO?

nora-n Rookie

scio is something computer-based (alternative). It has databases of well people and sick people and bacteriae and allergies etc, but not everything....it is often quite right on. (but it did not have glutening in its database I think) (it did mention about the same IgG allergies as the IgG food intolerance test said. Ige is the usual allergy reaction, but IgG is more in-between allergy and auto-immune.

I wonder if they say something about how much gluten in a gluten challenge here: Open Original Shared Link

nora

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):



  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      127,382
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748

    SherryH
    Newest Member
    SherryH
    Joined

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):


  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121k
    • Total Posts
      70.1k

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):





  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):



  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • Jason Hi
      "Commit in a serious way to the gluten-free diet"....I've been Gluten-free since 2008. That's why I was so sick and had to take nausea and bloating medications during the gluten challenge week prior to the upper gastrointestinal endoscopy performed by the gastroenterologist. The "younger" doctor (the internal medicine who did the blood test), said the antibodies should remain in your system and you don't have to eat gluten (i.e., blood test last year). Hence my posting on finding a good doctor.
    • trents
      Well, the next step would logically be to commit in a serious way to the gluten-free diet and see if you have significant improvement in your symptoms. You should see improvement very soon with regard to GI issues and within weeks if there are other symptoms if gluten is indeed the issue. If there is significant improvement after going gluten free, that would tell you that you must avoid gluten and given the test results you already have, the logical conclusion is NCGS. As I said, an NCGS diagnosis is arrived at by first ruling out celiac disease, which seems to have been done. Then you could go back to that doctor with the other evidence component (improvement of symptoms with gluten-free eating) and ask if he/she would now be willing to declare an official dx of NCGS and give you a note. Or, you could book an appointment with another doctor who could look at your test results online, together with symptom improvement after going gluten-free, who might be more cooperative. I would seek out a younger practitioner as they are more likely to not be operating on outdated info about gluten disorders. By the way, NCGS is about 10x more common than celiac disease. 
    • Jason Hi
      Thank you for clarifying the terminology. Based on what my doctor told me, I understand that I do not have celiac disease, but that I’m “likely gluten sensitive.” From what I’ve researched, that places me in the category of Non-Celiac Gluten Sensitivity (NCGS)—as you mentioned, the key difference is that with NCGS there are no damaged villi and no positive celiac-specific antibodies. Either way, my treatment is the same: follow a gluten-free diet to avoid feeling sick. My understanding is that there are three main issues related to gluten: 1. Celiac Disease (produces specific antibodies and damages the small bowel) 2. Wheat Allergy (an immune response to wheat proteins) 3. Non-Celiac Gluten Sensitivity (negative celiac tests but still symptomatic from gluten) Regarding tax breaks or workplace accommodations, I came across a statement from celiac.org (https://celiac.org/gluten-free-living/federal-benefits/tax-deductions/) indicating that having any formal diagnosis—celiac disease or non-celiac gluten sensitivity—plus a prescription from a physician is typically required to qualify. In my case, my goal is to avoid feeling sick and secure documentation for both work and potential tax benefits. If I do pursue further tests or get more detailed lab results, I’ll share those here to confirm whether the doctor is suggesting celiac disease or truly NCGS. But as of now, the doctor’s comments lead me to believe I fall under NCGS.
    • trents
      Welcome to the forum, @Jason Hi! First, we need to deal with some squishy terminology. There are two terms which are, unfortunately, used interchangeably and indiscriminately to refer to two different gluten-related disorders. The two terms are "gluten sensitive" and "gluten intolerant". Because these terms are used carelessly we are not certain what you mean when you say your doctor told you that your are likely "gluten sensitive". The actual medical terms for these two gluten disorders are: "celiac disease" and "Non Celiac Gluten Sensitivity" or NCGS for short. The test you had run by the GI doc are intended to check for celiac disease. There is no test for NCGS. To arrive at a diagnosis of NCGS, celiac disease must first be ruled out.  Because these terms are used by many people interchangeably I'm not sure that your doctor, after running the tests, was intending for you to understand that he believes you have celiac disease or NCGS. So, to clear up the confusion, can you post the results of your blood test, not just the test scores but the reference ranges used by the lab analyzing the blood sample to determine negative/positive or normal/high? The difference between celiac disease and NCGS is that celiac disease damages the lining of the small bowel over time whereas NCGS does not. However, they may share many of the same gastro intestinal symptoms. Both need to be addressed with a gluten free diet but the tax breaks and work place accommodations you speak of would likely only accrue from an official celiac disease diagnosis. So, can you post the blood test results along with the reference ranges and also the endoscopy report. We can help you decipher whether or not the doc was suggesting you may have celiac disease or NCGS if you will do that.
    • Jason Hi
      I recently had an upper gastrointestinal endoscopy and blood tests, and my gastroenterologist concluded that I’m “likely gluten sensitive.” However, they wouldn’t provide a prescription or a formal doctor’s note—just a test result saying I’m likely gluten sensitive, along with the advice to avoid gluten. I’m frustrated because I know that proper documentation could help with tax breaks for gluten-free foods and even workplace accommodations. I’m also not willing to go through another gluten challenge—it was rough! Does anyone have recommendations for a doctor (U.S. based preferably Texas) who is more understanding and willing to provide the necessary documentation for gluten sensitivity? I’d really appreciate any suggestions!
×
×
  • Create New...