Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):

    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Gluten Challenge-Questions

crampy girl

Recommended Posts

crampy girl Apprentice
crampy girl
Posted

Ok, I am on day 7 of this gluten challenge. I have to admit I have not been doing the full on 4 servings, started with one, progressed to 3 due to fear of reoccurance of my horrible stomach cramps and D. I have mild cramping after I eat gluteney stuff (cheezits, triscuits, bagels, bread, cream of wheat) but no diarrhea yet. My scopes are in 3 weeks. My question is this:

1. Do I have to eat the same amount that were causing my symtoms to get the "damage" to show up on endoscopy? ( I was having daily cramps, and 2x a week dibillitating episodes) Everything I have read says 4 servings 4 weeks, I was gluten free for 12 weeks prior to the challenge.

2. Since I haven't had a major reaction, is it possible that I have a threshold and as long as I stay under it, I am ok, ie, no damage to intestines, organs,etc. and that I don't have Celiac but rather just gluten intolerance, therefore I can sneak some amount. Does this hold true for casein, soy?

3. Does Dr. Fines Enterolab results of IgA really hold true for anyone, I wonder if I am really milk protein/soy allergic and symtomatic?? Has anyone found this to be true????? I do have cramps with lactaid milk if I am overdoing it on milk products (usual consumtion is 3-4 servings of dairy daily)

those are loaded questions. I don't expect a straight foward answer just wanted to see what you guys with celiac/gluten intolerance thought or have experienced......

thanks in advance. You guys have been so helpful and I really appreciate it.

Crampygirl.....

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


jerseyangel Proficient
jerseyangel
Posted

Hi Crampy,

I've not done a gluten challenge myself, and I'm not an expert-- but having been around here for years I notice that many times people that have gone gluten-free for a while and then reintroduce gluten have varied responses. I don't think there is an established pattern--it kind of depends on how damaged you were, how quickly you heal, and just your own reaction pattern.

I've seen people that reacted strongly to trace amounts when on the diet take a while to react when eating gluten full on. Some get awful reactions right away. From personal experience, I wouldn't equate reactions with possible damage--they don't always go hand in hand.

My advice to you would be to stay the course and try to stay as close to the "4 slices a day or the equivalent" as you can if you want as accurate a result as possible.

crampy girl Apprentice
crampy girl
Posted
  • Author

Thanks Jersey angel, I had some more cramps and 3 trips to the bathroom so far, no D yet, but scared. I will stay on course with 4 pieces of bread. 2 more pieces to go today.

cassP Contributor
cassP
Posted

some members on here suggest that at least 2 months or more is required for a proper gluten challenge.

my doc only put me on a 2 week challenge- and my tests were pretty weak.. they werent positive enough for the docs to think i was Celiac 2 years ago.. but i am indeed a Celiac..

honestly tho- i dont think i could have handled more than 2 weeks- i was emotionally DONE... oddly my bowels were not as bad off as they had been in the past- but my anxiety and shakiness was thru the roof- i was DONE

good luck with your challenge- i know how uncomfortable/painful it can be

PS-make sure they do all the blood tests so that the challenge wasnt a waste of your time

Skylark Collaborator
Skylark
Posted

1. Do I have to eat the same amount that were causing my symtoms to get the "damage" to show up on endoscopy? ( I was having daily cramps, and 2x a week dibillitating episodes) Everything I have read says 4 servings 4 weeks, I was gluten free for 12 weeks prior to the challenge.

2. Since I haven't had a major reaction, is it possible that I have a threshold and as long as I stay under it, I am ok, ie, no damage to intestines, organs,etc. and that I don't have Celiac but rather just gluten intolerance, therefore I can sneak some amount. Does this hold true for casein, soy?

3. Does Dr. Fines Enterolab results of IgA really hold true for anyone, I wonder if I am really milk protein/soy allergic and symtomatic?? Has anyone found this to be true????? I do have cramps with lactaid milk if I am overdoing it on milk products (usual consumtion is 3-4 servings of dairy daily)

1. You have to eat a LOT of gluten if you are only challenging for 4 weeks. One study showed the median time for reappearance of damage for a challenge with a light amount of gluten is about 12 weeks. Yours may come back faster since you weren't gluten-free for too long.

2. You have DQB1*0201, which is linked to DQA1*0501. That means you have pretty good chance of having a copy of DQ2.5. If I had DQB1*0201, cramps from wheat, and all your symptoms, I would personally go strictly gluten-free. You may not have full-blown celiac disease, but you have what we currently think is the genetic background to develop it. You can always reintroduce wheat if we learn more in the future and there are more tests. You can't "undo" celiac from eating wheat beyond when your body starts to complain. (This is based partly on seeing a talk by Markku Maki. He is of the opinion that everyone with DQ2.5 and reactions to gluten should go gluten-free for life.)

3. Dr. Fine's Enterolab is not a validated clinical diagnostic test. There is no data to discuss whether it holds true for everyone, as he has not seen fit to publish any. If you have cramps from a food, that is a much more definite sign of intolerance.

crampy girl Apprentice
crampy girl
Posted
  • Author

Thanks Skylark, you are always so helpful. After this challenge, once I get my scope results back, I think I am going to redo the blood tests. But, everything I am reading and seeing posted here tells me what you do. It's just so painful. I am going to resolve that I will go gluten free no matter what my scope/blood work says since I am symtomatic from gluten (just takes a larger dose of it to get it flared up) and it's probably only a matter of time before the bomb will go off. Today was a borderline day, I had cramps with several bm but no D, but my reflux, burping and gas are all back when they had disappeared off gluten. I swear it's like a drug, you try a little and get little pleasure, up the annie and taste starts to come back and before you know it, I am out of control and want to eat a box of cheese its, or pig out on bread and butter.

It would be so much easier if my husband would do it with me. And if my kids had it too. I am thinking of testing them for the celiac blood profile and enterolab and if either come back positive for gliadin or Ttg auto antibodies that will make it so much easier to convert my entire house hold to meat and potatoes. Sighhhh. thanks for always being there Skylark, I mean that.

Anita

Skylark Collaborator
Skylark
Posted

Glad to help a little. As far as your kids, they have a 50% chance of having DQB1*0201 so it makes sense to get them celiac panels, especially if they show any GI or nervous system trouble.

You'll get used to the diet, even with gluten-eaters around. You don't need to push your husband into the diet, unless you turn out to be highly sensitive and need a gluten-free kitchen. What you DO need is support from him, not waving pizza in your face, keeping crumbs cleaned up, maintaining separate jars of peanut butter and mayo - that sort of thing. It's pretty easy to find "normal" foods that are gluten-free to feed your family at mealtime. Really it's better if your husband and kids are healthy on a normal diet, right?

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):


  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      126,203
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    Milarynn
    Newest Member
    Milarynn
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      120.9k
    • Total Posts
      69.2k
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):


  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • kopiq
      starting to heal, vitamin d deficiant but cannot tolerate vitamins. what to do? also multiple ongoing issues.

      By kopiq · Posted

      I also have food particles left on toiet paper when i wipe and my stool is light yellow not absorbing fats. I urinate about 15 times a day and have very sticky snot,dry throat.
    • kopiq
      starting to heal, vitamin d deficiant but cannot tolerate vitamins. what to do? also multiple ongoing issues.

      By kopiq · Posted

      Hi all, I was diagnosed by blood work about 2 months ago and have since went on a strict gluten free diet. I have an endoscopy in January and the GI dr said nothing about staying on gluten for it; hes aware i went no gluten. starting to heal symptoms include: (this is huge) sensation coming back to genitals and when having a bowl movement. everything has been numb for a long time down there including lower belly button area. good size (not abnormal) bowel movements once a day or every two days. small dot size wart just fell off my finger that was there for years. have not broke out with a cold sore this winter (every winter prior for years i would develop a cold sore on my lip) Ongoing issues I don't sweat. not from my hands, or armpits or feet. I do not get butterflys in stomach. my hands have been so dry for years ive been using a crack cream as they crack and bleed very severely in the fall and winter.  (since going gluten free ive not used crack cream but they are still very very dry and chapped/flaky, no sweat or moisture in palms of hands at all. I dont crave food. i have no cravings at all, not for pizza, ice cream , nothing. my cravings are dead. smell of foods kinda make me hungry, but my stomach blocks it. pins needles in feet get weak legs standing up from sitting and dizzy, things almost turn black. i cannot tolerate veggies or vitamins. Iam vitamin D deficient according to my Dr and Ive tried vitamin D pills. they give me a massive migraine for 8 hours and upset my stomach. the heat from the direct sun make me extremely tired to the point of wanting to pass out. again i don't sweat. broccoli gives me a migraine headache as well. mushrooms, bell peppers burn my stomach. fruits burn my stomach, fats (peanut butter, any oil or fat from meats make me sick to my stomach for a couple hours or longer. salt and pepper burns my stomach. all these issues cause pain at my belly button area and expand to the rest of my upper stomach and sides the more i ingest through out the day. I currently eat bland basmati rice, chicken, pork chops (fat trim), boiled russet potatoes no skin for three meals a day. my snacks are gluten free ground buckwheat flour pancakes. (just water, no oil , salt, dairy.) how am i to get vitamins in my system if i cannot tolerate them in my stomach? i mentioned epidermal vitamin patchs but dr said no. why cant i stand the heat from the sun ? why cant i sweat? thanks for any info.                
    • trents
      Celiac Maybe a Possibility?

      By trents · Posted

      Because you have significantly reduced your gluten intake over a considerable amount of time, it is likely that you will test negative on the antibody tests. However, if the $112 for the Quest test is not a burden, it wouldn't hurt to try. It tests for total IGA (to ascertain if you are IGA deficient) and tTG-IGA. If total IGA is deficient, it can result in false negatives in other IGA tests. The tTG-IGA is the single most popular test ordered by physicians. The Quest test is not a complete celiac panel by any means (refer to the linked article above) but it might be a good place to start. Personally, I think you know enough to conclude that you need to get serious about avoiding gluten, whether you have celiac disease or NCGS. Human nature being what it is, however, many people seem to need an official diagnosis of celiac disease in order to stay on the bandwagon. Otherwise, they seem to rationalize cheating on the gluten-free diet. And there is this misconception out there that NCGS is inconvenient and uncomfortable but not harmful so it's okay to cheat. The more we learn about gluten-related disorders the more they seem to not fit into our neat little black and white categories. By the way, celiac disease is not a food allergy. It is classified as an autoimmune disorder.
    • More2Learn
      Celiac Maybe a Possibility?

      By More2Learn · Posted

      These responses are all extremely helpful, ty.  Really good reminder about omega 6.  I also know I'm low in zinc; I took the zinc test where I drank it on a spoon and couldn't taste it.  To that end, I try to eat a lot of oysters.  I do think it would be a good idea to get the blood test.  Two questions: 1-  Is there any reason you wouldn't recommend that I just buy and take a test like this as a first step? 2- I've been somewhat gluten free since ~Jan 2023 (technically organic, gluten free, soy free, light on dairy).  I eat a lot of meat, vegetables, rice -- a common breakfast for me is three eggs and a sausage link, and I can't remember the last time I had a sandwich or bread.  However, because in my mind I didn't think I had an allergy, and I more was doing gluten free to avoid artificially iron-enriched foods, I do make exceptions.  I'll eat breaded calamari.  When my Dad visits, I split mozzarella sticks with him because he loves them so much.  I'll eat the "gluten sensitive" items at a restaurant and if they asked, "is cross contamination ok?",  I always said yes.  Based on that, since I never probably fully eliminated gluten, but it was significantly reduced... is that good enough to take the blood test?  Because the pain in my side gets SO bad (really sometimes I can't function, and I absolutely thought I was dying), I am hesitant to do the gluten challenge.  Would it make sense to take the test, and if it's negative, then consider doing the challenge and seeing if I can deal with eating the bread every day? Thanks again!
    • Yaya
      Muscle Twitching

      By Yaya · Posted

      For me, with osteoporosis, Celiac and more than 1 heart condition, the slower, safer route is preferable.  I'm on 5 meds per day.  Too much of anything can disturb absorption of this or that. Have a Happy Thanksgiving.  I'm gone for a few days.  
×
×
  • Create New...