Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×
  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.




  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):



    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):


  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Newly Diagnosed?


Merriweather

Recommended Posts

Merriweather Newbie

My blood tests came back positive and my biopsy showed an increase in immune cells in my small intestine but no vilious atrophy. According to my doctor I have celiac disease but based on information I've been reading there seems to be conflicting opinions about a diagnosis without vilious atrophy. Does anyone have more information about this?


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



rosetapper23 Explorer

Yes, one of the leading experts on celiac disease, Dr. Alessio Fassano, believes that a positive endoscopic biopsy should no longer be considered the gold standard for diagnosing celiac disease. If your bloodwork was positive, you can be certain that you have celiac disease (false positives are rare). Be thankful that your celiac was diagnosed before too much damage occurred.

Merriweather Newbie

Thanks for your feedback. I've been struggling with IBS for 15 plus years and was happy to finally have some answers besides doctors just telling me I have IBS. I didn't realize how confusing the diagnosis process is....I just wonder if a different GI dr. looked at my biopsy results would he/she have a different diaganosis?

rosetapper23 Explorer

Actually, Dr. Fasano cites a number of things that can skew a biopsy: 1) the scope wasn't long enough to reach the damaged area, 2) the surgeon was not skilled enough at taking samples, 3) the pathologist lacked the skill or competence to diagnose celiac, 4) even if a large number of samples were biopsied, it's possible that the surgeon did not biopsy the areas with villous atrophy, and 5) probably a number of other factors that I can't remember. From a study I read recently, the chances of getting a correctly sampled and read biopsy at a standard clinic or hospital are pretty low but accuracy increases at teaching hospitals and universities. There are so many variables that can go wrong, biopsies can be pretty much worthless.

Merriweather Newbie

As a follow up, I met with my primary care doctor this week and according to her, my diagnosis is not a "slam dunk", meaning all test results "suggest celiac disease" due to the positive blood work and increase of intraepithelial lymphocytes from my biopsy, but because there's no vilous atrophy it's not a diagnosis of 100%. Even though other autoimmune diseases were ruled out, I have onogoing GI issues and a history of vitamin deficiences and low iron. This all confuses me even more so because when my GI doc gave me the results he said that I definitely have celiac disease, even when I questioned that the biopsy results only showed an increase in IELs. It just seems like there are many differing opinions on this. Do others have the same confusion I'm experiencing? I guess I'm going with what my GI doctor said, but I still have some doubts due to the biopsy result. I've had horrible GI symptoms for many years, so shouldn't this have been reflected in the amount damage to my small intestine?

mushroom Proficient

The increase in IEL's is one of the precursors to villous atrophy. Inflammation is another. There are varying stages in the progression of intestinal damage. The old standard required for total or subtotal villous atrophy, the equivalent of III on the Marsh scale of I - IV before they would diagnose. Doctors seem a little more enlightened these days and realize that you don't have to wait until somebody is really damaged that badly to make a diagnosis. I would go with your GI's opinion rather your PCP since he has more experience in such things. :)

Takala Enthusiast
I've had horrible GI symptoms for many years, so shouldn't this have been reflected in the amount damage to my small intestine?

Not necessarily, as strange as it may seem. The intestines are quite long and the damage is patchy.... they are looking for the atrophy in the haystack, so to speak. Plus, you can be reacting to different foods in addition to gluten - and some or all of this may go away after going gluten free, or sometimes one discovers additional intolerances. People may think they can't digest fats, when in reality, their livers and gall bladders are very wonky from consuming gluten. Eliminate gluten, and the ability to digest some fats may return. People may have a lot of trouble digesting any sort of starch derived from non gluten grains, either temporarily or permanently. I had no idea flax would do a number on me, until I kept running into gluten free baked goods with that as an ingredient. There was no reason for me to eat flax in the first place, I had tasted it and thought "nasty, bitter." Yet a lot of recipes have it, and I can tell people how to use it as an egg substitute, just leave it out of my food, thank you. Other ingredients which can disagree with celiacs/gluten intolerants include soy flours and the lactose in dairy products.

Fine tuning the gluten free diet can take awhile sorting out what does and does not agree with you at first.

I was not "confused" as I knew "for sure" I had a food problem, it was the medical profession which was being contradictory - it has been over a decade since I started to try getting diagnosed ( !!! ), I've done enough experimenting on my diet that I know, and I have had atypical symptoms for most of my adult life. Eventually, I had a brain scan which showed bright spots. I still do not "officially" have my disease, but the other problem was that we moved cross country in the late '90's and went into a different form of insurance... I think my old GP in the former state, who was very sharp, may have eventually caught this, but I was rather shocked at some of the deliberately incompetent responses I had when taking my other auto immune issues first into the HMO - these so called non profit orgs are nothing but rip offs. Good riddance. Current GP/PCP accepts that at least I am gluten intolerant because of the mysterious way I now been "cured" of several other problems since the Diet Change.


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



rosetapper23 Explorer

Your primary doctor is obviously not an expert on celiac, so I would disregard what she has said. Because there are so very few "experts" on this disease, you can pretty much take it to the bank when someone like Dr. Fasano says that a biopsy is not necessary. He's tried to convince many a doctor that the old gold standard simply no longer applies. If you have symptoms that resolve on a gluten-free diet, positive bloodwork, and positive genes, you do NOT even need to have a biopsy. Since your biopsy showed something amiss, I don't see how there could be any question that you have celiac disease.

I know it's confusing...but it's the doctors who are confused.

faithforlife Apprentice

Biopsies in our families were similar. But our GI says even if it's the beginning if celiac, it's still celiac. Our bloodwork and genetic testing is enough to verify. And how we feel gluten-free. But I still struggle with doubts it's more emotional. I have to work through letting it sink in. It's only been a year since we began the process of testing etc.

Skylark Collaborator

As a follow up, I met with my primary care doctor this week and according to her, my diagnosis is not a "slam dunk", meaning all test results "suggest celiac disease" due to the positive blood work and increase of intraepithelial lymphocytes from my biopsy, but because there's no vilous atrophy it's not a diagnosis of 100%. Even though other autoimmune diseases were ruled out, I have onogoing GI issues and a history of vitamin deficiences and low iron. This all confuses me even more so because when my GI doc gave me the results he said that I definitely have celiac disease, even when I questioned that the biopsy results only showed an increase in IELs. It just seems like there are many differing opinions on this. Do others have the same confusion I'm experiencing? I guess I'm going with what my GI doctor said, but I still have some doubts due to the biopsy result. I've had horrible GI symptoms for many years, so shouldn't this have been reflected in the amount damage to my small intestine?

Did you ask your primary care doctor just how sick you have to get before she'll stop practicing poor medicine and diagnose you? I mean really, does she want you to wait until you have total villous atrophy? You are very fortunate to have a GI who is reading the latest research. Increased IEL is the first phase of celiac disease and the latest thinking is that positive bloodwork plus increased IEL is definitely celiac disease.

Merriweather Newbie

Thanks for all your feedback....everyone here is so helpful!

I got a copy of my pathology report with the following:

Duodenum biopsy: duodenal mucosa with normal villous architecture and increased intaepithelial lymphocytes. See note.

Note: Villous architecture is essentially preserved. The differential diagnosis includes gluten sensitivity or family history of gluten sensitivity, tropicalsprue, post viral gastroenteritis, bacterial overgrowth, allergy to other antigens and immunodeficiency syndromes (CVID, IgA defiency) these features have also been described in patients with a history of crohn's disease (Modern Path 2002).

When I talked to my GI doctor he said that based on my positive tTG and biopsy results I definitely have celiac. I'm just confused with this path report because the note doesn't really clarify a diagnosis....any thoughts?

kareng Grand Master

Looks like you got lucky and were diagnosed before too much damage was done. Also possible that they took 4 microscopic biospies of 16 feet of small intestine and missed the worst spots.

Skylark Collaborator

I don't understand why you are fighting a celiac diagnosis so hard. Don't you want to be rid of the horrible GI symptoms? You have a chance to change everything here! :) Have you gone gluten-free? Are you feeling better? That will be the final proof for you, when years of GI symptoms melt away over the next few months.

Your GI is looking at the whole picture, symptoms, blood tests, early celiac biopsy. He's looking from the perspective of a doctor who has probably seen a lot of cases of celiac disease and he has obviously kept well up-to-date on the celiac research. Doctors don't diagnose on a single test; they take all the information before them into account.

Merriweather Newbie

@skylark - It might come across that I'm fighting the diagnosis, but I guess I was just hoping for more conclusive results from my biopsy - given the terrible GI symptoms I've had for years, I thought the biopsy would either show no damage or a lot oh damage, but maybe that's just my misunderstanding of all of this. I'm definitely going with the diagnosis from my GI doc and have been gluten free for a little over a week now. I've been feeling ok so far, but time will tell to see if there's an impact over time. My dr Tod me I can have IBS along with celiac, so we shall see if eating gluten free is the answer. I certainly hope so!!!

Skylark Collaborator

@skylark - It might come across that I'm fighting the diagnosis, but I guess I was just hoping for more conclusive results from my biopsy - given the terrible GI symptoms I've had for years, I thought the biopsy would either show no damage or a lot oh damage, but maybe that's just my misunderstanding of all of this.

Let me put it in perspective. It's HARD to get positive results on celiac tests, even when you know gluten is half-killing you. There are people on this board who have paid $300 and up for alternative, unvalidated fecal tests or genetic testing their insurance wouldn't cover because their blood tests were negative and they KNEW they couldn't eat gluten.

Ten years ago, someone had to not only have antibodies, but chronic diarrhea, horrible villous atrophy, and be pretty much wasting away before they would be diagnosed as celiac. Celiac wouldn't even be suspected without massive weight loss from malabsorption because it was considered rare. Turns out what is rare is a Marsh 3 or 4 biopsy, not celiac disease. Lots of people like you stayed miserable because their doctors would say they didn't have celiac disease. Now doctors are diagnosing on antibodies and increased IEL because they've realized that developing villous atrophy can be a gradual process, and because people with earlier signs of celiac get dramatically healthier on a gluten-free diet. It's good medicine. :)

You do realize the epithelial lymphocytes are the ones that do the autoimmune celiac damage, right? That's a fairly new piece to the puzzle, figured out within the last five years or so. Your autoimmune antibodies have called natural killer cells to your intestine and they are there to attack your villi. It's only a matter of time before they do their work and you end up with a severe biopsy, but you don't want to go there. :blink:

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Celiac.com:
    Donate

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):





    Celiac.com Sponsors (A17-M):




  • Recent Activity

    1. - trents replied to LynnM's topic in Gluten-Free Foods, Products, Shopping & Medications
      1

      Is "Shield" skincare products gluten-free?

    2. - LynnM posted a topic in Gluten-Free Foods, Products, Shopping & Medications
      1

      Is "Shield" skincare products gluten-free?

    3. - kopiq posted a topic in Post Diagnosis, Recovery & Treatment of Celiac Disease
      0

      almost a year in recovery - so many questions about to give up

    4. - Scott Adams replied to Trina Zee's topic in Introduce Yourself / Share Stuff
      1

      Need GI doctor referral

    5. - Trina Zee posted a topic in Introduce Yourself / Share Stuff
      1

      Need GI doctor referral


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):



  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      130,546
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748

    bethlama
    Newest Member
    bethlama
    Joined

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):


  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.3k
    • Total Posts
      1m

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):





  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):



  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • trents
      I see nothing in the ingredient list that concerns me from a gluten intolerant perspective. Historically, how has your 13 yr. old been treated for his acne? When I was a teenager I had acne issues (this was in the 1960s) and was put on a long term regimin of tetracycline. It helped the acne but I am convinced it altered my gut microbiome and contributed to the development of celiac disease.
    • LynnM
      Hello. My 13 YO son has celiac disease and terrible acne. Our older son, not celiac disease is using a product that is new on the mkt within the last few years called SHIELD. Body wash, cream and patches. Wonderful results. I contacted the Co and they were very helpful but definitely suggested we contact our G.I. specialist, I have done so but I have not heard back from her. Below is the correspondence with the company and I was wondering if anyone here could please tell me whether or not these ingredients are safe.     Hi Lynn, thank you for reaching out and for your interest in our products! To ensure transparency, here is the full list of ingredients used in our products. While we do not add gluten-containing ingredients, we always recommend reviewing the list below if you have sensitivities or allergies. Moisturizer Ingredients: Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Juice Squalane Hydroxyethyl Acrylate/Sodium Acryloyldimethyl Taurate Copolymer Niacinamide Chamomilla Recutita (Matricaria) Flower Extract Glycerin Butyrospermum Parkii (Shea) Oil Tetrahexyldecyl Ascorbate (Vitamin C) Phenoxyethanol Ethylhexylglycerine Face Wash Ingredients: Active: 4.0% Benzoyl Peroxide (Curoxyl-42) Inactive: Water Sodium C14-16 Alpha Olefin Sulfonate Propylene Glycol Cocamidopropyl Hydroxysultaine Glycerin Ceramide NP Ceramide AP Ceramide EOP Phytosphingosine Cholesterol Sodium Lauroyl Lactylate Carbomer Xanthan Gum Phenoxyethanol Niacinamide Sodium Hyaluronate Propanediol Glycolic Acid Tetrasodium EDTA Ethylhexylglycerin Pimple Patches: Hydrocolloid Body Wash Ingredients: Active: 4.0% Benzoyl Peroxide Inactive: Water Sodium C14-16 Olefin Sulfonate Cocamidopropyl Hydroxysultaine Propylene Glycol Sodium Hyaluronate Niacinamide Ceramide NP Ceramide AP Ceramide EOP Phytosphingosine Sodium Lauroyl Lactylate Propanediol Glycolic Acid Tetrasodium EDTA Sodium Hydroxide Carbomer Acrylates Copolymer Xanthan Gum Phenoxyethanol Ethylhexylglycerin If you have a gluten allergy, we recommend consulting your healthcare provider before use, just to be safe. Let me know if you have any other questions, I’m happy to help!
    • kopiq
      so im short a year of diagnosis this october. As soon as I was diagnosed i quit all gluten and relied on buckwheat and potatoes at times as my carb sources. Due to a power outage i could not eat buckwheat for a couple days, i felt better but when power was back on i ate buckwheat and felt sick, i soon cut it out of my diet.long story short I have developed psoriasis and cramping in my calves and feet, brutal cramping at that. I cut out rice and potatoes and corn and eggs as consuming them would make my psoriasis extremely itchy. I have only ate sweet poatoes and plantins for two months straight 5 to 6 times a day with no symptoms other than slow digestion of small intestine. I was also diagnosed with raynauds phenomenon recently. that's three auto immune diseases that i know about, I have constant belching from mouth even just eating chicken, Im so sick of sweet potatoes and plantains, i have no idea what to eat anymore.  the major trigger I have had with celiac is my nervous system, I was numb to everything and as I heal i have more sensation. I got sick with flu and covid during this time and I felt physically and mentally fine even though my wife was vomiting, i could feel the body aches and chills but was numb to feeling sick to my stomach. its like celiac masked the sensation which is scary cause if I was really sick with something serious I would not know it. Im at the point that im eating rice and potatoes even though it flares my psoriasis and causing inflammation and this numbness in my stomach genital area as my digestion get slower. I think im lacking enzymes but dont know for sure my dr has done so many blood tests for liver, pancreas, gall bladder, rheumatoid arthritis and thyroid all which she says comes back fine. I dont know what to do anymore, am i hurting my small intestine (villi) by eating eggs, rice and corn? they do flare my itch psoriasis and cause inflammation to the point of numbness in lower stomach genital area,  but is it affecting my villi? i need carbs, but all these grains effect my nervous system, I have so much gas from eating it affect my erections and sensations during sex, i havent had sexual arousal in almost a year, i only feel strong pressure and when it is over the pressure is gone and i have a lot of flatulence. its the strangest thing like something needs to relax down there and it relives pressure and gas. need help, my dr dosent know what to do. do i need immune suppressants?   thanks.
    • Scott Adams
      While I don’t have a specific personal recommendation, there are several ways to find a skilled GI doctor in Tucson who specializes in celiac disease. Check the Celiac Disease Foundation’s Healthcare Practitioner Directory for listed providers in Arizona: https://celiac.org/about-celiac-disease/find-a-healthcare-practitioner/ Also, local healthcare systems like Banner-University Medicine or El Rio Health may have gastroenterologists with celiac expertise—consider asking for referrals to doctors familiar with gluten-related disorders. When contacting potential doctors, ask about their experience with celiac diagnosis, follow-up protocols, and whether they work with dietitians.
    • Trina Zee
      Several years ago I attended a celiac group meeting in Tucson and I was referred to a doctor who was serving as the Celiac Group's resource for medical info.  He was very helpful to my situation (Dr Lindsey Pearson) but I understand that he's no longer in Tucson.  Can you tell me what doctor is working with your group now as I'm once again looking for a doctor.  Dr Pearson was a gi doc, fyi.
×
×
  • Create New...