Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):

    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Negative Biopsy

shadowicewolf

Recommended Posts

shadowicewolf Proficient
shadowicewolf
Posted

I had my endo yesterday and the GI doc called today to tell me that the biopsy was negative and that he didn't think i had celiac and that i could go back to eating everything again.

I don't agree with him. Pretty much all of my symptoms coinside with Celiac as did my blood work. Yet he wants me to go back to eating gluten? <_< He said at my consultation that if it came back negative he would do further testing, but at this time he doesn't believe i have it due to the fact that my insides looked 'normal' (with the exception of my throat which was really irritated/inflamed).

Furthermore he wants to just say that i have acid reflux and IBS. Ugh.

I go in on monday for an ultrasound due to the fact that my abdomen keeps hurting.

He said he wanted to get to the bottom of my issues to figure out whats going on.

But what i don't understand is why change my diet now (i'm seriously considering not doing that, due to how it made me feel before)?

I'm just so frustrated and not feeling well and ugh. :(

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


Skylark Collaborator
Skylark
Posted

If you have celiac bloodwork and a negative biopsy, there is some research supporting your thoughts that a gluten-free diet is a good idea. Developing celiac seems to be a process, starting with the TTG antibodies and progressing to villous atrophy. There was a study where they found people with anti-TTG but a normal endoscopy still had a metabolic profile that was the same as celiacs. I'd usually link the study, but I'm so dratted brain-fogged myself today that I can't find it.

Get your own copy of the biopsy report too. Doctors don't usually diagnose biopsies with only lymphocytic infiltration as celiac as it can happen for other reasons, but with a positive celiac panel it's a smoking gun.

I'd encourage you to listen to your body too. There is no harm in trying the diet strictly now that your tests are done. Your GI does not control what you put in your mouth. B)

By the way, watch your reactions to soy and milk carefully too. Lots of celiacs don't tolerate them, especially while you're healing.

kareng Grand Master
kareng
Posted

Did he just do 1 biopsy? There is a lot of small intestine, would be easy to miss the 50% that is damaged & get a piece of good intestine.

I would definitely ask for a copy of the pathology report (biopsy), op report and the blood work. Make sure you got done what you think you had done.

He got the biopsy report back the next day? That's quick. Look at the actual report.

shadowicewolf Proficient
shadowicewolf
Posted
  • Author

Alright i'll try to get a hold of the actual report (i meet with him again on monday so i'm sure that i can get it then).

That was my thought as well. You have about 20ft of small intestans there is a big chance of a miss right there.

Also the fact that i have been gluten free for 4 weeks. I told him this and he said it should be a problem :blink:

ravenwoodglass Mentor
ravenwoodglass
Posted

Alright i'll try to get a hold of the actual report (i meet with him again on monday so i'm sure that i can get it then).

That was my thought as well. You have about 20ft of small intestans there is a big chance of a miss right there.

Also the fact that i have been gluten free for 4 weeks. I told him this and he said it should be a problem :blink:

Your being gluten free for four weeks would likely cause a false negative on the biopsy. If being on the diet for 4 weeks gave you a bit of improvement and you had positive blood tests you might want to suggest to your doctor that instead of doing a challenge and rebiopsying perhaps you could go back to gluten free and see if your positive blood test becomes negative and you symptoms improve after 3 to 6 months. If for some reason you need a 'formal' diagnosis perhaps that might get you one?

maximoo Enthusiast
maximoo
Posted

Altho there is 20+ ft of intestine the pediatric GI told me he only takes samples from a 6 in area--that the endocope doesn't go around all those tightly wound twists & turns. Another procedure/test is needed to test any further into the intestines, & is usually not recommended. (well for kids anyway)

How many samples did your GI take & was it in a 6 in length of intestines as well? You should ask. Maybe you can suggest he take a stool sample & run lots of tests on it. Im sure some info could be obtained from that.

Stay gluten-free if it helps you.

shadowicewolf Proficient
shadowicewolf
Posted
  • Author

I became gluten free after the blood test.

Now that the doctor said that both my grandmother and mother think i should go back on gluten... and they believe every word he said. Sorry but just because you didn't see anything doesn't mean its not possibly there.

If it were the case that i could go back on gluten, why the heck did i test positive on the blood test <_<

Just so annoying :(

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


shadowicewolf Proficient
shadowicewolf
Posted
  • Author

Altho there is 20+ ft of intestine the pediatric GI told me he only takes samples from a 6 in area--that the endocope doesn't go around all those tightly wound twists & turns. Another procedure/test is needed to test any further into the intestines, & is usually not recommended. (well for kids anyway)

How many samples did your GI take & was it in a 6 in length of intestines as well? You should ask. Maybe you can suggest he take a stool sample & run lots of tests on it. Im sure some info could be obtained from that.

Stay gluten-free if it helps you.

I'm not sure how many he did. I will ask when i see him on monday.

mushroom Proficient
mushroom
Posted

I can only reiterate what others have said. Gluten free for four weeks definitely could be a problem. Doctors are incredibly blase about this. Just as is their lack of belief in non-celiac gluten intolerance. Celiac is NOT the beginning and end of gluten intolerance and if eating gluten free makes you feel better, do it. Your dietary choice has nothing to do with your doctor's opinion, it is something you do of your own volition.

I also agree with ravenwood that testing your blood later and getting a negative would be just as diagnostic as a positive biopsy, as far as gluten's influence on your body. And the way I read it, the reason you have acid reflux and an irritable bowel is due to the havoc gluten is causing.

Meg123 Explorer
Meg123
Posted

Your being gluten free for four weeks would likely cause a false negative on the biopsy. If being on the diet for 4 weeks gave you a bit of improvement and you had positive blood tests you might want to suggest to your doctor that instead of doing a challenge and rebiopsying perhaps you could go back to gluten free and see if your positive blood test becomes negative and you symptoms improve after 3 to 6 months. If for some reason you need a 'formal' diagnosis perhaps that might get you one?

That is such a great idea :D . I think I might do that too if mine comes back negative ;) . I wonder why Gi's and GP's don't do that themselves, it seems so obvious.

ravenwoodglass Mentor
ravenwoodglass
Posted

That is such a great idea :D . I think I might do that too if mine comes back negative ;) . I wonder why Gi's and GP's don't do that themselves, it seems so obvious.

I does seem obvious doesn't it and there are some that do diagnose based on the combo of positive blood and recovery on the diet. Hopefully more will start.

I show negative on blood tests and was too sick from the second challenge to go to the biopsy. I was diagnosed based on my 'miraculous' recovery off gluten and my extemely bad reaction to the challenges. My new GI, not the one who demanded the second challenge that, not to exaggerate almost killed me, with a GI bleed, states that he puts anyone suggestive of celiac on the diet for 6 months after the biopsy no matter what the results as false negatives are unfortunately common.

Roda Rising Star
Roda
Posted

Your being gluten free for four weeks would likely cause a false negative on the biopsy. If being on the diet for 4 weeks gave you a bit of improvement and you had positive blood tests you might want to suggest to your doctor that instead of doing a challenge and rebiopsying perhaps you could go back to gluten free and see if your positive blood test becomes negative and you symptoms improve after 3 to 6 months. If for some reason you need a 'formal' diagnosis perhaps that might get you one?

Didn't do a scope/biopsy for my youngest son. I am going to see if I can get his blood drawn soon (it's been a litle over 6 months gluten free) and see if his ttg is negative now. I'm going to have it sent to the same lab so everthing is the same (ref. ranges). Hopefully with everything, positive ttg, good response gluten free, bad response when we reintroduced gluten for only 3 days, my diagnosis and if his repeat blood work is negative, that is enough for an official diagnosis.

shadowicewolf Proficient
shadowicewolf
Posted
  • Author

Why would my blood tests be positive and my GI doctor just, pretty much, blow it off by saying "well most people score high on the TISSUE TRANSGLUTAMINASE AB IGA" (as a 37 no less)? My mom agrees with the doctor because he 'couldn't find any sign of it on the biopsy' and my grandmother thinks i ate too much gluteny foods before the test :blink: (more like one or two small pieces of bread a day and a bunch of salad stuff).

Any ideas on how to bring up further testing from the GI doctor? (i need to have an official diagnosis for school reasons).

kareng Grand Master
kareng
Posted

Why would my blood tests be positive and my GI doctor just, pretty much, blow it off by saying "well most people score high on the TISSUE TRANSGLUTAMINASE AB IGA" (as a 37 no less)? My mom agrees with the doctor because he 'couldn't find any sign of it on the biopsy' and my grandmother thinks i ate too much gluteny foods before the test :blink: (more like one or two small pieces of bread a day and a bunch of salad stuff).

Any ideas on how to bring up further testing from the GI doctor? (i need to have an official diagnosis for school reasons).

Did you get a copy of everything yet?

Take it to a " regular" doctor. Maybe he/ she will diagnose you based on the blood tests and a good response to gluten-free.

shadowicewolf Proficient
shadowicewolf
Posted
  • Author

Did you get a copy of everything yet?

Take it to a " regular" doctor. Maybe he/ she will diagnose you based on the blood tests and a good response to gluten-free.

I did :( thats how i got my original diagnosis (and i got a letter from that). However, it is somewhat important to 'convince' my mom and grandma to accept it and also validating my original diagnosis. Right now they are all like 'if you eat a little bit it won't hurt you'. :blink:

I will get a copy when i go to the doc next friday.

I have to go in for an ultrasound on my abdomen on monday. IF they don't find anything would that somehow further support my 'celiac' diagnosis?

ravenwoodglass Mentor
ravenwoodglass
Posted

I did :( thats how i got my original diagnosis (and i got a letter from that). However, it is somewhat important to 'convince' my mom and grandma to accept it and also validating my original diagnosis. Right now they are all like 'if you eat a little bit it won't hurt you'. :blink:

I will get a copy when i go to the doc next friday.

I have to go in for an ultrasound on my abdomen on monday. IF they don't find anything would that somehow further support my 'celiac' diagnosis?

Yes IMHO it would. Also since you had a positive blood test your GP may 'officially diagnose' you after you have had some time strict on the diet and have recovered from your issues. More doctors are becoming aware of false negatives on biopsy and will diagnose based on positive blood work, recovery on the diet and negative blood work after a time gluten free and reoccurance of symptoms if we get glutened.

LivesIntheSun Apprentice
LivesIntheSun
Posted

Did the doctor take an IEL count? New research shows that this is more indicative of celiac disease then villious atrophy.

Open Original Shared Link

Open Original Shared Link

They also talk about it on this interview-

Open Original Shared Link

I have been gluten free for 4 years although I still fell pretty unwell (nothing compared to before though). I was told by the doctor that after all ths time but with periodic glutenings I am almost certain to have elevated IELs and that this along with my case history would be sufficient for a diagnosis.

Good luck!

Skylark Collaborator
Skylark
Posted

Why would my blood tests be positive and my GI doctor just, pretty much, blow it off by saying "well most people score high on the TISSUE TRANSGLUTAMINASE AB IGA" (as a 37 no less)? My mom agrees with the doctor because he 'couldn't find any sign of it on the biopsy' and my grandmother thinks i ate too much gluteny foods before the test :blink: (more like one or two small pieces of bread a day and a bunch of salad stuff).

Any ideas on how to bring up further testing from the GI doctor? (i need to have an official diagnosis for school reasons).

Unfortunately, there is no further testing. Blood and biopsy are it. You to get strong support from your GP. Most people do NOT score high on tTG; only people with autoimmune diseases do. The one thing you could do is go strictly gluten-free and show the tTG antibodies falling.

You need to stay strong and refuse gluten. Hopefully when your family sees you feeling better they will humor you if nothing else.

shadowicewolf Proficient
shadowicewolf
Posted
  • Author

Unfortunately, there is no further testing. Blood and biopsy are it. You to get strong support from your GP. Most people do NOT score high on tTG; only people with autoimmune diseases do. The one thing you could do is go strictly gluten-free and show the tTG antibodies falling.

You need to stay strong and refuse gluten. Hopefully when your family sees you feeling better they will humor you if nothing else.

There is one where they look foor the 'genetic' component of celiac i think.

Skylark Collaborator
Skylark
Posted

There is one where they look foor the 'genetic' component of celiac i think.

The genetic tests are mostly worthless. 30% of the US population has a so-called celiac gene (DQ2 or DQ8). Even worse, there are plenty of people without a so-called celiac gene who are celiac by blood and biopsy. If you happen to come up double-DQ2.5 you might have an argument based on the genetics but even then it's not diagnostic.

psawyer Proficient
psawyer
Posted

The genetic tests are mostly worthless. 30% of the US population has a so-called celiac gene (DQ2 or DQ8). Even worse, there are plenty of people without a so-called celiac gene who are celiac by blood and biopsy. If you happen to come up double-DQ2.5 you might have an argument based on the genetics but even then it's not diagnostic.

What she said. Only 1% of the population, or 1 in 30 with the so-called celiac gene, actually develop the disease. US medicine is just beginning to recognize that people without either of those markers can also develop celiac disease. Europe is way ahead on that front.

shadowicewolf Proficient
shadowicewolf
Posted
  • Author

ah :( well maybe i can get that blood test redone again or something.

I'm sick of being told "well the doctor said you can have it" <_< Fyi, i was diagnosed gluten intolerent by a nurse practitioner and celiac by my GP. Hmmm.... no gluten from two one yes from the GI. Sorry, but gluten free rules out here.

Can ya tell how frustrating this is? -sigh-

(sorry for the rant)

mushroom Proficient
mushroom
Posted

Well, I think you are just going to have to go gluten free, and feel better :)

Skylark Collaborator
Skylark
Posted

It sounds terribly frustrating. I take it you are still living with your family.

Stick to your guns! Going off gluten can help some of the other things in your signature like the Asperger's and stress issues too. Maybe if your family sees you improving they'll listen.

shadowicewolf Proficient
shadowicewolf
Posted
  • Author

thank you for the support. It helps :)

I sure hope it does. I think i ate something last night that didn't agree with me and caused me to have that damn burning/numb feeling again (similar to what i had before going gluten free). I also think it was the reason i had a panic attack last night :blink: but i double checked everything (including the bbq sauce i had, website stated it was gluten free). I'm starting to think that was the cause.

Not fun not fun. Hopefully i'll have some answers this next week.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):


  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      128,183
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    recipe
    Newest Member
    recipe
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.1k
    • Total Posts
      70.7k
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):


  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • Wheatwacked
      Testing

      By Wheatwacked · Posted

      Once you have removed the inflammatories, it is time to focus on the deficiencies.  A lot of them not specific to Celiac, but deficiency in them elicits symptoms associated with Celiac. According to research, celiac disease tends to be more prevalent in urban areas compared to rural areas.  Same is true with airborne viruses.  Because urban residents get less sunlight.  To top it off we use lotion and gear to block the little light there is.  This compremises the vitamin D blood level.  A virus attack further lowers vitamin D and the immune system loses control over the Celiac genes and they go into acute symptoms. 40% to 75% depending depending on country are vitamin D deficient. 50% do not eat the Adequit Intake for potassium (4700 mg a day) 90% do n ot eat the Adequit Intake for Choline. Iodine intake since 1970 had dropped 50%.  The western diet is typically excessive in omega 6 fatty acid compared to omega 3.  Above 14:1 by some estimates.  So they sell us expensive, processed oils to compensate.  Anyway after 10 years gluten free myself,  here is what has helped me in just the past few years; once I realized I was at a healing plateau and just GFD would not cut it, and reallized my deficiencies.  Most recently, I started a statin which I only took for two weeks before it started to cripple me.   Got a prescription for Nicotinic Acid to 2000 and am more flexible now Plus HDL went 29 to 44, eGFR from 55 to 79. I also learned if the pharmacist gets a prescription for Niacin that it is dealer's choice whether you get Nicotinic Acid or Niacinimide.  And it comes out of a regular vitamin manufacturer.   "likely deficiencies and what I take to boost my intake (I get anorexic at the drop of a hat so I take them to keep me stable):  the ones that helped me the most noticibly Was increasing vitamin D blood level to 80 ng/ml and Iodine to 500 mcg once or twice a day, Thiamine, Choline, and Iodine. 10,000 IU vitamin D 500 mg Thiamine or more Choline Iodine – 600 to 1200 mcg of Liquid Iodine Vitamin B2 helps break down proteins, fats, and carbohydrates. It plays a vital role in maintaining the body's energy supply.  500 mg Nicotinic Acid - increase capillary blood flow, lower cholesterol. I recently started 2000 mg a day instead of a statin which I cannot tolerate. I the first month my HDL went from 29 to 44. eGFR (kidney function) jumped from 55 ti 75. It also has make my whole body less stiff. The ichy, flushing with the first few doses goes away. The non flush forms of vitamin B3 do not work. It is the relaxing of the capillaries and tendons. 500 mg Pantothenic Acid vitamin B5 Omega-3 and Omega-6 Fatty Acids in Vegetables  Eating more of the vegetables low in omega six and high omega 3 can reduce inflammation Whole Milk Vanilla yogurt to which I add 100 grams of raspberrys, black berries and blueberries has lots of probiotics and makes my tummy and body happy. Red Bull has sugar (not high fructose corn syrup) and the vitamins (B2,3,5,6 need to metabolize to ATP energy and Taurine as an antioxident). It is a good source of energy for me because my genetic hyperlipidemia does not process complex carbs well.        
    • trents
      For people with celiac disease and corn intolerance from it: Is salt still okay for most people?

      By trents · Posted

      Gluten-like cross reactions to other foods are from the proteins that make them up. Dextrose is the sugar component found in corn.
    • Ryangf
      For people with celiac disease and corn intolerance from it: Is salt still okay for most people?

      By Ryangf · Posted

      I just found out a few days ago that some salt like table salt contains dextrose that’s derived from corn. I’ve been thinking about getting rid of using table salt and just using my own kosher or Himalayan salt, but tbh I’m reluctant to do it. I’ve cut out a lot of things and I don’t really want to cut out anything else that I’m not sure will effect me…in a super small amount that it might be added to salts to stabilize the iodine. I don’t want to be further alienated when I have to go to a restaurant with my friends. Also most of the items at my house that have salt in it canned food etc. are some of the few quick things I can eat- because I’m not the one paying for the food in my household and i can only ask for so much. I’m not in a place financially where I can get a lot of my specialized items- although my family tries their best to get items I Can actually stand. I get I can bring a my own salt with me at a restaurant and ask for no seasoning but it feels like a lot to me- cause I already check for cross contamination and ask if the food has like a high volume of corn in it like cornstarch etc. I’ve also heard most dextrose is not derived from the Zein (corn gluten) portion of it- so it might be safe- but idk if that’s true. I just wanna know if anyone actually responded to it negatively.
    • Scott Adams
      I’m so confused…

      By Scott Adams · Posted

      For my first couple of years after discovering my celiac disease I also had to avoid cow's milk/casein and eggs, as well as other things, but could tolerate duck eggs and sheep and goat's milk products. I'm not sure if you've tried those, but it could be worth testing them out.
    • knitty kitty
      I’m so confused…

      By knitty kitty · Posted

      Hello, @Kwinkle, How are you doing?   Have you tried adding a Magnesium supplement?   The B Complex vitamins need magnesium to work properly, especially thiamine vitamin B 1.   Magnesium deficiency symptoms and Thiamine deficiency symptoms both include gas and bloating.  Thiamine deficiency symptoms also include loss of appetite and fatigue.   My gas and bloating resolved rather quickly when I took Benfotiamine (a form of thiamine shown to promote intestinal healing) and Magnesium Glycinate in addition to my B 50 Complex (all twice a day plus the following...).   I found Magnesium L-Threonate or Magnesium Taurate are better when taken with a form of thiamine called TTFD (Tetrahydrofurfuryl dusulfide) because all of these cross the blood brain barrier easily, which corrects the loss of appetite, fatigue and anxiety.    Like @Celiacandme said, keeping a food/mood/poo'd journal is a big help in finding problematic foods, and for making sure your diet is not carbohydrate heavy.  If you're eating a lot if processed gluten free facsimile foods, be aware they do not have vitamins and minerals added to them like their gluten containing counterparts.  For every 1000 kcal of carbohydrates, we need an extra 500 mg of thiamine to turn them into energy and not store them as fat.   Let us know how you're doing!
×
×
  • Create New...