Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×
  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.




  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):



    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):


  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

What Is The Gluten-Free Standard?


xMichellex

Recommended Posts

xMichellex Rookie

I believe I am getting better at reading labels. I thought that to be safe it was best to stick to stuff that has been labeled


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



psawyer Proficient

At the moment, in the US, there is no legal definition of "gluten-free."

Click here to go to a discussion a few months ago.

xMichellex Rookie

At the moment, in the US, there is no legal definition of "gluten-free."

Click here to go to a discussion a few months ago.

Peter,

I read the entire post. Thanks for that link. I am now truly bummed. This is discouraging and frightening.

Since you are so well informed on this topic, may I ask you another question?

Say that I consume 3 different produts in one day and each tests at 20ppm. Does that mean that I just consumed 60ppm? So perhaps I am not reacting to one product but rather to an accumulation?

psawyer Proficient

Michelle,

Lots of people get hung up on ppm, which is vexing because it really is a meaningless number. Like percentages, which ppm is a form of, most people have trouble understanding what they really mean.

Here is an example from the percent world. You make $20 per hour working for me. Times are really tough, so I insist that you take a 50% wage cut just to keep your job. 50% of $20 is $10. Your new wage is $10 per hour. Oh, wait, we just got a huge contract from a new customer. I can give you a 50% increase in your wages. That reverses the cut, right? Wrong. 50% of $10 is $5 and your new wage is $15 per hour.

Tests can detect 20 ppm or 5 ppm or some other detection threshold. A product tested for 20 ppm may, in fact, contain 19 ppm or 0 ppm, or any amount in between.

Let us assume that we have two baked products. One is tested for 5 ppm and the other for 20 ppm. Let us also assume that each is right at the detection limit, say 4.9 ppm and 19.9 ppm--that is not a valid assumption, but let's run with it for the moment.

Let's eat a 10 gram serving of the 20 ppm tested product. That's 196 micrograms of gluten.

Now, let's eat a 40 gram serving of the 5 ppm tested product. Holy cow! We still ate 196 micrograms of gluten.

What matters in terms of the gluten-free diet is the total amount of gluten ingested, not whether it came from dilute or concentrated sources. And I cannot repeat enough times, tested to X ppm does not mean contains X ppm. The content is less and is often far, far less than the test threshold.

I hope that helps. If not, let me know, but I didn't want to bury you in mathematics. It was my major...

xMichellex Rookie

Michelle,

Lots of people get hung up on ppm, which is vexing because it really is a meaningless number. Like percentages, which ppm is a form of, most people have trouble understanding what they really mean.

Here is an example from the percent world. You make $20 per hour working for me. Times are really tough, so I insist that you take a 50% wage cut just to keep your job. 50% of $20 is $10. Your new wage is $10 per hour. Oh, wait, we just got a huge contract from a new customer. I can give you a 50% increase in your wages. That reverses the cut, right? Wrong. 50% of $10 is $5 and your new wage is $15 per hour.

Tests can detect 20 ppm or 5 ppm or some other detection threshold. A product tested for 20 ppm may, in fact, contain 19 ppm or 0 ppm, or any amount in between.

Let us assume that we have two baked products. One is tested for 5 ppm and the other for 20 ppm. Let us also assume that each is right at the detection limit, say 4.9 ppm and 19.9 ppm--that is not a valid assumption, but let's run with it for the moment.

Let's eat a 10 gram serving of the 20 ppm tested product. That's 196 micrograms of gluten.

Now, let's eat a 40 gram serving of the 5 ppm tested product. Holy cow! We still ate 196 micrograms of gluten.

What matters in terms of the gluten-free diet is the total amount of gluten ingested, not whether it came from dilute or concentrated sources. And I cannot repeat enough times, tested to X ppm does not mean contains X ppm. The content is less and is often far, far less than the test threshold.

I hope that helps. If not, let me know, but I didn't want to bury you in mathematics. It was my major...

Peter,

You didn't bury me. You have just set me straight. Since we are dealing with arbitrary numbers and voluntary labeling and testing, there is no way to truly know what is being ingested.

The safest bet (for me) is the whole foods approach, at least until I figure things out. I just wish that would happen soon.

Peter, your information has been invaluable. I thought this website was a great resource, but now I see that the moderators are a big part of that. Thanks again.

eatmeat4good Enthusiast

Michelle,

He buried me.

But your first sentence cleared it up.

We can't know in the United States, how much gluten we are eating, if we choose to eat gluten free products.

Is that about it?

Whole foods for me then.

I only understood the words arbitrary plus voluntary equals cross contamination for those who are sensitive.

Thank you both.

I thought gluten free was gluten free.

Yikes :blink:

tarnalberry Community Regular

Here is an example from the percent world....

Peter, that was an EXCELLENT example/walkthrough!


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



dilettantesteph Collaborator

I often react to gluten free foods. It helps to check if they are made in a gluten free facility or on gluten free lines. After many occasions of getting sick you figure out which companies work out better. There are also various certifying programs and it can help to check if the food is certified by one of the better ones. It takes a lot of trial and error to figure it all out. It isn't the same for all celiacs. Our tolerances seem to vary widely.

jerseyangel Proficient

I often react to gluten free foods. It helps to check if they are made in a gluten free facility or on gluten free lines. After many occasions of getting sick you figure out which companies work out better. There are also various certifying programs and it can help to check if the food is certified by one of the better ones. It takes a lot of trial and error to figure it all out. It isn't the same for all celiacs. Our tolerances seem to vary widely.

This is what it comes down to for me also.

xMichellex Rookie

I often react to gluten free foods. It helps to check if they are made in a gluten free facility or on gluten free lines. After many occasions of getting sick you figure out which companies work out better. There are also various certifying programs and it can help to check if the food is certified by one of the better ones. It takes a lot of trial and error to figure it all out. It isn't the same for all celiacs. Our tolerances seem to vary widely.

That is probably the way to go, but only if you don't mind being your own guinea pig. I'm so new at this and I feel so raw still that I am afraid of getting sick. Partly because I am in grad school and getting sick can cause a lot of trouble there for me and partly because I have just barely begun to taste the freedom from being sick.

dilettantesteph Collaborator

That is probably the way to go, but only if you don't mind being your own guinea pig. I'm so new at this and I feel so raw still that I am afraid of getting sick. Partly because I am in grad school and getting sick can cause a lot of trouble there for me and partly because I have just barely begun to taste the freedom from being sick.

I totally understand. In that case, eat a grain free whole foods diet. Wash everything carefully. Peel what you can. You can try more things later when you are up to it.

jeannieknits Rookie

this thread is perfect....peter your information is invaluable!

I have been reacting lately to "gluten free" breads and now I'm thinking I know why.

bummed out, but informed.

thank you.

xMichellex Rookie

I totally understand. In that case, eat a grain free whole foods diet. Wash everything carefully. Peel what you can. You can try more things later when you are up to it.

That is very sound advice. It took more than a couple of days to make me so sick, then it will certainly take more than a few to get me better. For now, I am just going to keep it simple.

Good idea about the peeling. I always thought that the extra fiber you get from skins is healthy, but perhaps for now, at least, I should take your advice. Thanks!

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Celiac.com:
    Donate

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):





    Celiac.com Sponsors (A17-M):




  • Recent Activity

    1. - Ann13 replied to Iris Kraft's topic in Gluten-Free Foods, Products, Shopping & Medications
      14

      Inhaler problem

    2. - trents replied to Iris Kraft's topic in Gluten-Free Foods, Products, Shopping & Medications
      14

      Inhaler problem

    3. - Ann13 replied to Iris Kraft's topic in Gluten-Free Foods, Products, Shopping & Medications
      14

      Inhaler problem

    4. - trents replied to Iris Kraft's topic in Gluten-Free Foods, Products, Shopping & Medications
      14

      Inhaler problem

    5. - trents replied to Iris Kraft's topic in Gluten-Free Foods, Products, Shopping & Medications
      14

      Inhaler problem


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):



  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      128,820
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748

    Charisse25
    Newest Member
    Charisse25
    Joined

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):


  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.1k
    • Total Posts
      71.2k

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):





  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):



  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • Ann13
      Not everyone will be allergic to whatever they're using in food. There is another forum re people who are posting they have vocal cord & throat issues after they eat breads & pastas which stopped after they removed those foods from their diets. Same as me...gluten doesn't react as gastrointestinal it reacts orally. Which is why I'm saying ensure all your food isn't what you're having a reaction to.  ...& I used Cornflakes as an example because some gluten free people would assume it's gluten free but if they're allergic to barley they will have a reaction...nothing to do with their inhaler.  You're missing my points a lot & frustrating so I'm done commenting. You really need to ensure your food isn't what's causing the issue. I am checking with symbicort manufacturer to check their ingredients.  Good bye... I'm done with this. 
    • trents
      I certainly agree with all that. However, you also mentioned cornflakes with barley malt but that would obviously not be gluten free since barley is a gluten-containing grain. And the chemicals they spray on grains would affect everyone, not just those with gluten disorders. I'm just trying to figure out what this thread has to do with the main subject this online community is focused on. Is the point of this thread that having a gluten disorder makes someone more susceptible to reacting adversely to inhalers? That could be but it may have nothing to do with the inhaler having gluten. It could have to do with, say, having higher systemic yeast counts because the celiac community generally suffers from gut dysbiosis. So it would be easier for celiacs using inhalers to develop thrush.
    • Ann13
      Re food,  I said the gluten free thing isn't necessarily about gluten itself, but chemical sprays they use on GRAINS which cause allergic throat & vocal cord issues regardless of the inhaler you're using.  Your issue may not be the inhaler but eating gluten free food that still will bother you because they have been sprayed with certain chemicals. Barley & oats cause vocal and throat issues with me as well as gluten free flours. We didn't have gluten issues in the world yrs ago...the food changed somehow or they're using sprays that cause reactions in some people.  Re inhaler: Symbicort is registered as gluten free but companies can change their ingredients at any time so you may want to check with the company who makes it and get an ingredient list.  I don't believe I'm reacting to the inhaler...I believe it's a gluten free pasta I've been eating so I'm taking it out of my diet. I've used the inhaler for over 1 year and no problems up until now so I suspect it's the pasta. 
    • trents
      There could be other reasons you are reacting to the inhalers. There is no concrete evidence to believe they contain gluten. Anecdotal experiences can be misleading do not establish fact.
    • trents
      Are you saying you believe there is gluten in the inhaler products? I mean you talk a lot about reacting to foods that are supposed to be gluten free but this thread is about inhalers. 
×
×
  • Create New...