Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×
  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.




  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):



    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):


  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Brown Rice Intolerance - Wild Rice Ok? Other Foods To Avoid?


sreese68

Recommended Posts

sreese68 Enthusiast

I definitely do not tolerate brown rice. The first few weeks I went gluten-free, I could eat it without much trouble. But about 5 weeks into it, I reacted to Tikiyada brown rice pasta - 2 days after eating it, I had bad stomach pain for 2 days. I waited a couple of weeks and ate one serving of Lundberg brown rice to confirm that that was indeed the culprit. After 2 days, my pain came on worse than the last time and caused my constipation to get really bad - had 5 days of trouble that time. (I just discovered this week that my reaction to gluten is primarily neuro, so it wasn't an issue of CC.)

What I don't get is that I can eat white rice with no problems. I'm curious if wild rice would be an issue? Are there other foods that have something in common with brown rice that I should be very careful of? I saw a couple of things mentioned that brown rice has that white rice doesn't. One was phytic acid. But it's also in corn and peanuts, and I can eat corn products and peanut butter with no trouble. I also looked up lectin. But it's in potatoes, strawberries, and oranges, and I can eat all of those.

I certainly hope that this is an intolerance that fades the longer I'm gluten-free. It's in SO many gluten-free products!!!


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



mushroom Proficient

Intolerances can be funny things (not humurous, however) :( You mentioned lectins, for example. Hardly anyone is intolerant to all lectins. I am intolerant to more than most, but I handle dairy just find. You can be intolerant to a few lectins, or one or two, or only one. Sometimes it depends on how much of the particular food you eat. I used to eat a lot of nightshades. After I became intolerant of them I ate a lot of legumes - yep, you guessed it, intolerant now. Since I enjoy strong flavors I eventually became intolerant of citrus through overuse. :( I am hoping to be able to reintroduce some of these foods. Also, I haven't eaten corn that contains the outer covering for years, but I can tolerate cornstarch in baking, which is highly refined. I have no idea of its lectin content, but it might have something to do with the fact that it is combined with other foods also.

I eat white rice rather than brown rice because most of the lectins in rice are contained in the bran and I am not anxious to add rice to my no-go list. And you should have no problem with wild rice because it is a grass, a different family from regular rice.

GlutenFreeManna Rising Star

I definitely do not tolerate brown rice. The first few weeks I went gluten-free, I could eat it without much trouble. But about 5 weeks into it, I reacted to Tikiyada brown rice pasta - 2 days after eating it, I had bad stomach pain for 2 days. I waited a couple of weeks and ate one serving of Lundberg brown rice to confirm that that was indeed the culprit. After 2 days, my pain came on worse than the last time and caused my constipation to get really bad - had 5 days of trouble that time. (I just discovered this week that my reaction to gluten is primarily neuro, so it wasn't an issue of CC.)

What I don't get is that I can eat white rice with no problems. I'm curious if wild rice would be an issue? Are there other foods that have something in common with brown rice that I should be very careful of? I saw a couple of things mentioned that brown rice has that white rice doesn't. One was phytic acid. But it's also in corn and peanuts, and I can eat corn products and peanut butter with no trouble. I also looked up lectin. But it's in potatoes, strawberries, and oranges, and I can eat all of those.

I certainly hope that this is an intolerance that fades the longer I'm gluten-free. It's in SO many gluten-free products!!!

Okay a few things for you to consider:

1. Was the Tinkyada made in pans previously used for gluten pastas or drained in a strainer previously used for gltuen pastas? Did you take care to eliminate all forms of cc? And what did you eat with the Tinkyada? Any type of sauce or butter, etc.?

Althoguh your reaction may have been primarily neuro, reactions can change after goign gluten-free. I did not have any of the bad digestive symtpoms prior to goign gluten-free. Now I get the neuro symptoms AND the digestive symptoms too.

2. Lundberg is labeled gluten free, but I have read of others on this board having trouble with that brand specifically.

3. You may just not be able to digest brown rice yet. It may be somethign you just need to avoid for several months until your body heals more. However if it bothers you there's really no harm in eating white rice instead. I know people talk about how "healthy" brown rice is compared to white but really IMO that does not apply to people with issues such as celiac. Wheat is considered to be "healthy" too and we can't eat that. It's better for you to avoid foods that make you sick. With the brown rice I would avoid it for at least 6 months and then trial it to see if the reactions were the same.

sreese68 Enthusiast

Okay a few things for you to consider:

1. Was the Tinkyada made in pans previously used for gluten pastas or drained in a strainer previously used for gltuen pastas? Did you take care to eliminate all forms of cc? And what did you eat with the Tinkyada? Any type of sauce or butter, etc.?

Althoguh your reaction may have been primarily neuro, reactions can change after goign gluten-free. I did not have any of the bad digestive symtpoms prior to goign gluten-free. Now I get the neuro symptoms AND the digestive symptoms too.

2. Lundberg is labeled gluten free, but I have read of others on this board having trouble with that brand specifically.

3. You may just not be able to digest brown rice yet. It may be somethign you just need to avoid for several months until your body heals more. However if it bothers you there's really no harm in eating white rice instead. I know people talk about how "healthy" brown rice is compared to white but really IMO that does not apply to people with issues such as celiac. Wheat is considered to be "healthy" too and we can't eat that. It's better for you to avoid foods that make you sick. With the brown rice I would avoid it for at least 6 months and then trial it to see if the reactions were the same.

Thanks for the suggestions. I made the pasta in an unscratched stainless steel pot I had scrubbed VERY well. Brand new strainer only used for gluten-free food. I only used butter on the pasta and have since used buttter with no trouble. Another reason I suspect brown rice is that I had a lot of burping (unusual for me) when I first went gluten-free. When I stopped eating gluten-free bread and bagels, which had brown rice flour, the burping stopped. Then, we I felt so bad after eating the pasta, I put two and two together. I've kept a food diary the last 5 weeks, which is helping me figure all this out. (

I think I will try it again in 6 months and hope it's a temporary intolerance. I'm doing a FODMAP diet since I react to high levels of fructose and am not sure what else, so it's going to take me a LONG time to cycle through new foods anyway! LOL!

gf-soph Apprentice

A lot of people with fodmap problems can't tolerate brown rice, myself included. It's been tested safe for fodmaps but some people think they react to the small amount of fructans.

Are you a member of the yahoo group 'fructose malabsorption australia'? If not, they are a great resource.

sreese68 Enthusiast

A lot of people with fodmap problems can't tolerate brown rice, myself included. It's been tested safe for fodmaps but some people think they react to the small amount of fructans.

Are you a member of the yahoo group 'fructose malabsorption australia'? If not, they are a great resource.

I am a member of that group, thanks! I just thought i'd get the celiac point of view. :) I met with a dietician last night, and she's encouraging me to start testing foods and see how it goes.

I really look forward to the cookbooks I ordered and the flours. It's hard to make the kids gluten-free bread from the mixes I have and not be able to try it!!

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):



  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      128,817
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748

    Charisse25
    Newest Member
    Charisse25
    Joined

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):


  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.1k
    • Total Posts
      71.2k

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):





  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):



  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • Iris Kraft
      I do not use menthol lozenge, but I have found a brand of oral probiotics that has same ingredients as Prodentim but without spending $50  bottle. I bought Naturewise Oral probiotics from Amazon at $29 a bottle for 50 chewables instead of the 30 qty. The Simbicort upset the bacteria is my mouth, had white tongue and created a dental problem with a tooth, plus the inflammation in throat, vocal cords. Used the chewable and rested it along the gum where tooth hurts 4 x on Monday. Tuesday, went to dentist and she looked at what I thought was my problem tooth and she said all looked pink and happy. No problem.  Also, I spoke with my Allergist and he said instead of two puffs am and pm, try one puff only in am.Can always add one puff in PM if needed. Rinse mouth twice and gargle twice, and brush tongue. Use the Rescue inhaler Albuterol if needed (which I didn't need to). Know that Flucasolone, Simbicort, Advair are interchangeable.
    • Ann13
      I have the exact same symptoms for a couple of wks now but I've been taking Symbicort for quite awhile at this point. I read you can get yeast infection in the vocal cords so I may ask my Dr. for antifungal meds cos I cant wait for an ENT exam. Also read on this site the connection between Vit D and K2 deficiency and asthma...doesn't apply to me cos mine is from mold in a house years ago but still might try and see if my asthma improves. I am Celiac and gluten causes the same symptoms but it says this inhaler is gluten free and it only started acting up so that option is out. I use Ventolin on occasion but using that for many many years. For me I will see if can switch inhalers to a brand that doesn't affect vocal cords as much, Advair is NOT one of them, plus will try the supplements. Do not suck on menthol lozenges cos menthol dries out cords more...sleeping elevated and sucking on ice chips gets the swelling down...at night this can really help especially. I can't continue like this so will get on everything this coming week.  
    • Rhenriksen
      Did a little more research just now and found out that even though the max methane should not exceed 10. It is normal to be around 3 and not rise. Again, I was at 13 so this does make me a bit suspicious. This was done back in May of 2024. I do recall being put on 14 day Antibiotic called Rifaximin but I'm really not sure if it made a difference, but if it did, then the problems still came back:( 
    • Rhenriksen
      I did a SIBO Test about a year ago, and I barely elevated on the Methane portion (max was 10 and I hit 13). Dr wasn't too concerned.    
    • trents
      Have you looked into SIBO (Small Intestine Bacterial Overgrowth)?  Also, MCAS (Mast Cell Activation Syndrome)/histamine intolerance (they go together like a hand and glove).  Both of the above are common in the celiac community.
×
×
  • Create New...